Tom's Hardware Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » 9600GT vs. HD3870: Which to get?
 

9600GT vs. HD3870: Which to get?




Word :   Username :  
 
 Page : 1 2
Previous
Author
 Thread : 9600GT vs. HD3870: Which to get?
 
Master-de-bater
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

In many reviews, the 9600GT beats the HD3870 in most tests, so naturally the 9600GT is the better deal. With the price being so close, is there any reason to go with the HD3870?

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by Evilonigiri on 02-22-2008 at 03:20:08 AM

---------------
"Nvidia, the Way It's Meant to be PAID Played! - Corrado
*Lesbian Lover Club* - founder Assman
Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

*Smacks turpit with a +5 ban stick*
Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

Because the HD3870 also beats the 9600GT in reviews.


---------------
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w179/random1301/Ibanezrandom-1.png
Sig art copyright verndewd

Ode to Fanboi: http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] l#t1862103
Master-de-bater
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

http://www.firingsquad.com/hardwar [...] /page5.asp

I only see 2 games that the HD3870 significantly wins.


---------------
"Nvidia, the Way It's Meant to be PAID Played! - Corrado
*Lesbian Lover Club* - founder Assman
Profile: member
More Information

Also the 3870 has a better cooling solution, and better HD-playback

Master-de-bater
Profile: Eternal Poster
More Information

itheral wrote :

Also the 3870 has a better cooling solution, and better HD-playback


Dunno about the better HD-playback but according to [H], the 9600GT runs cooler than the HD3870 and the 8800GT thanks to the new bigger fan: http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/arti [...] VzaWFzdA==

The 9600GT also takes up less power, a tad less than the HD3850.

Can you show me a link containing info on the 3870 having better HD-playback?


---------------
"Nvidia, the Way It's Meant to be PAID Played! - Corrado
*Lesbian Lover Club* - founder Assman
Not today maybe tomorrow
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

randomizer wrote :

Because the HD3870 also beats the 9600GT in reviews.


and my farts beat them all


---------------
WAITING FOR THE NEXT MOMENT TO STRIKE

 

Once its gone, its gone
Profile: newbie

http://www.tomshardware.com/2008/0 [...] age17.html

And I say whichever is cheaper get it.
AMD DID drop the costs of its 38xx series.

Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

Evilonigiri wrote :

http://www.firingsquad.com/hardwar [...] /page5.asp

I only see 2 games that the HD3870 significantly wins.



Tomshardware, this site, just did a review on the 3870 and the 9600GT. To sum it up, the 3870 wins the majority of benchmarks without AA. The 9600GT win's a few more, but by a narrow margin, when AA is enabled.

Long story short, you probably won't be able to tell the difference between the two, go with what's less expensive.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by weskurtz81 on 02-22-2008 at 04:31:50 AM
Balls of Steel
Profile: addict

Also, the 38xx series does handle HDTV and video type work a lot better from what I've seen, especially dealing with overscan issues and scaling resolutions.

iTs Me
Profile: addict
More Information

and the 3870 has an audio controller on the card and suppprts VIVO. basic 9600gt lacks certain features, whereas the other one is really good for future proofing thanks to the displayport.


---------------
| Athlon x2 5000+ @ 3.2 | Biostar Tforce 570 sli | Sli 9800GT | 2x 512mb Corsair xms ddr2-800 | 2x 512mb Crucial Tracers ddr-800 | Antec 900 | 22" HannSpree | Creative Itrigue 3000 | PS triple
Profile: addict
More Information

weskurtz81 wrote :

Tomshardware, this site, just did a review on the 3870 and the 9600GT. To sum it up, the 3870 wins the majority of benchmarks without AA. The 9600GT win's a few more, but by a narrow margin, when AA is enabled.

Long story short, you probably won't be able to tell the difference between the two, go with what's less expensive.



true, toms review of 9600GT shows that it is behind the 3875 without filters. n beats, or lose with small margin with AA.

n with the prices cut of 3870. it is the perfect thing to get. specially if u wanna go crossfire.


---------------
Q6600 @ 3Ghz | zalman 9700NT cooler | gigabyte P35-DS3L | Kingstone DDR2 667 1GB x 2 | HIS 4850HD with Accelero S1 Rev.2 | enermax Liberty 500w | Coolermaster C5 case |
*Smacks turpit with a +5 ban stick*
Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

Anandtech also did a review showing the HD3870 on top.


---------------
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w179/random1301/Ibanezrandom-1.png
Sig art copyright verndewd

Ode to Fanboi: http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] l#t1862103
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

They are close, and we all know that the ATI produces better images then NVIDIA period. Nvidias drivers tweak a few extra fake frames for numbers. BIG DEAL. Seeing is believing.

*Smacks turpit with a +5 ban stick*
Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

And I prefer to see a higher framerate over negligible IQ differences.


---------------
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w179/random1301/Ibanezrandom-1.png
Sig art copyright verndewd

Ode to Fanboi: http://www.tomshardware.com/forum/ [...] l#t1862103
Only the paranoid survive.
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Go for both :) Nah, joking. Get any that's avaialable on the market whichever cheaper :) That's it. True that AA filtering enabled the 9600GT has a slightly advantage, but without AA enabled it's otherwise. With this situation all come down to the price :)

*Smacks turpit with a +5 ban stick*
Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information
n°1791854
02-22-2008 at 06:30:25 AM
Hide