Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > 8800GTX V 9800GTX V 2 X 8800GT
8800GTX V 9800GTX V 2 X 8800GT




Warning, if you click on "see results", you won't be able to vote
Word :    Username :           
 

Out of this selection of cards what would be the best choice overall?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

I'd say 2 8800 GTs (probly both with 1 gb) would rock SLI since you'd probly want lots of textures and the speed should be relatively the same, though take it with a grain a salt as I prefer ATI and am not the best person to judge NVIDIA

------------------------------ It is a very newb question, which is why I ask it.
Reply to jonyb222

You'll need to give us more info. What games do you want to play? What about resolutions? System specs?

The best choice all depends on the price of the vidcard.

------------------------------ "Nvidia, the Way It's Meant to be PAID Played! - Corrado
*Lesbian Lover Club* - founder Assman
Reply to Evilonigiri

All types of new games really. I'm not sure about resolution because not my monitor is only 1280 X 1024 but i'm sure I will end up getting a 1080P one. System specs are still be decided but i'm sure they will not bottleneck the cards.

Reply to Dark Comet
- 0 +

Well id say 8800GTs would defeat all of em pretty easily even at the relativly low res of 1280x1024.

But id say go with 9800GTX out of convenience really. Don't go for an nvidia motherboard if you can help it.

------------------------------ Na na na na na na na na HATMAN!
Reply to Hatman

Ok its better to go with intel chipset? Why not Nvidia?
Do you think the 2 X 8800 GTs would out perform the 8900 GTX at high resolutions because of the added memory? (512MB X2)

Reply to Dark Comet

SLI does not add memory. So 2 x 8800GT 512MB will use only 512MB of vram.

------------------------------ "Nvidia, the Way It's Meant to be PAID Played! - Corrado
*Lesbian Lover Club* - founder Assman
Reply to Evilonigiri

What it only uses one of the cards VRAM? Thats kinda stupid and wastes money too.

Reply to Dark Comet

You'll only want an Nvidia chipset if you plan on going the SLI route now or in the future.Go with an Intel chipset(X48)if your sure your not gonna add a second Nvidia card.As a bonus,if you were to use ATI in the future,the Intel chipset would allow you to add in extra ATI cards...

------------------------------ Q9550,ASUS P5N-T Deluxe 780i mobo,ANTEC 900 case,PC Power&Cooling Turbo Cool 1200 watt,4 Gigs OCZ 1066mhz,Zerotherm Nirvana Cooler,X-Fi Platinum sound card,BFG GTX 285 OC SLi,Razer Tarantula Keyboard,Razer Lachesis mouse,Razer Barracuda Headphones.Gateway
Reply to kellytm3

Dark Comet wrote :

What it only uses one of the cards VRAM? Thats kinda stupid and wastes money too.


No, each card uses it's own memory.

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1] http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg
Reply to mousemonkey
- 0 +

Not an expert,but it seems that the 8800gtx is king with higher resolutions and AA on.Meaning if you go with 24'' or higher widescreen it wins.

Reply to ivanski

mousemonkey wrote :

No, each card uses it's own memory.



Evilonigiri wrote :

SLI does not add memory. So 2 x 8800GT 512MB will use only 512MB of vram.



???

Reply to Dark Comet


Do some research. :whistle:

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1] http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg
Reply to mousemonkey

Did some quick research. One of the GTXs will be the best choice now I think.

Reply to Dark Comet

Dark Comet wrote :

Did some quick research. One of the GTXs will be the best choice now I think.



Research properly mate...2x8800GT rape a 8800GTX to kingdomcome.


------------------------------ Intel E6750 * Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L * Galaxy 8800GT 512mb 620MHz* Corsair VX450 * 2GB Transcend 667* 2x120GB Seagate SATA * Altec Lansing ATP3*
Reply to mihirkula

2 512 mb videocards in sli dont equal one 1gb video card because each video card has to have the exact same information stored in it's memory as the other card. And also, make sure you have the power supply and ample case ventilation for sli. If you're going to stay with the 1280 x 1024 I would stay with a single card. To me a 2nd would be a waste. If you do opt for the bigger monitor then sli would be more fitting.

------------------------------ Vista Home Premium.Gigabyte GA-P35DS3L. Intel Q6600 @ 3.4- Thermalright ultra 120. Scythe 120mm.4gb Geil DDR2 800.OCZ GameXstream 700w.EVGA GTX 280.Soundblaster Audigy 2 zs.Antec 900.2x Western Digital Caviar SE16 320gb B3
1x Western Digital 500gb GP
Reply to bobert866

2 GTs is the best set up, but at that res, I'd be tempted to stick with a single 512MB 8800 GTS. If you're thinking of getting a monitor with higher res, go for the GTs.

Reply to two bit hit
- 0 +



2x 8800 GT 512Mb in SLI means games won't use two lots of 512Mb as 1GB and will treat the VRAM available to it as just one lot of 512MB. So even if you had 4x 8800GT 512MB games would only address 512Mb of Vram.

Reply to JeanLuc

So the 8800 GTX would have more VRAM then 2 X 8800 GTs therefore it should do better in higher resolutions shouldn't it?

Reply to Dark Comet

Dark Comet wrote :

So the 8800 GTX would have more VRAM then 2 X 8800 GTs therefore it should do better in higher resolutions shouldn't it?


In theory yes, but in reality no.
http://www.legionhardware.com/Benc [...] TALKER.png

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1] http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg
Reply to mousemonkey
- 0 +

While GTX will naturally perform better in higher resolutions SLI scales much better in higher resolutions too, and the gap between GT and GTX isnt big enough to make up the difference.

------------------------------ Na na na na na na na na HATMAN!
Reply to Hatman
- 0 +

It's always been my understanding that in SLI one card renders one half of the screen while the other card renders the other half. So each card stores different information, thus 1GB would be correct for SLI'd 8800GTs.

But I've been known to make mistakes :P

------------------------------ "He is no fool who gives what he cannot keep to gain what he cannot lose" -- Jim Elliott
Reply to leo2kp

leo2kp wrote :

It's always been my understanding that in SLI one card renders one half of the screen while the other card renders the other half. So each card stores different information, thus 1GB would be correct for SLI'd 8800GTs.

But I've been known to make mistakes :P


And there is also 'alternate frame rendering' either way both cards store the textures for the entire frame, the same frame @ 512 mb each. AFAIK

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1] http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg
Reply to mousemonkey
- 0 +

leo2kp wrote :

It's always been my understanding that in SLI one card renders one half of the screen while the other card renders the other half. So each card stores different information, thus 1GB would be correct for SLI'd 8800GTs.

But I've been known to make mistakes :P



You haven't made a mistake because you were talking about SLI from 3DFX weren't you? ;)

Reply to JeanLuc

I think I will get 1 8800GT for now and add another one in the future when I upgrade my CPU etc. I think I will get this one http://www.komplett.co.uk/k/ki.aspx?sku=342835 I was going to get the XFX one but for £20 more the EVGA one has 120 months warranty (Is this a mistake?) and Crysis. Its core clock speed is also 10mhz faster :sarcastic: . I will also upgrade my RAM. I will get this RAM http://www.komplett.co.uk/k/ki.aspx?sku=321028 as it is cheap (I will upgrade to 4 GB later on so there is no need to spend alot of money on RAM I won't have for long). It is also quite low latency as most RAM at 800mhz is CL5 and this is CL4. This should improve my 7100 GS and 1 gig 667mhz (CL5) set up now :D.

Reply to Dark Comet
- 0 +

Neither! 2x 8800 GTS G92 512MB...worth the very small price increase.

Reply to Waspy

If you had an 8800gtx already, ide say buy a second one. 2 8800gtx's put a big hurtin' on 8800gt's at high resolutions, and the 8800 gtx is down to 290 now on newegg. But price wise, you have to go with the 8800gt if you don't already own a card. They are so cheap.

Reply to hypocrisyforever

hypocrisyforever wrote :

If you had an 8800gtx already, ide say buy a second one. 2 8800gtx's put a big hurtin' on 8800gt's at high resolutions, and the 8800 gtx is down to 290 now on newegg. But price wise, you have to go with the 8800gt if you don't already own a card. They are so cheap.

 

Yes, the 8800gt is down to $170-180 range on newegg. Not bad for 90% of GTX performance. I agree with you completely.


Message edited by TurdBurglar on 04-07-2008 at 09:41:55 PM
------------------------------ Q6600 @ 3.2ghz w/ Tuniq Tower 120 | Gigabyte P35-DS3L |
2gb Super Talent PC6400 | BFG 8800GT OC 512mb (740/1854/1980) w/ Accelero S1 Turbo |
Corsair 450VX PSU | Cooler Master Elite 330 Case | Windows XP Pro | 3dMark06 14,716
Reply to TurdBurglar
------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1] http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg
Reply to mousemonkey

Do people like XFX over EVGA?

Reply to Dark Comet
- 0 +

EVGA imo better for a number of reasons.

...

------------------------------ Na na na na na na na na HATMAN!
Reply to Hatman

I know that EVGA does that Step up thing which XFX does not do. I've heard that people like EVGA but I have not heard much about XFX. The EVGA graphics card I am looking at according to Komplett.co.uk has 120 months warranty!

Reply to Dark Comet

jonyb222 wrote :

I'd say 2 8800 GTs (probly both with 1 gb) would rock SLI since you'd probly want lots of textures and the speed should be relatively the same, though take it with a grain a salt as I prefer ATI and am not the best person to judge NVIDIA

Actually the 1GB 8800GT has virturally no frame rate boost (for the most part).

 

SLI 8800GTs for the win. Even one 8800GT can perform within 5 frames of a 8800GTX. But remember, that it is heavily dependent on the resolution you're running it at. The percentage of performance boost at, say, 1280x800 is significantly less then at 1920x1200.

 

Here are some benchmarks... and there are a ton of other games that look the same.

 

http://www23.tomshardware.com/grap [...] &chart=357
http://www23.tomshardware.com/grap [...] &chart=297

 

------------------------------ E8400 3.6Ghz | 4GB DDR2-800 | HD4870 | 780GB HDD Space | VX550W | WinXP | Win7-64 | Ubuntu Studio 8.10

 

Reply to doomsdaydave11

This motherboard will work with a 8800 GT won't it. http://tw.giga-byte.com/Products/M [...] uctID=2381

Reply to Dark Comet

Waspy wrote :

Neither! 2x 8800 GTS G92 512MB...worth the very small price increase.

 


 

nuh uh!

 

And @ Dark Comet, I must say that that you definitely do not want to get that motherboard... get this one or something similar. Good all around: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813128014

 

But to answer your question, it will work.


Message edited by doomsdaydave11 on 04-08-2008 at 01:56:40 AM
------------------------------ E8400 3.6Ghz | 4GB DDR2-800 | HD4870 | 780GB HDD Space | VX550W | WinXP | Win7-64 | Ubuntu Studio 8.10

 

Reply to doomsdaydave11

Ok cheers. I already have that motherboard. I'm going to upgrade it soon anyway.

Reply to Dark Comet

Dark Comet wrote :

I know that EVGA does that Step up thing which XFX does not do. I've heard that people like EVGA but I have not heard much about XFX. The EVGA graphics card I am looking at according to Komplett.co.uk has 120 months warranty!


120 month warranty is not bad, XFX give a double lifetime warranty however and as far as I know they don't mind aftermarket coolers or overclocking so long as you revert the card back to standard should you have to RMA it but I've never had one go bad so I cannot say how good or bad the customer service is.

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1] http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg
Reply to mousemonkey

The XFX one I was looking at had 24 months. I don't think i'll need to overclock a 8800 GT for a while. :)

Reply to Dark Comet
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > 8800GTX V 9800GTX V 2 X 8800GT
Go to:

There are 930 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them