Tom's Hardware Forums » Graphic & Displays » Graphics Cards » 9600gt SLI or 3870 CF?
 

9600gt SLI or 3870 CF?

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : 9600gt SLI or 3870 CF?
 
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

Which offers better performance?
9600gt SLI or 3870 CF?
Someone tell me!

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Profile: member
More Information

Well, it really depends on the game really.....
 
Try this article :
http://www.techspot.com/article/88 [...] on-hd3870/

Profile: addict
More Information

Using COD4 for reference...........A friend of mine has both. The nvidia cards seem to show the smoke/fog/particle effects much better. ATI  really slipped here for some reason.

Serenity Now!
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Filtering kills the 3870 check tom's review on the 9600 GT


---------------
L1qu1dat1on Ag3
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 @ 3.6, RAM: 8 gig 1066 5-4-3-6, Fan: Water Cooling, Mobo: Asus Striker II Formula, Hard Drive: 2x's 150 Raptor (RAID), VGA: BFG 9800 GX2 (770, 1125)PSU:CorsairHX1000 Windows Vista Ultimate 64
Serenity Now!
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Filtering kills the 3870 check tom's review on the 9600 GT


---------------
L1qu1dat1on Ag3
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 @ 3.6, RAM: 8 gig 1066 5-4-3-6, Fan: Water Cooling, Mobo: Asus Striker II Formula, Hard Drive: 2x's 150 Raptor (RAID), VGA: BFG 9800 GX2 (770, 1125)PSU:CorsairHX1000 Windows Vista Ultimate 64
Serenity Now!
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Filtering kills the 3870 check tom's review on the 9600 GT


---------------
L1qu1dat1on Ag3
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 @ 3.6, RAM: 8 gig 1066 5-4-3-6, Fan: Water Cooling, Mobo: Asus Striker II Formula, Hard Drive: 2x's 150 Raptor (RAID), VGA: BFG 9800 GX2 (770, 1125)PSU:CorsairHX1000 Windows Vista Ultimate 64
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

^ :lol: at triple post  :P.

 

@OP: keep in mind that the 3870 has a better cooling system, and ATI cards usually get better image quality (an obvious exception is what swifty_morgan mentioned, although potentially that could be an isolated incident). But like L1qu1d said, filtering hurts the 3870s performance.

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by Avenger_K on 03-29-2008 at 04:29:24 PM
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

It's exactly the same. Nothing more to say. :p

Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

like 9600gt, it gets 182percent performance in SLI compared to single card.  
What about the 3870? Is it as efficient?

Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

romulus47plus1 wrote :

like 9600gt, it gets 182percent performance in SLI compared to single card.
What about the 3870? Is it as efficient?

 


  

It's the same. SLI and Crossfire are basically the same thing by competing companies. Between those two, I'd choose 3870, because the superior x38 chipset supports Crossfire and not SLI. You get to highly overclock your cpu this way. If you don't oc, it doesn't matter either way.

 

It might make more sense to get 8800gt, which performs significantly better than either 9600gt or 3870 for relatively small cost increase. It's the best bang for the buck.

 

And keep in mind that "182%" is just boasting. In most games under realistic conditions, the performance for SLI/Crossfire is far lower.


Message edited by dagger on 03-29-2008 at 04:55:26 PM
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

Btw, I am running an AMD system. Is 790FX a good overclocker?
If I am gonna buy a 9600gt I'll wait for the 750i

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Depends on on if you want to play Crysis. The 9600 GTs will give you much better performance here... should be more than enough in all other games with either solution.


---------------
C2D E6550 @ 3 GHz   >Asus X38 P5E   >4 gigs DDR2 @860mhz 4 4 4 12   >X-fi Fatality
>Thermaltake Toughpower 650w   >PALiT 8800 GTS 1024MB @800/2000/2200
 
 
Still playing my Dreamcast
Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

Avenger_K wrote :

ATI cards usually get better image quality

That was generally the case until the release of the Geforce 8 series.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

Like most comparisons like this.. Each card setup will trade blows depending on the game. Basically the setups are equal. Knowing that.. I would recommend the CF setup as the ATI cards have better features than the 9600's and have cooling fans than move the air out of the case. Also.. if the 7-Series is anything to judge by.. the 9600's may not look so good in a year or 2..

Serenity Now!
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

LOl sorry I was on Utorrent and I kept clicking the button LMAO didn't even see it! ahahahaha


---------------
L1qu1dat1on Ag3
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 @ 3.6, RAM: 8 gig 1066 5-4-3-6, Fan: Water Cooling, Mobo: Asus Striker II Formula, Hard Drive: 2x's 150 Raptor (RAID), VGA: BFG 9800 GX2 (770, 1125)PSU:CorsairHX1000 Windows Vista Ultimate 64
Profile: Honorary Veteran of THGC
More Information

Both good options IMO just depending if you want an Intel chipset mobo or SLI mobo.  They should each win a fair share of games.  You can check this 9600GT SLI review as it includes the HD3870X2 anyway.  
http://www.firingsquad.com/hardwar [...] /page3.asp


Message edited by pauldh on 03-29-2008 at 07:56:22 PM

---------------
MSI P6N SLI Platinum, Q6600, 2GB Crucial Ballistix Tracer PC8000,  
SLI BFG 8800GT OC 512MB, SB X-Fi Fatality, Antec TruePower Trio 550W, Windows XP pro
"Couldnt think of one"
Profile: addict
More Information

If i were you dont bother with sli or cf rather go with 1 single powerful card.
New games have issues with sli and cf so your going to be frustrated at new released games.
But if you chose to do sli or cf go with cf because drivers appear faster from amd/ati.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Avenger_K wrote :

ATI cards usually get better image quality


 

Heyyou27 wrote :

That was generally the case until the release of the Geforce 8 series.


 
I was basing my statement on what I've heard from many different forum users on their personal experience with 8800s and 3800s. I confess I haven't actually used them myself, but many people have said that the colors with recent ATI cards are richer than the 8800s. Can anyone else confirm this?

Serenity Now!
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

yes I can. And I can confirm that the Texture and picture quality is much richer on the 9800 GX2's than the 9600 GT's. (I had the 9600 GT in SL!)
 
ATI was reigning champ up until Nvidia released the 8 series. But I did hear that there was a situation where nvidia lower it's picture quality for the 8 series during benchmarks to show it as much better than the ATI 2900 XT.  
 
This was August 2007, it was in Maximum pc and on every site, I'm sure you can find it if you search google.


---------------
L1qu1dat1on Ag3
CPU: Intel Core 2 Quad Q9450 @ 3.6, RAM: 8 gig 1066 5-4-3-6, Fan: Water Cooling, Mobo: Asus Striker II Formula, Hard Drive: 2x's 150 Raptor (RAID), VGA: BFG 9800 GX2 (770, 1125)PSU:CorsairHX1000 Windows Vista Ultimate 64
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

What I had heard was that with the 3870 Ati retook the IQ crown.... but I never saw tests as conclusive as the ones that we saw when the 2900 came out. So until we get a really detailed comparison its hard to measure how big the difference is.


---------------
C2D E6550 @ 3 GHz   >Asus X38 P5E   >4 gigs DDR2 @860mhz 4 4 4 12   >X-fi Fatality
>Thermaltake Toughpower 650w   >PALiT 8800 GTS 1024MB @800/2000/2200
 
 
Profile: addict
More Information