Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Power Supplies, PC Cases & Case Mods > Which is best for my requirements?
Word :    Username :           
 

Hello,

 

I was hoping for suggestiong about which power suuple should I choose?
here are the PC specs:
Q6600/E8500 (overclocked)
9800GTX VIDEO
WD2500aaks HDD
some kind of dvd burner
gigabyte p35 ds3r MOBO (not sure yet,p35 100%)
mushkin 2x2gb cl4 RAM
some kind of cpu cooling
cpu overclock (nothing too extreme)
case with 2/3 12cm fans

 

Here is what I think is suitable (I saw reviews of the vid card with more extreme processors use about 350W of power under load so I think 500W is enough):
OCZ StealthXStream 500W
Thermaltake TR2 W0093R 500W
Thermaltake W0101RU 550W
Cooler Master eXtreme Power 500W
NZXT PP500W
SeaSonic SS-500ET-APFC-F3 500W
FSP BlueStorm II 500W
Antec EarthWatts 500W
SilverStone Strider 500W
PC C&C silencer 470W

 

Thanks in advance!

 

EDIT: UPDATED PROCESSOR


Message edited by ilan2212 on 04-05-2008 at 09:44:01 PM
Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Don't overlook the Corsair 550VX. $55 in buy.com.

------------------------------ Intel E6750 * Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L * Galaxy 8800GT 512mb 620MHz* Corsair VX450 * 2GB Transcend 667* 2x120GB Seagate SATA * Altec Lansing ATP3*
Reply to mihirkula

So which one is it?(the link didnt help me very much)

Reply to ilan2212

PC Power and Cooling Silencer 610w, it is the best in that wattage range, and is priced well for the wattage.

Reply to The_Blood_Raven

hmm it wont do its of budget (I live outside of the US)
Any other suggestions?And which one is best from what I have listed?

Reply to ilan2212

CoolerMaster and NZXT are on tier-5 ("Do not buy" ) on the list that rodney linked. Of the ones you listed, I would probably choose Seasonic if the budget allows. Esit: second choice would be OCZ.


Message edited by jtt283 on 04-03-2008 at 08:12:24 PM
------------------------------ There is ALWAYS a drone. Exactly where, or how many drones you will encounter may vary, but that there will be at least one will not.
Reply to jtt283

Intresting , because its the cheapest one.
So Seasonic>OCZ (in the specific model I mentioned)?

Reply to ilan2212

So what the verdict?
edit: I have added the FSp blustorm 2
- Is sub 500W power supply will do? (say enermax noisetaker2 420W, or any other suggestions you might have)


Message edited by ilan2212 on 04-04-2008 at 04:32:56 PM
Reply to ilan2212

With your computer, not being able to spend $100 a good psu is sad. I would go for the PC P&C 610W, A Seasonic no less than 550W, a Corsair no less than 550W, or a Antec NeoPower no less than 550W. Then again, there is much more than goes into selecting a power supply than just looking at what components you have. How long you want to keep the computer, how much upgrading you are going to do, how long you will have your computer on everyday, etc.

Reply to pokemon

haha sorry im on a budget but thats just how things go...
daily uses - gaming mostly and surfing , instant messaging etc...


Message edited by ilan2212 on 04-04-2008 at 06:43:40 PM
Reply to ilan2212

What is important is the amps that the psu can reliably deliver on the 12v rails, not the watts. It is recommended that a pc with a single 8800gt/gts have a psu with 26a, and a 8800GTX 30a on the 12v rails. I expect the 9800gtx to be in between.
Lower quality psu vendors up the watts for marketing by either delivering them on the 3v and 5v rails which is easy, but not useful. They also claim peak watts and at 25c instead of a more realist temperature. Lower quality units will also operate at lower efficiency.

The 9800gtx requires two pci-e connectors. One indicator of a psu that can handle your 9800gtx is if it comes with two pci-e connectors.

Of the units you listed, I think the FSP unit is the best value, or even the seasonic based on their reputation as a quality primary manufacturer.

A psu is not the place to go cheap with a nice system such as yours. The PC P&C silencer610 would be appropriate. A lower, second choice would be corsair or seasonic m-12 or s-12..

It would be better to save $50 on the case instead of the psu.


Message edited by geofelt on 04-04-2008 at 06:44:20 PM
Reply to geofelt

First of all , thanks alot for your reply , its just that im a first time builder and I left the PSU and case for last , so thats the situation.
Im not sure about the power requirement for a system as I wrote , so I kinda guessed.
I will take your comment into consideration and look further for PSU.
EDIT: the PC P&C silencer610 is too expensive (do remember I live outside of the US, and prices are diffrent)
but the 470W model is about right.Ill add more later.
EDIT2:Antec EarthWatts500W fits in my budget , what is your take on it?
EDIT3:SilverStone Strider 500W also fits , your opinion?


Message edited by ilan2212 on 04-04-2008 at 08:12:15 PM
Reply to ilan2212

Get a Q6600 instead of a Q9450, there now you have +$100 to add to the budget without harming performance. Unless you are going to be doing some serious encoding with this computer, theres not much reason to get a SSE4 processor over one that only does SSE3. You still need to tell us probably the two most important things: How long you plan on keeping the power supply? and how often it is on per day (24/7?)?

Reply to pokemon

NOT 24/7 except maybe a few night of downloading etc.
I plan to keep as long as I see fit - I dont know exactly when im going to upgrade or change the whole thing again , but at least 2 years.

Reply to ilan2212

Antec earthwatts 500W is a good unit and has more amps on the 12volt rail (total 34) than PC Power and Cooling 470 which has 26amps

Reply to rolli59

pokemon wrote :

Get a Q6600 instead of a Q9450, there now you have +$100 to add to the budget without harming performance. Unless you are going to be doing some serious encoding with this computer, theres not much reason to get a SSE4 processor over one that only does SSE3. You still need to tell us probably the two most important things: How long you plan on keeping the power supply? and how often it is on per day (24/7?)?



Wow, no, not even close. The reason he would pay extra for the Q9450 is that the Q9450 is supposed to perform on the level of a dual core CPU in games. That is why I want one, that is why it is worth the money.

Reply to The_Blood_Raven

rolli59 wrote :

Antec earthwatts 500W is a good unit and has more amps on the 12volt rail (total 34) than PC Power and Cooling 470 which has 26amps



No, not even close. You can NOT just add the Amperage, it does not work that way. The Antec has an actual Amperage of 24A, the PC P&C has 32A. The PC P&C has an insane amount of Amps for a 470w or even a 500w, it is the only one I would trust to run that system.

Reply to The_Blood_Raven

I guess that was just my opinion. I would pass on something that really isn't worth its cost for what I am doing; especially if its causing me to believe that a power supply is an accessory for a computer.

Reply to pokemon

The power supply is the most crucial part of a system, no matter how many cores, or how many GPUs you have they will suck if they are not being powered.

Reply to The_Blood_Raven

Thanks for your replies, but is there a conclusive answer?
-SilverStone Strider ST50F 500W
-Antec EarthWatts 500W
-PC P&C Silencer 470W


Message edited by ilan2212 on 04-05-2008 at 08:38:56 AM
Reply to ilan2212

The_Blood_Raven wrote :

No, not even close. You can NOT just add the Amperage, it does not work that way. The Antec has an actual Amperage of 24A, the PC P&C has 32A. The PC P&C has an insane amount of Amps for a 470w or even a 500w, it is the only one I would trust to run that system.


Well I don't think that is right. Let me do the math and see if I'm just doing it wrong.
Formula: Watts (W)/Voltage (12V) = Amps (A)
Antec Earthwatts 500w PSU:
If you read the sticker, it says 12v1, 12v2 MAX load is 408 watts.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Show [...] wer+Supply
so inputting the values into the equation you get:
408w/12v=......34Amps!!! Now this sticker does fall under the "just add them up" syndrome. Your right that "MOST" PSU stickers don't label the same way.

PCP&C 470w PSU:
States right on the sticker that it only has 26A for the +12V rail.
See picture here:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Show [...] wer+Supply

I'll throw in another PSU to show you differences.
Enermax Liberty PSU, shows clearly that it only can produce 36A on the combined 12V rails or 432w/12V=36Amps!

I don't disagree that PCP&C makes good PSU's, but I'd double check your calculations next time.

For the best value, I'd go with the Corsair vx550w PSU. It has 41A on the 12V rail and comes with a 5 yr warranty which none of the ones listed have that. It is also cheaper (after MIR) than the ones listed.
Corsair VX 550W ATX Power Supply - CMPSU-550VX
http://www.buy.com/prod/corsair-vx [...] 52646.html


Message edited by lunyone on 04-05-2008 at 10:49:07 AM
------------------------------ PSU Tiers
GPU Power
8800gtx w/e6600 OC'd will run on Antec 380w w/27A on 12v rail, PSU!!
Reply to lunyone

Thats the problem , I DONT live in the US , and the corsair is considerably more costly here.
And again I ask: Which is the best of the three?
-SilverStone Strider ST50F 500W
-Antec EarthWatts 500W
-PC P&C Silencer 470W


Message edited by ilan2212 on 04-05-2008 at 11:14:46 AM
Reply to ilan2212

PC P&C 470.

------------------------------ Intel E6750 * Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L * Galaxy 8800GT 512mb 620MHz* Corsair VX450 * 2GB Transcend 667* 2x120GB Seagate SATA * Altec Lansing ATP3*
Reply to mihirkula

lunyone you forget you are comparing a single rail PSU to multiple rail PSUs, it does not work that way.

Reply to The_Blood_Raven

The_Blood_Raven wrote :

lunyone you forget you are comparing a single rail PSU to multiple rail PSUs, it does not work that way.



The Antec EarthWatts does NOT have multiple +12V rails. It only has one +12V rail with no limiters on any of the connectors.

from;
http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.p [...] y2&reid=35

In this case, it does work that way.

------------------------------ q9650 @ 4.050 | Asus Rampage Formula | 2x2 Corsair Dominators | WD Black 640 x2
EVGA GTX260 Core216 @ 686/1479/1103 | Antec TPN 750

 

Reply to Delluser1

Interesting, but I will trust ANTEC to give me the information on an ANTEC power supply. The truth is, I emailed them and as always the tech support was great, and they said that in fact the Antec Earthwatt runs off of 32A for 12v rail, which is the same as the PC P&C. This brings me back to my original point, Antec is an ok PSU manufacturer, PC P&C is one of, if not the, best PSU manufacturer on the market.

Reply to The_Blood_Raven

Thanks everyone , and I guess that most agree on the
PC P&C Silencer 470W as the best from the ones I have listed.
Thanks alot!

Reply to ilan2212

I came to a conclusion - I wont be buying the Q9450 for several reasons.
My choices are now Q6600/E8500 , Im leaning toward the E8500 because
my main uses will be gaming , and overclocking is easier on a dual core.
With that in mind , should I change my choice for the PSU or leave it at that?

Reply to ilan2212

So 26A on the PCP&C is more than 34A on the Antec? I guess that the 26A is better? PCP&C makes good PSU's but Antec does so too. I'm just pointing out that 26A doesn't beat 34A of power. The PCP&C has a 5 yr warranty and the Antec only has 1 yr warranty, so that is the difference maker in that category. I wouldn't buy a 26A PSU for the proposed build, especially since most newer GPU's are requireing about 26-30A of power. This will limit OC'ing and future upgrades. The OP can buy it, but I'd try and get something with more amps on the 12V rail.

------------------------------ PSU Tiers
GPU Power
8800gtx w/e6600 OC'd will run on Antec 380w w/27A on 12v rail, PSU!!
Reply to lunyone

OK thanks everyone, but ill go with blood_raven this time , but thank you too lunyone!

Reply to ilan2212

Hopefully you won't have any power issues, so good luck and let us know what your final build will be.

------------------------------ PSU Tiers
GPU Power
8800gtx w/e6600 OC'd will run on Antec 380w w/27A on 12v rail, PSU!!
Reply to lunyone

Just got back to this thread. Thanks lunyone for putting the b-raven right on the amps. I would never have posted what I did with out doing the research and looked up all the psu listed by OP and picked the one with the best rating/price ratio not because I like the brand name.
To OP your power requirements under heavy gaming are right up there what that PC Power and Cooling can deliver constantly on the +12V rail.

Reply to rolli59

lunyone wrote :

Antec only has 1 yr warranty,
I wouldn't buy a 26A PSU for the proposed build, especially since most newer GPU's are requireing about 26-30A of power. This will limit OC'ing and future upgrades. The OP can buy it, but I'd try and get something with more amps on the 12V rail.



The Antec warranty is 3 years.
Definitely need to go for higher amperage.

------------------------------ q9650 @ 4.050 | Asus Rampage Formula | 2x2 Corsair Dominators | WD Black 640 x2
EVGA GTX260 Core216 @ 686/1479/1103 | Antec TPN 750

 

Reply to Delluser1

http://www.tomshardware.com/2008/0 [...] age12.html
According to Toms own review the power consumption of the 9800gtx under load is 265watts = 22 amps that leaves 4 amps for the rest of the system under constant use.

Reply to rolli59

@rolli59: The toms figure is for the entire system, not just the vga card. Nvidia states that the requirement for the 9800gtx is 156w (or 13a).

Reply to geofelt

Yeah, but if you have the system for a few years and add a more power hungry GPU (9800gx2) you will be pushing things. I'm not saying that it will work, but with capacitor aging you could run into problems. It's nice to have a little extra now, so you don't have to upgrade in a year or two. Just wanted to point that out. The OP can go with whatever he feels comfortable with, but thought I should mention my concerns/opinion.

------------------------------ PSU Tiers
GPU Power
8800gtx w/e6600 OC'd will run on Antec 380w w/27A on 12v rail, PSU!!
Reply to lunyone
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Power Supplies, PC Cases & Case Mods > Which is best for my requirements?
Go to:

There are 1007 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them