Tom's Hardware Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » Video Card Decision...
 

Video Card Decision...

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Video Card Decision...
 
Profile: addict
More Information

I am deciding between a HD 3870 or a 8800GTS.G92

I don't have a lot of money to spend but want to invest it wisely and not waste it, if the higher priced card is worth it for seasons I'm not technically savvy enough to know please explain.

I have 2 Dell 19" displays and don't plan to play games at HIGH settings but maybe mid to low-high and maybe mid-high if that's even possible.

I thank you in advance for your input, comments & opinions.

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Profile: old hand
More Information

That's kind of a funny decision since the 8800GTS is so much faster than the 3870, but also reasonably more expensive. If you don't have a lot of money and won't be playing at the highest settings I'd suggest getting a lower end card than the 8800GTS. They are a lot cheaper and, although slower, offer a lot more bang for the buck. The HD3870 is fine but you should also consider the 8800GT/GS and the newly released 9600GT. There are a lot of choices right now that perform similarly for similar amounts of money...

-mcg


---------------
Athlon X2 3800+ (230x10) @1.40v w/Tuniq Tower | Asus A8N32-SLI Deluxe
2x1GB Corsair XMS PC3200 2.5-3-3-8 1T @409MHz | eVGA 7900GS (500/1380)
WD 640GB AAKS, Seagate 7200.8 250GB, Hitachi 80GB
Corsair VX450 | Samsung 206BW | Vista Ultimate x64
Profile: addict
More Information

Yeah I was just reading a decent article that was saying that the 8800GT is the best card for the money and the slight increase in performance for the GTS.G92 isn't worth it and that the 8800gt 512 is way better than the 3870.

So it seems I'm heading towards the 8800GT or wait a few weeks to a month till the 8800GTS gets to $200 or a pinch below.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

I'd get the 3870. There's one on sale at newegg for 179.99 after $10 rebate. My friend just got one. It works really well, has great color, and the native HDMI is really nice if you have an HDTV sitting around.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814102719

Profile: addict
More Information

I would go with an 8800GT. In most games you wont tell a big difference. The only reason why I went from a GT to GTS was for better cooling. Now several manufacturers offer better cooling. Also brands like XFX and EVGA allow aftermarket cooling without voiding the warranty.

The MSI 8800GT offers great value and after MIR comes less than $200.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127329

However, I would also encourage that you look at the 9600GT, and it offers great performance at its price point.

But even still the 3780 is a great card and even if you decide on it, I dont believe you'll be disappointed.


---------------
Asus P5B Deluxe, Core 2 Quad Q6700, Nvidia 8800GTS (G92), Corsair 4GB PC2 6400, Sound Blaster X-Fi Platinum, Thermaltake 700W PSU
Overclocked and Undervolted
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Definitely look at the 9600GT. It's a little bit faster than the 3870 for about the same price. The 3870 isn't a bad choice, but it would be a travesty not to at least consider the 9600.

If you get an 8800GT try to get one with a modified cooling solution. The stock cooler sucks on many levels. I suppose the same could be said about the 9600GT, but that card doesn't run quite as hot.

Profile: journeyman

for a 19inch screen a 3870 is more than powerful enough. If you had a 22 I would suggest a 8800GT.


---------------
E6600 3.2ghz, HD3870, 4gb Ram.
XP 32 / Vista 64 Dual boot
What became of subtlety?
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

compy386 wrote :

I'd get the 3870. There's one on sale at newegg for 179.99 after $10 rebate. My friend just got one. It works really well, has great color, and the native HDMI is really nice if you have an HDTV sitting around.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814102719



Native HDMI? Not on the card you linked there, bud.

Profile: addict
More Information

mtyermom wrote :

Native HDMI? Not on the card you linked there, bud.



It comes with an HDMI toggle that they failed to mention, but it is a true HDMI that does carry sound just like all the 37xx series cards.


---------------
Asus P5B Deluxe, Core 2 Quad Q6700, Nvidia 8800GTS (G92), Corsair 4GB PC2 6400, Sound Blaster X-Fi Platinum, Thermaltake 700W PSU
Profile: journeyman
More Information

mtyermom wrote :

Native HDMI? Not on the card you linked there, bud.



I got one for a friend. It definitely has native HDMI. We hooked it up to my Sony 60A2000. Sound and everything works. Haven't actually tried gaming on it, but don't see why it'd be a problem.

Overclocked and Undervolted
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Native with an adapter, gotta love it :D

Profile: newbie
More Information

homerdog wrote :

Definitely look at the 9600GT. It's a little bit faster than the 3870 for about the same price. The 3870 isn't a bad choice, but it would be a travesty not to at least consider the 9600.

If you get an 8800GT try to get one with a modified cooling solution. The stock cooler sucks on many levels. I suppose the same could be said about the 9600GT, but that card doesn't run quite as hot.



Actually the 3870 is a bit faster under most circumstances but costs a little more.
Both are great choices,I just installed a 9600gt in my friend's computer and he loves it.
Check out: http://www.tomshardware.com/2008/0 [...] index.html

Profile: newbie
More Information

I'm in the same boat as this guy...debating between the 3870 & 8800GT.

 

I've got 2 big hangups:
CrossFire VS SLI
ATI drivers

 

...it's nice to get another card in a few months to a year for $100 and add a little boost to my performance, but SLI isn't supported on the newer Intel chipsets.
Also, ATI drivers pretty much suck right now, and you have to get RIVA tuner or some other 3rd party utility just to prevent the damn things from over heating.

 

On paper, the 3870 should be owning the competition, but in reality, it doesn't quite work out that way.

 

Think their drivers will improve enough to the point that they'll start kicking the butt that they should?

 

Also, HDMI is kinda overrated, IMO. I got a DDL card so I can always have 5.1 going to my receiver, not my TV.

 

BTW, www.monoprice.com is the ONLY place to get cables, and they have DVI to HDMI cables (among other things) that are way cheaper than you'll find anywhere else.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by Oh SoS on 03-01-2008 at 02:47:33 AM
Overclocked and Undervolted
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

My understanding is this:
-9600 is a bit faster than 3870 without AA
-9600 is a lot faster with AA
-Most games these days are solicited by Nvidia, giving their cards a significant advantage until ATI can optimize its drivers (sad but true)
-3870 has better video processing (full VC-1 decoding)
-3870 has a much better stock cooler
-3870 has better "image quality," whatever that means

I guess if you look at it that way the cards are about equal. I'd put my money on a 9600 since AA is important to me. Others could care less about AA, in which case the 3870 looks more attractive.

They're both great cards at great prices though.

Profile: newbie
More Information

Something else to chew on:
EVGA and XFX offer lifetime warranties...and their 8800GTs are coming down in price; a few dip below the $200 mark at the egg.

 

What's really hanging me up is having to eventually get locked into an nForce chipset to go SLI w/ a quardcore.


Message edited by Oh SoS on 03-01-2008 at 07:27:24 PM
Because Mike Rowe said so!
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

I vote the gts 512 if you can afford it. Outstanding card, it just rocks. You won't regret a single penny. Evga and Xfx are my recommendation because they have awesome warranties.

I am leary on the 8800GT because of the single slot cooler Performance is there though and a bit better then the 3870. the MSI one has a nice cooler on it though and clocked higher i believe.

The 3780 does have a 2 slot cooler which i like. And the prices have come down.

Get the most you can afford or want to pay, that's my rule. If you don't you will kick youself and say "why didnt I spring for the better one for $40"


---------------
E6400@3.2ghz w/ Thermalright Ultra-120 Asus P5W DH Deluxe
4x1GB Crucial Ballistix PC6400 4-4-4-12 CoolMax 600W PSU
XFX 8800GTS Alpha Dog (@750/1000) Dell 22" E228WFP
Seagate 250GB ES.2 & 250GB 7200.10 Creative X-Fi XtremeGamer
Profile: addict
More Information

Oh SoS wrote :

On paper, the 3870 should be owning the competition, but in reality, it doesn't quite work out that way.

Think their drivers will improve enough to the point that they'll start kicking the butt that they should?



Drivers aren't everything. Pentium Ds looked good on paper, but their problem wasn't because the "drivers" weren't that good. There's different architectures with both CPUs and GPUs, so that you can't compare clock speeds and the number of stream processors directly.

haha u gotta be kidding me
Profile: stranger
More Information

I reccomend the MSI 8800GT 512MB - http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127329

Its only $216.99 + $5.84 S/H, and you get a $30.00 mail in rebate. So it comes in at; $192.83. Its got a nice heatsink, and its stock overclocked.

Overclocked and Undervolted
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

That's a good looking card drunkalien6. I must admit though that I am partial to eVGA. I've had nothing but good experiences with their cards and the Step-Up program is just incredible. I went from a 320MB GTS to a 512MB GT for nothing but $15 in shipping. They were out of stock GTs so they sent me a superclocked card instead. Like I said, incredible.

Profile: member
More Information

A 3870 should be fine for you. If you have decent cooling for your case I would say go for the GT. Don't bother with the GTS unless you have the money to blow and really need that double slot and a few extra FPS over the 3870.

Profile: newbie
More Information

well i took the plunge; just got that MSI card from newegg.