Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New System Build > hideous underperformance of new gaming PC`

hideous underperformance of new gaming PC`

Forum Homebuilt Systems : New System Build - hideous underperformance of new gaming PC`

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

OK. I have a problem. I am a first time home system builder. The build seems to have gone OK (except for 1 thing - more of which later - i don't think this is the problem). I have fairly high spec BUT games (bioshock let alone crysis) are a slideshow on reasonable settings. My 3Dmark score is 1120 when comparable systems are 10 000 +.

Full system specs as follows:
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3
Intel Q6600
OCZ Technology 2x1GB PC2-6400 DDR2 Platinum
Inno3D 8800GT OC 512MB
Corsair 520 Watt, ATX, EPS12V, PS/2, Modular Power Supply
Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium 32-bit OEM DVD
Seagate Barracuda 7200.1 500GB 7200RPM S300 32MB
Gigabyte 3D II liquid cooling kit
standard dvd writer, monitor etc.

All non-3D applications seem to be working fine (e.g. web browser) so I am of the opinion there's a problem with my 8800GT that restricts its performance but doesn't fully kill it. The driver I have is up to date (forceware 169.25) and I have clean installed this with no impovement.

(Yes, the 8800GT does have an auxilliary 6-pin PCI power supply and this is plugged in. Looking at the GPU status in windows, the power state is D0 which I believe is normal and with no restrictions?)

Any suggestions would be appreciated - I am at my wits end :??:



PS - the one complication that occured was that in the 1st day of switching the system on for the 1st time, the controller for the fan on the Gigabyte 3D II liquid cooling kit went puff - literally, with a smell of ozone etc. However I believe that the problem was there before this happened with bad perfomance in bioshock. I returned it and re-installed the cooling system, with nothing else untoward happening.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

>>Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium 32-bit OEM DVD

Problem located, upgrade to XP.

Reply to snarfies1

Have you downloaded CPU-Z to see at what speed your 8800gt is running ? Some of the 8800gt's have some problems with some boards regarding the PCI-E lane speed. It seems some of them default to 1x lane speed instead of the standard 16x. This is due to the 8800gt being PCI-E 2.0 and the P35 motherboards are PCI-E 1.x. If that is your problem look on Gigabyte's website for a bios update. This would be the first thing I would check since your hardware config seems to be pretty good.

------------------------------ Intel Core i5 750 Asrock P55 Extreme 4GB OCZ DDR3-1333 BFG GTX275OC Benq 24" FP241vw Creative X-Fi Fatality pro OCZ Vertex 60gb 2x Seagate Sata2 500gb LG GGC H20L Blu-Ray/HDDVD TT Toughpower 650W Antec 1200
Reply to smartel7070

Yup, that sure explains a 9000 lower score.

Lets see, claims are 10-30% lower performance on Vista vs XP, gee that sure works out doesnt it Snarfies?

To the OP, do you have the system overclocked at all? Have you tried setting it back to original settings for testing?

Reply to Dooyas

smartel7070 wrote :

Have you downloaded CPU-Z to see at what speed your 8800gt is running ? Some of the 8800gt's have some problems with some boards regarding the PCI-E lane speed. It seems some of them default to 1x lane speed instead of the standard 16x. This is due to the 8800gt being PCI-E 2.0 and the P35 motherboards are PCI-E 1.x. If that is your problem look on Gigabyte's website for a bios update. This would be the first thing I would check since your hardware config seems to be pretty good.

 

According to CPU-Z the link width is indeed 16x.

 

very oddly though under the CPU tab when I started CPU-Z up this time, the multiplier is switching at random between 6 and 9 ( and hence core speed from 1600 to 2400 MHz). This was not happening when I have checked this on previous occasions!

 

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by chairmaker on 01-30-2008 at 10:30:20 PM
Reply to chairmaker

If anything i'd guess it was the pci-e lane(ing) not setup correctly. I've got 2x2900Pro's and i'm playing bioshock maxed out at 2048x1536. Haven't forced driver settings yet :P but it's been smooth the whole way through.

------------------------------ Latest Rig:
Q6600 OC 3.8 || Abit IX38 OC 2000 || 4x1GB DDR2-800 OC 1075 OCZ Ati Cert || 2x2900Pro OC 825/1800 || ABS Tagan ITZ 800w 20A 6 rails || 1TB HD Space || 21" CRT for 2048x1536 resolutions. Yummy. || XClio A380-PLUS: 2x250mm fan + 1x360mm fan
Reply to korsen

Dooyas wrote :

Yup, that sure explains a 9000 lower score.

Lets see, claims are 10-30% lower performance on Vista vs XP, gee that sure works out doesnt it Snarfies?

To the OP, do you have the system overclocked at all? Have you tried setting it back to original settings for testing?



No, I have not tried overclocking - I was aiming to get it working normally before cranking it up!

Reply to chairmaker

Ok then have you used speedfan to monitor your temps while running 3dmark ? The waterblock on your cpu could be mounted incorrectly if so your cpu would overheat and throttle itself to lower speeds so it won't fry. Could also be happening with your gpu block if you watercool the video card. I'll be back later tonite to check your progress.

------------------------------ Intel Core i5 750 Asrock P55 Extreme 4GB OCZ DDR3-1333 BFG GTX275OC Benq 24" FP241vw Creative X-Fi Fatality pro OCZ Vertex 60gb 2x Seagate Sata2 500gb LG GGC H20L Blu-Ray/HDDVD TT Toughpower 650W Antec 1200
Reply to smartel7070

snarfies1 wrote :

>>Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium 32-bit OEM DVD

Problem located, upgrade to XP.



Idiot

------------------------------ Amd x2 6400+ @ 3.5ghz | Ati 3870 | 3gb ram
Reply to vip3569

chairmaker wrote :

very oddly though under the CPU tab when I started CPU-Z up this time, the multiplier is switching at random between 6 and 9 ( and hence core speed from 1600 to 2400 MHz). This was not happening when I have checked this on previous occasions!

I'm sure it was, you just didn't notice it. That is C1E, it can be disabled in the BIOS but there is really no reason, because it's not your problem.

http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] multiplier


Reply to Zorg

Thanks for all your suggestions guys - really appreciate your help on this one.

 

Direct x - definitely running version 10

 

Regarding cpu temps - core temps tells me 34 - 38 degrees idle, only goes up a couple of degrees during and at the end of running 3DMark. No more than 43 for any core absolute max.

 

Zorg - thanks for the pointer re the multiplier.

 

any more suggestions? - i can't help feeling its something to do with the graphics card - are there any tools which can tell me if its running ok?


Message edited by chairmaker on 01-30-2008 at 11:29:37 PM
Reply to chairmaker

chairmaker wrote :


Inno3D 8800GT OC 512MB



A long time ago I had one 8800GTX that would run fine with the drivers that came from the factory but whenever I tried to upgrade the driver to any other version, the card would go into safe mode and run horribly slow.

Turns out the card had a bad voltage regulator that was being triggered by a the newer drivers. Apparently Nvidia thought no one would bother to upgrade their drivers or something?

If your card has a bad voltage regulator or something similar it will go into safe mode on boot up and run like crap. Sometimes I would get a pop up warning on boot up but not always.

Also try unplugging the card and moving it to another slot and see if that makes a difference.

------------------------------ Evga X58 3XSLI : i7 920 @ 4.2Ghz :GTX295+ x 2 :12GB XMS3 Dominator 8-8-8-21 1600 :XFi Fatal1ty:150GB WD VelociRaptor: 150GB Raptor: 4TB WD 32MB x4: Monsoon Vigor III: Lian Li P80 (black): BFG 1Kw PS: 37" Westinghouse 1080p 8ms :Vista64bit
Reply to warezme

I've got essentially the same problem. After a couple horrendous weeks of research, it's looking like it's a fairly common problem with the power supply. The cpu is not supplying power to the video card early enough in the boot cycle, and the card is then dialing down performance because it thinks it's underpowered. I'm waiting on an adapter from Enermax which is supposed to fix the issue. You may want to contact your PSU manufacturer, since it seems that many of them are aware of the issue (although they aren't all that forthcoming with admitting it's their problem).

If you do a quick search on "slow 8800gt psu" you'll find lots of answers.

Reply to StaggerLee

sorry - that should read "the psu is not supplying power ..."

Reply to StaggerLee

snarfies1 wrote :

>>Microsoft Windows Vista Home Premium 32-bit OEM DVD

Problem located, upgrade to XP.



way to be useless.

Anyways i use Vista ultimate though i dont have your card mine are factory OC'ed ignore my sig i now use Dual 3870 cards and i havent personaly had any performance issues in game.

I have never heard of the company that made your card. If it was me personaly i would return it and get a different brand that confines to the refference design. Like has been suggested reverse all over clocks as well. I would say make sure your power supply is really a 520Watt but i would find it hard to believe corsair would make a POS componant but then again i have no exp with thier power supplys.

------------------------------ M2R32-MVP Deluxe || Athlon 6400+ x2 || 8gig PC800 Corsair Expert
ATi Radeon 4870 x2 || Sound Blaster XFi Titanium
2 X 500gig 1 X 250gig Hitachi || 16x Pioneer DVD-RW - 16X DVD
Samsung 305t 30" LCD 2560x1600 || 1000watt enermax Galaxy
Reply to EnFoRceR22

Corsair PSUs are very good.

Download Rivatuner v2.06 and go under monitoring and tell us the results on the graph

------------------------------ Antec 1200|Antec Signature 850w|Asus Maximus II Formula|Q9650|4GB Dominator 1066|EVGA 9800GX2
Reply to Silverion77

Here's the link that explained it for me (assuming this is the psu issue)

http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/s [...] st10408472


And as for it being surprising that corsair would build a crappy unit, I would agree but I've got an Enermax Galaxy, which by all regards should be the best on the market, so I think this has hit across the board. Seeing the problems others are having with various models pretty much confirms it.

In my case the PSU was hugely rebated which is why I went with the 1000w model, and now I think I know the reason. When I compare the user manuals for the one that shipped with my unit versus the latest shipping model, they've now got a specific connector for the motherboard's PCI-e molex which wasn't there before, and I believe it's for precisely this problem.

Reply to StaggerLee

StaggerLee wrote :

Here's the link that explained it for me (assuming this is the psu issue)

http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/s [...] st10408472


And as for it being surprising that corsair would build a crappy unit, I would agree but I've got an Enermax Galaxy, which by all regards should be the best on the market, so I think this has hit across the board. Seeing the problems others are having with various models pretty much confirms it.

In my case the PSU was hugely rebated which is why I went with the 1000w model, and now I think I know the reason. When I compare the user manuals for the one that shipped with my unit versus the latest shipping model, they've now got a specific connector for the motherboard's PCI-e molex which wasn't there before, and I believe it's for precisely this problem.



StaggerLee - sounds like you have hit the frickin nail on the frickin head as the saying goes.

I will be taking this up with Corsair and/or the vendor. It seems madd ghey that PSU and GPU manufacturers haven't got together sooner to sort this 5H17 out.

Thanks so much for your help


Silverion - I have got RivaTuner 2.06 but can't see any monitoring or graphs??? possibly i'm being dumb...

Reply to chairmaker

clip on the arrow at the top half above driver settings. Then hit the picture that looks like movie film with a magnifying glass. That will bring up the monitoring

------------------------------ Antec 1200|Antec Signature 850w|Asus Maximus II Formula|Q9650|4GB Dominator 1066|EVGA 9800GX2
Reply to Silverion77

OK, results of the hardware monitoring from RivaTuner 2.06:

 

Graph 1 - Core Clock \ ROP domain, MHz: scale from 0 - 1500; @ 648 MHz
Graph 2 - Core Clock \ shader domain, MHz: scale from 0 - 1500; @ 1512 MHz - i.e. more than the graph allows, and has a warning sign on graph scale
Graph 3 - Memory clock, MHz: scale from 0 - 1500; @ 950.40 MHz
Graph 4 - Core Temperature, C: scale from 0 - 200; @ 50 MHz

 

These results are rock solid when running only firefox


Message edited by chairmaker on 01-31-2008 at 01:10:22 AM
Reply to chairmaker

Well those are right...the warning is just saying the scale is too small

Try doing a load test and tell me the results. Firefox isnt enough

------------------------------ Antec 1200|Antec Signature 850w|Asus Maximus II Formula|Q9650|4GB Dominator 1066|EVGA 9800GX2
Reply to Silverion77

i ran 3Dmark (generally running the various tests @ 2 - 5 FPS) and none of those graphs budged in the slightest - all flat horizontal lines

Reply to chairmaker

hows the CPU running?

------------------------------ Antec 1200|Antec Signature 850w|Asus Maximus II Formula|Q9650|4GB Dominator 1066|EVGA 9800GX2
Reply to Silverion77

It might be that your video acceleration is at software and not hardware.
On XP it would be right click on desktop -->properties-->settings-->Advanced-->Troubleshoot--> Drag the hardware acceleration to full.

Reply to dodian

rarely getting upto 50% overall during 3Dmark

Reply to chairmaker

Well, here's a depressing follow up...

My adapter from Enermax was waiting for me when I got home. It's basically an extension of the main ATX connector for the MB with a molex hanging off of it with 2 wires plugged into one of the molex pins.

I tried it out, and I'm still screwed. Maybe I'm missing something, so I'm going to follow up with Enermax but I could just have a bad video card (possibly the motherboard, but I doubt that). I just scored 1100 in 3DMark.

My problem aside - you could still be having the PSU issue, as it seems pretty common.

One thing you should check - are you getting the NVidia power warning when you boot? Most people are reporting that they get a message about the card lowering its performance because it's not getting enough power. I for one don't get that message, which may be indicative of a fried card instead of a PSU issue.

Lastly, I don't think I saw this posted as I scanned the thread...there are Vista hotfixes for game performance here:

http://www.nvidia.com/object/windo [...] fixes.html

One of them states that vista basically reserves FAR too little memory for directx and essentially starves the graphics system of memory. Funny that they couldn't see video cards and games consuming half a gig of memory when they were developing vista - only the most resource hogging OS of all time.

So, give that a shot. It did nothing for me, but maybe you'll fare better.

Reply to StaggerLee

Just a quick question. Did you install the motherboard drivers?

Reply to MrMr

MrMr wrote :

Just a quick question. Did you install the motherboard drivers?



I know I did...don't know about the OP. I think the P35 may also be part of the Vista install, but I can't remember exactly.

Either way, I had all the latest drivers ready when I installed. BIOSes are all updated, on the MB and Video card.

Also, in case it isn't clear...The rest of the system runs great. I didn't even notice the graphics problem for a week because I was busy overclocking the CPU, which is totally stable at 3.1 GHZ on stock voltage. The OP seems to be saying the same thing. I was so confident that I went ahead lapped my cpu and heatsink thinking I had a great system going, then went out and bought Crysis to see what I could really do with this box only to find that I was in the crapper.

Reply to StaggerLee

I think I have the answer for you. Bad video card. RMA and install new one. Recommend eVGA, BFG, or any other well-known brand. eVGA has a step-up program and is known for the best customer service.

------------------------------ e6700 (stock speed for now), Scythe Infinity HSF, Evga 680i, Evga 8800 GTX, Corsair 2 x 1 gig 6400c4, WD 150 gig 10,000 rpm, Thermaltake Toughpower 700W, Thermaltake Armor full tower case (black)
Reply to pongrules

He told us the graphics is running at the right clocks

------------------------------ Antec 1200|Antec Signature 850w|Asus Maximus II Formula|Q9650|4GB Dominator 1066|EVGA 9800GX2
Reply to Silverion77

MrMr - yes, mobo drivers installed a-ok AFAIK.

Silverion - you say the graphics are running at the right clocks. I am completely ignorant of this aspect so this may be a dumb question - shouldn't the clocks have been changing when I ran 3Dmark? They were rock solid. Could you enlighten me please?

StaggerLee - sorry to hear you're not having any luck. I will try the link you sent tonight (I am now at work). It does seem that we have similar if not identical problems. IMO the problem is, in order of likelihood hi to low

(a) PSU either damaged or in some form not compatible with my 8800 GT
or (b) dodgy graphics card - but Silverion doesn't seem to think so
or (c) 'something' wrong with the mobo

Regarding "have I ever seen the low power pop up?" - once! I didn't mention it earlier cos I didn't want to confuse the issue. This popped up just after the fan speed contoller for the radiator fan on my Gigabyte liquid cooling kit went pop. But that is the only time I have seen it and from what I understand if this was a continuing problem this message would pop up every time I boot?

Reply to chairmaker

chairmaker wrote :


Regarding "have I ever seen the low power pop up?" - once! I didn't mention it earlier cos I didn't want to confuse the issue. This popped up just after the fan speed contoller for the radiator fan on my Gigabyte liquid cooling kit went pop. But that is the only time I have seen it and from what I understand if this was a continuing problem this message would pop up every time I boot?



not if you ticked the "dont show this message again" box though im not sure if there even is any (i think i saw one but im not sure)
i would try uninstalling gfx and mainboard/chipset drivers and only install the drivers that came with the hardware to see if it makes any difference.

Reply to smokegfx

Silverion77 wrote :

He told us the graphics is running at the right clocks



Yes, but it doesn't matter what the software says, the card is not performing, bottom line. Looks like all the other stones have been overturned.

OP, do yourself a favor and go with a brand known for high quality like I posted above. It shouldn't make that much of a difference, but I don't think any of us here have ever heard of that brand of card you have.

------------------------------ e6700 (stock speed for now), Scythe Infinity HSF, Evga 680i, Evga 8800 GTX, Corsair 2 x 1 gig 6400c4, WD 150 gig 10,000 rpm, Thermaltake Toughpower 700W, Thermaltake Armor full tower case (black)
Reply to pongrules

Try changing your ram to another brand i have seen this before in a system i built for gaming.


Reply to techguy911

chairmaker wrote :

MrMr - yes, mobo drivers installed a-ok AFAIK.
Regarding "have I ever seen the low power pop up?" - once! I didn't mention it earlier cos I didn't want to confuse the issue. This popped up just after the fan speed contoller for the radiator fan on my Gigabyte liquid cooling kit went pop. But that is the only time I have seen it and from what I understand if this was a continuing problem this message would pop up every time I boot?



Yeah, it'll keep popping up according the posts I've seen. The image on the link I posted shows that there is not a "Do Not Show Again" box. I saw it initially when I built the system because I didn't plug in the motherboard molex. The instruction manual said it was for when you have multiple graphic cards, so I was unsure. After plugging in the molex, the message went away. This seems to be the chief indicator of it being a PSU issue.

I'm still waiting on a response Enermax about the adapter not working, but I think we've both got some bad video cards. Possibly it's the motherboard, but most likely the video card. I've got an eVGA so I'm kind of lucky. They've offered to RMA like 3 times already while working through the issue.

If Enermax tells me that I'm using the adapter properly, then I don't think this is a PSU issue. I ran a test where I hooked up a secondary PSU to the PCI-e Power input on the video card, so there was PLENTY of power. The adapter is supposed to fix the Power-On timing issue that is out there, which in my opinion leaves only the video card at fault.

Reply to StaggerLee

Hi everyone. Problem solved. I am now so so happy - 3DMark06 score of 11500.

My graphics card came with a 4-pin peripheral connector to PCI-E cable. However, since my PSU came with its own PCI-E socket and cable I thought it best to use that. When today I randomly decided to try the 4-pin peripheral to PCI-E, it worked right away.

I am guessing that means that the PCI-E sockets (there are 2 - I tried both) on my PSU are either bust or never meant to handle the load of an 8800GT OC.

Thank you everyone for your time on this. StaggerLee in particular - man, I hope you manage to solve your 5hi7 - don't let it get you down!!1

chairmaker out

Reply to chairmaker

PS - now its crysis time...

Reply to chairmaker
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New System Build > hideous underperformance of new gaming PC`
Go to:

There are 1097 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them