Tom's Hardware Forums » CPU & Components » CPUs » The 200 Dollar Difference
 

The 200 Dollar Difference




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : The 200 Dollar Difference
 
Profile: newbie
More Information

Hi guys,

I've been pricing out some computers lately (yes, I know, if I could build one, I would, but I really need the piece of mind with the warranty and I've heard too many horror stories about people messing up their CPU's and other components when building it themselves)...

Anyway, there are 2 different models that I'm looking at, and for all intensive purposes (slight mobo discrepancy), the specs are exactly the same: dual 8800GT's, 4gb ddr2 RAM, 500GB 7200 rpm hd, same sound card, etc etc etc...

The price difference between the 2 is just around $200. One of the computers has a q9450 in it, and the more expensive one has a QX6850 in it. As the charts on this site don't have the q9450 on them yet, it's hard for me to make a comparison between the two.

I'm going to be using the computer for gaming (especially flight simulator), photo editing, and DJ'ing, among other things. I plan on OC'ing the processor, but I'm not into hardcore nitrogen cooling etc...

Does the extra 200 bucks justify the performance difference that I would get?

Thanks very much,
Chris

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Play that funky music, white boy!
Profile: addict
More Information

Go for the Q9450, I would, overclocking will be a breeze and you might get another 600 or more MHz out of it! The QX6850 is faster stock and has an unlocked multiplier, but I personally would go for the Q9450 every time.

j


---------------
Athlon 6000+, GeForce 6600 256mb, GeIL 2GBs D/C DDR2 800 @ 4-4-4-12, MSI K9N Ultra nForce 570,250Gb,Sony 17" SXGA, X-550 5.1
Profile: nimble knuckle

^ q9450... worth it... maybe not 200$ but if t was smaller it would be worth it

Profile: old hand
More Information

Companies often charge a lot to add extra RAM to a system. You might be able to save a few bucks by purchasing yours with only 2x 1GB of memory and purchasing another set to match and install yourself.

Profile: old hand
More Information

jonisginger wrote :

Go for the Q9450, I would, overclocking will be a breeze and you might get another 600 or more MHz out of it! The QX6850 is faster stock and has an unlocked multiplier, but I personally would go for the Q9450 every time.

j



You may or may not even be able to overclock depending on the bios used. There is really nothing to worry about as far as building your own. There are plenty of people here and other resources on the web to make sure you do it right. If you build your own, you will know what ram is being used,ect, but the most important component, and this is my opinion, is the power supply that is used. There are too many prebuilts that come with CRAP power supplies, that will in turn damage other parts of the rig. I do agree if going with this, get the Q9450 , but you should also try a build, the satisfaction you will have when you get it going really makes it worth it.


---------------
Opinions are like asses,everybody has one.
Sniper
Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

^+1 for DIY PC.


---------------
E2180 @3.2Ghz + P35DS3L +8400GS (700/475 OC)
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3268/2588429538_b3c41b29c3.jpg
Profile: nimble knuckle

^ +2 for +1ing the DIY PC

Play that funky music, white boy!
Profile: addict
More Information

^+3 for +2ing the +1ing of a DIY PC


---------------
Athlon 6000+, GeForce 6600 256mb, GeIL 2GBs D/C DDR2 800 @ 4-4-4-12, MSI K9N Ultra nForce 570,250Gb,Sony 17" SXGA, X-550 5.1
Profile: addict
More Information

^+4 for +3ing the DIY pc.

Its easy dont be afraid. If you can cook a meal, you can build a computer! ;)


---------------
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L*Intel E2180 OC 3.00Ghz Lapped*PowerColor ATI 3850 256MB*Patriot 2x1GB DDR2 800*Cooler Master CM690*Western Digital 250 GB*Silverstone Strider 600 Watt Modular PSU*Samsung Lightscribe Drive*CoolerMaster Geminni II Lapped Mirror Finish
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

wait for the new lines of video cards to come out un 2 weeks.

i would buy a ps tester for about $20. trust me you want one. i built a $2500 system for my freind and i had a bad ps so it freid the mobo, cpu, video card, hard drives. that was a bad experience

Ninja Vanish!!
Profile: addict
More Information

+4 for +3ing the +2ing the +1ing of a DIY PC

there are countless guides that can help you get going. If I fail to convince you, then I would go with the Q9450. Just with the fact that the 45nm cores are about 5-10% faster clock for clock (depending on the app) with the obvious addition of L2 cache. As well as others said, just wait 2 weeks, twooo more weeks, and all will be right in the world. The GPU world that is. ^.^


---------------
// Intel C2D E6750 @ 3.2ghz 1.35v // Asus P5K P35 // 2gb Patriot 1000mhz // Sapphire HD4850 @700core 1100mem // Antec neo 500 HE // Antec 900 // SB X-FI // WD 250gb Sata-2 //
Profile: newbie
More Information

+6 the+4 for +3ing the +2ing the +1ing of a DIY PC

lol my brother in grade 6 could do it :P of course i had to help im i was in grade 9 :P


---------------
Gigabyte DS3 rev. 3.3
Intel e4300@3 ghz
Patriot 6400 4-4-4-12
eVGA8800 GTS
The Order Odonata - We do what we must
Profile: Faithful Poster
More Information

If you believe you have the aptitude, patience, and and would enjoy it I'd have to agree to DIY.

 

If you just want an already working and warrantied PC ...get a Dell (or equivalent).

 

If you buy a prebuilt you'll soon see that the parts they put in it are likely of lower quality and more expensive than what you could have purchased, built, and took pride in. As long as you're cool with that then buying a pre-built can be, cough, cough, okay.


Message edited by halcyon on 06-03-2008 at 03:18:50 AM

---------------
Yes, I use an Intel Quad. Sometimes its a little overclocked, sometimes a bit underclocked. Yet, its always nice and the virtualiztion is sick. And?
Profile: old hand
More Information

Also keep in mind that additional benefits of building are:
1. You know how it was put together and should have an easier time if you have to repair something, or if you just want to upgrade.
2. You can overclock for additional performance gains that you usually cannot do on a purchased rig
3. For the cost savings - don't forget that purchased warranties usually last no more than one year - unless you pay even more
4. The bigger cost savings come not with the first build but with the major upgrades - when you get an almost new system by upgrading just the mobo, memory, and cpu or when you build a "completely" new system but reuse many parts from the old - cases and drives. This can be a huge savings - right now I can rennovate an Intel, on the low end side, with a new DS3L mobo, E8400, and 4 GB of DDR2 memory for about $400 instead of buying a new comparable Dell machine for about $900.
5. The pride that comes with the accomplishment.

Never the less, don't byo unless you feel comfortable with it and are willing to invest a little time the first time. BYO is not for everyone.

Sniper
Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information
Profile: newbie
More Information

Well I've been thinking of building my own computer for a while now, but the problem has been the family, who thinks that there's more piece of mind with buying a pre-built computer.

On the off chance that I do end up building one, can someone direct me to a web page or even book that describes at least the correct order for setting up the computer (especially software, drivers, etc)?