Tom's Hardware Forums » CPU & Components » Power Supplies, PC Cases & Case Mods » Help me choose... Antec 300 vs. Coolermaster 590
 

Help me choose... Antec 300 vs. Coolermaster 590

Add a reply



Antec 300 vs. Coolermaster 590


 
20.0 %
 3 votes
1.  Antec 300 $55.00
 
 
40.0 %
 6 votes
2.  Coolermaster 590 $65.00
 
 
40.0 %
 6 votes
3.  Other - Comment in the thread pls.
 

All : 21 votes (6 blank votes)
This poll is closed, you cannot vote
 Word :   Username :  
 
 Page :   1  2
Previous 
Author
 Thread : Help me choose... Antec 300 vs. Coolermaster 590
 
Profile: member
More Information

Need help choosing.
 
Best reasons for the coolermaster I can think of are the 2 to 120 mm fan holes which look perfect for watercooling (very long term, probably never),  no hard to find 140 mm fan like the antec, and a front 1384 port.
 
Best reasons for the antec, it's an antec, price, appearance, hinged front panel and fan mounts.
 
I want to use this with an earthwatts 500 that I already have, so the ATX main 24 pin power cable length may be an issue.
 
http://www.coolermaster.com/produc [...] il&id=3927
 
http://www.antec.com/us/productDet [...] odID=15300

Related Pr oduct
Register or log in to remove.

Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

The Cooler Master RC690 is an outstanding case at a very inexpensive price although a little higher than the ones your looking at.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811119137
 
If I had to choose between the two you listed I would go with the Cooler Master but you should really look at the 690.


---------------
http://i192.photobucket.com/albums/z311/AUsch30/badge_wtp_02_3001.jpg
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
Aristotle
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

<also agrees with ausch30

Profile: Forum Veteran
More Information

I've built with the Coolermaster Centurion and more recently with the Antec 300.  Both have excellent cooling capabilities with the mesh front panels.  I got the Antec 300 for $49 about 10 days ago.  Great price, great case.  The 300 has the PSU mounted in the bottom of the case, so make sure you have a PSU with a long 24 pin and 4/8 pin 12v leads.  The Antec 300 takes it.  I also looked at the Coolermaster 690 at Fry's.  It's a very nice nice case I would like to buy soon.  Can't go wrong there.

Be Crazy...there are careful people out there!
Profile: journeyman
More Information

<also agrees with ausch30 and runswindows95
I have this case. It can hold alot of fans,a lot of space for all components. EXCELLENT AIR FLOW!
Very easy for wire mgmt.

Profile: member
More Information

Other than Front Port Placement and Cosmetic Differences what is the difference between the 590 and 690?  ( I like the look & port placement of the 590 better)


Message edited by Cyborg28 on 05-15-2008 at 03:49:29 PM

---------------
Black Hackint0sh Pro
Antec EarthWatts 500, Coolermaster 690, Intel Q6600 @ 3.0 GHz, Xigmatek S1283 HSF, Asus P5K-VM Mobo, nVidia 7600GT 256MB, 250 GB Seagate 7200.10 SATA HDD, IDE DVD-RW
http://valid.x86-secret.com/cache/banner/393560.png
The Order Odonata
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

ausch30 wrote :

...but you should really look at the 690.


 
+1  
 
You may also want to look at the Thermaltake M9 http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811133059 or http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811133058

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by halcyon on 05-15-2008 at 04:15:00 PM

---------------
Q9450 | Rampage Formula + 8GB OCZ Reaper 1066 | Plenty of RAID 0 storage | X-Fi XGFP + Logitech Z5500 + Firestone Cute Beyond Headphone Amp & Spitfire DAC + Grado SR325i & Senn HD595 | 8800GTX + 30" & 21" LCDs
Reformulated with 20 percent less ahole !
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

coolermaster, because you get the firewire port too. DAMN, I woulda bought one of those instead of my 532 if they had em at newegg !


---------------
X2 5400 + 780gm-a ATX, 2 gig mushkin, 8800gts 512 , CM 532
 
"Now if the 4870x2 was actually notably faster than the 280 for about the same price, then I might even take a chance on it.  However, that won't be the case."-robx46
Reformulated with 20 percent less ahole !
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information


 
 -1..Thermaltake = FUGLY !
 


---------------
X2 5400 + 780gm-a ATX, 2 gig mushkin, 8800gts 512 , CM 532
 
"Now if the 4870x2 was actually notably faster than the 280 for about the same price, then I might even take a chance on it.  However, that won't be the case."-robx46
Profile: member
More Information

Not a fan of Thermaltake Cases.  
 
WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A 590 & A 690?!?!?!?
 
Please.... Somebody... Anybody?
 
...It's my thread and I'll shout if I want to, shout if I want too....

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

The 690 is bigger and comes with an extra fan.

Reformulated with 20 percent less ahole !
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

As far as the main cable length don't worry...you can safely use an extension.
 
example:
 
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6812162006


---------------
X2 5400 + 780gm-a ATX, 2 gig mushkin, 8800gts 512 , CM 532
 
"Now if the 4870x2 was actually notably faster than the 280 for about the same price, then I might even take a chance on it.  However, that won't be the case."-robx46
Profile: member
More Information

royalcrown wrote :

As far as the main cable length don't worry...you can safely use an extension.


 
Aaargh!  Will I need to?  Will the smaller 590 reduce the chances of this? I WILL NEVER run CF or SLI & I have a server for storage.
 
Why the heck to these cases not come with these if it is a regular issue?

Ironhide: Why are we fighting to save the humans?
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

runswindows95 wrote :

The 690 is bigger and comes with an extra fan.

I think they use the same sidepanels (so I'm not sure about the size difference).
The 590 has a 4 drive cage while the 690 has 5 trays for HDDs.
The 590 also lacks cable management (stock) but you can always do it yourself.
The rest is details like foam padding for PSU on the 690 and the plastic trim on top of the 690.


Message edited by Andrius on 05-15-2008 at 07:53:47 PM
Profile: addict
More Information

If you are planning on getting the 300 at newegg for $70, you might consider spending an extra $10 to get the Antec 900 for $80 after $40.00 in rebates.  For $10 more you are getting another $50 of case - and it is considered an excellent case.  You might not need the extra size now, but you might grow into it.  The nice thing about cases is that they can last a little longer than a cpu - and take you through several generations.
 
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811129021

The Order Odonata
Profile: Honorary Poster
More Information

That's why I wish the Lian-Li A70 I got ~month ago was less expensive.  I wish more people could get to experience that kind of quality.  Anywho, I'd pick the Antec 300 over the 900 even if the 900 was cheaper than the 300, but I know the 900 is a popular "gamers" case.


Message edited by halcyon on 05-15-2008 at 08:43:01 PM

---------------
Q9450 | Rampage Formula + 8GB OCZ Reaper 1066 | Plenty of RAID 0 storage | X-Fi XGFP + Logitech Z5500 + Firestone Cute Beyond Headphone Amp & Spitfire DAC + Grado SR325i & Senn HD595 | 8800GTX + 30" & 21" LCDs
Profile: addict
More Information

i strongly recommend the cooler master cm 690 case.

Please leash your dogma!
Profile: member
More Information

rockyjohn wrote :

If you are planning on getting the 300 at newegg for $70, you might consider spending an extra $10 to get the Antec 900 for $80 after $40.00 in rebates.  For $10 more you are getting another $50 of case - and it is considered an excellent case.  You might not need the extra size now, but you might grow into it.  The nice thing about cases is that they can last a little longer than a cpu - and take you through several generations.
 
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6811129021


 
I would say the Coolermaster.  But if the Antec is on sale--GRAB IT!  Aim for the top, and then have no regrets!!!


---------------
e2180 at 3.2 GHz with AC Freezer 7 Pro | MSI P35 Neo2 FR | HIS HD3870 ICEQ3 | 4 GB OCZ Reaper DDR2 800| 250 GB WD Caviar | 600 Watt OCZ StealthExtreme | Antec 900 | XP Pro
Profile: member
More Information

I'm in Canada so No NewEgg for me.

 

CM 690 will be $75, Antec 900 $100, CM 590 $70, Antec 300 $55.

 

I don't need the space, this rig was in an Ultra MiroFly SFF

 

I'm looking for Cooling,  efficient use of space, front (not top) ports & conservative good looks.
The only thing the 690 has going for it for me is Cable Management.  Something the 300 & 590 lack.

 

I find the thought of water cooling intriguing but will probably never do it.  I take my rig apart way too often.

 

This won't have anything over an *600 (1600/2600/7600/8600/9600) series video card in it. Midrange price/performance in 3D is fine for me.

 

*EDIT*

 

Vote People!   Over 200 views and under 10 votes.  For Shame!  Come on and exercise your democratic right (to slightly influence my highly biased decision).

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by Cyborg28 on 05-15-2008 at 09:04:52 PM
Please leash your dogma!
Profile: member
More Information

CM 690 is a classic.  I actually bought it on sale over the Antec 900--but Microcenter stiffed me a week later and canceled my order saying they were out of product6.  I see it as a functional equivalent to the 900--slightly different, with different strengths and weaknesses, but excellent either way.
 
I got the '900 and am happy.  But my brother DID manage to get the 690 and he is happy with it.  I think the 690 looks a bit better, and I suspect it is built a bit better.
 
I know you have to draw the line somewhere, but the 590 is a no-brainer over the 300, and for $5, the 690 is DEFINITELY a no-brainer over the 590.  Get the 690 and don't look back!!!


---------------
e2180 at 3.2 GHz with AC Freezer 7 Pro | MSI P35 Ne