Tom's Hardware Forums » Graphic & Displays » TV/Video Cards » Help me pick a new video card
 

Help me pick a new video card

Add a reply



 Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Help me pick a new video card
 
Profile: journeyman
More Information

I'm placing an order tonight. I'm trying to decide between the ASUS EAH 3870 512 and the EVGA GeForce 8800GT.

I have an ASUS P5W DH Deluxe mobo, 2 gigs of RAM, and a Core 2 Duo E6600. My PSU is a PC Power and Cooler Quad 750.

I'm never going to Crossfire or SLI so I'm not an ATI or Nvidia fanboy. I'm looking for something that'll last a few years.

Thanks for the advice.

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

What resolution do you play at? At 1280 x 1024 or less either will be fine.

GinoS wrote :

I'm looking for something that'll last a few years.



Well then you have to get the 8800GT, as it's simply more powerful, and therefore more future proof.

Also the HD3870 is dual slot, whilst the eVGA 8800Gt is only a single slot.

Profile: member
More Information

8800GT is simply better and it should be OK at that res for a while yet.

Profile: newbie
More Information

Future proof you said huh?
I'd say wait a few eeks and get a Radeon 4850 512mbs or faster if you can =]

Padawan Eater
Profile: addict
More Information

I'd agree but instead suggest a 4870


---------------
Exile- Kreia what are you Jedi or Sith?

Kreia- Does it matter? Of course it does; such titles allow us to rip the galaxy into two halves: light and dark, good and bad. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they really are: pieces to a puzzle.
Padawan Eater
Profile: addict
More Information

how bout u get a PS3 instead, nah j/p


---------------
Exile- Kreia what are you Jedi or Sith?

Kreia- Does it matter? Of course it does; such titles allow us to rip the galaxy into two halves: light and dark, good and bad. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they really are: pieces to a puzzle.
Profile: addict
More Information

I think the 3870 is built better. I am not a fan of build of the 8800 (G92), especially the GT. It looks like a budget card from 3 years ago. I decided to go with two Asus 9600GT Silent, since I really wasn't thrilled with any of the high end cards. I think the ATI looks like a beefy card. I know looks shouldn't be that big of an issue, but it is to me. It seems the new 88s are not built to last like the old ones. The new GTS not bad, the GT is pretty flimsy. I also installed on in my nephews computer with identical components to mine except card. I had the old 8800GTS (G80). His doesn't outperform mine at least not in Crysis. In fact I think my numbers are better a higher res. If I were to go with an 8800GT, it would be the egva Akimbo. The Akimbo costs more but has an excellent cooling system and overclocks really well. Or do like I did and get a 9600gt save your money for the next gen.

Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

cisco wrote :

I think the 3870 is built better. I am not a fan of build of the 8800 (G92), especially the GT. It looks like a budget card from 3 years ago. I decided to go with two Asus 9600GT Silent, since I really wasn't thrilled with any of the high end cards. I think the ATI looks like a beefy card. I know looks shouldn't be that big of an issue, but it is to me. It seems the new 88s are not built to last like the old ones. The new GTS not bad, the GT is pretty flimsy. I also installed on in my nephews computer with identical components to mine except card. I had the old 8800GTS (G80). His doesn't outperform mine at least not in Crysis. In fact I think my numbers are better a higher res. If I were to go with an 8800GT, it would be the egva Akimbo. The Akimbo costs more but has an excellent cooling system and overclocks really well. Or do like I did and get a 9600gt save your money for the next gen.

 


The 3870 is definately not built better. It suffers from major bottlenecking issues. How did they manage to get a gpu with so such high floating point capacity and raw processing power to perform so poorly? It's such a shame. The 4870, with twice the TMUs, should ease this bottleneck, and we may finally get to see what it's supposed to do.

 

In performance, 3870 is identical to 9600gt, and slower than 8800gt and g92 8800gts. g92 8800 gts is the best bang for the buck right now at $169.99 after MIR.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814134037

 

Ideally, wait for 4870 or possibly 9900.


---------------
Q6600@3.6ghz, GA-EX38-DS4 X38 chipset motherboard, 8gb 800mhz ddr2 4-3-3-12, 8800GTS(g92)@780mhz, 1TB 7200rpm 32mb cache hdd, 850watt 12v rails=4x20amp powersupply
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

8800GT!
OR
Wait till the 9900s or the 4800s come out, then everything's gonna change, and prices are going to fall... Hehehe...

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by romulus47p lus1 on 04-26-2008 at 07:06:49 PM

---------------
Why so serious?
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

romulus47plus1 wrote :

8800GT!
OR
Wait till the 9800s or the 4800s come out, then everything's gonna change, and prices are going to fall... Hehehe...

 


You mean 9900s. 9800gtx is already out, and as you can see from this benchmark against the g92 8800gts...
http://en.expreview.com/2008/04/03 [...] review/12/


---------------
Q6600@3.6ghz, GA-EX38-DS4 X38 chipset motherboard, 8gb 800mhz ddr2 4-3-3-12, 8800GTS(g92)@780mhz, 1TB 7200rpm 32mb cache hdd, 850watt 12v rails=4x20amp powersupply
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

Sorry dagger, typo mistake...


---------------
Why so serious?
Padawan Eater
Profile: addict
More Information

dagger you really love showing that benchmark around, just thrashing that 9800series card. Makes you feel better about that G92 hamburger you got in that PCi-Express slot doesnt it?


---------------
Exile- Kreia what are you Jedi or Sith?

Kreia- Does it matter? Of course it does; such titles allow us to rip the galaxy into two halves: light and dark, good and bad. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they really are: pieces to a puzzle.
Profile: Ancient Poster
More Information

DarthPiggie wrote :

dagger you really love showing that benchmark around, just thrashing that 9800series card. Makes you feel better about that G92 hamburger you got in that PCi-Express slot doesnt it?


Yep, hamburger is yummy. :p


---------------
Q6600@3.6ghz, GA-EX38-DS4 X38 chipset motherboard, 8gb 800mhz ddr2 4-3-3-12, 8800GTS(g92)@780mhz, 1TB 7200rpm 32mb cache hdd, 850watt 12v rails=4x20amp powersupply
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

Lol. hamburger is yummy


---------------
Why so serious?
Padawan Eater
Profile: addict
More Information

but its really bad for your health(im a health nut :bounce: )


---------------
Exile- Kreia what are you Jedi or Sith?

Kreia- Does it matter? Of course it does; such titles allow us to rip the galaxy into two halves: light and dark, good and bad. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they really are: pieces to a puzzle.
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

Yea, You really have to keep fit since your a Darth...


---------------
Why so serious?
Padawan Eater
Profile: addict
More Information

And your a romulus, founder of ROme


---------------
Exile- Kreia what are you Jedi or Sith?

Kreia- Does it matter? Of course it does; such titles allow us to rip the galaxy into two halves: light and dark, good and bad. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they really are: pieces to a puzzle.
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information

Yea, thank you...
I guess I'm the one who has to keep fit, since there's no such thing as liposuction in my era...


---------------
Why so serious?
Padawan Eater
Profile: addict
More Information

lmfao. Dude I loved RTW.


---------------
Exile- Kreia what are you Jedi or Sith?

Kreia- Does it matter? Of course it does; such titles allow us to rip the galaxy into two halves: light and dark, good and bad. Perhaps I am neither, and I hold both as what they really are: pieces to a puzzle.
Ronald- Nazi in disguise.
Profile: old hand
More Information