Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > Did I make a mistake ordering a e8400?

Did I make a mistake ordering a e8400?

Forum CPU & Components : CPUs - Did I make a mistake ordering a e8400?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

I ordered a E8400 for a mATX setup I'm building, and now notice the Q6600 is basicly the same price. Should I have gone with the q6600 and just clocked it at 3Ghz?

I was not planning on overclocking at first, but it seems to me 3ghz x4 would multitask a bit better than 3Ghz x 2

My original theory was to get the Duo core now, and upgrade in a year or so to a higher clock Quad when the prices come down.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Impossible to answer since you didn't mention what you planned on using your rig for. Are you multitasking or are you MULTITASKING? There is a difference.

Reply to rodney_ws

Hi good people,

in my opinion , OS still don't require this 4 cores processor ,
but there are some Engineering like IVUS that require 4 cores .
if you are dealing with some programs like this , you should get the quad.
if you don't and you use your pc for games, I think dual is just fine .
you can overclock it and it would work great .

by the way in Hebrew there is a phrase that when someone is starting to grow up later than all the people , he will grow more than the other people,
so I say wait a year, you will get something much better I believe.

but still its really depends on what your planning to do with this machine.

Best regards,
Noam .

Reply to hnml24

Mostly Web Browsing, some video conversions (Apple ipod Touch & a couple other branded MP3 players in the house) and a little gaming.

I also will have 4GB Ram & 8800GT video as well on a 7200.11 Seagate SATA drive.

Reply to y2kgtp

The quad might help with the video work depending on the software you use...

If you're building a mATX system, I assume it's in a SFF case? If so, the cooler unOCd 8400 would definitely be the better choice.

Reply to mi1ez

You are getting a matx MB , I'm not sure if there are really good OCing MATX mb's ... are there?

So if it isn't a good overclocking MB don't worry about it cause you might not have gotten much more out of the Q6600.

Reply to cah027

y2kgtp wrote :

Mostly Web Browsing, some video conversions (Apple ipod Touch & a couple other branded MP3 players in the house) and a little gaming.

 

I also will have 4GB Ram & 8800GT video as well on a 7200.11 Seagate SATA drive.

 

You don't need a quad core.

Reply to jitpublisher

cah027 wrote :

You are getting a matx MB , I'm not sure if there are really good OCing MATX mb's ... are there?

So if it isn't a good overclocking MB don't worry about it cause you might not have gotten much more out of the Q6600.



I ordered this: GIGABYTE GA-G31M-S2L LGA 775 Intel G31 Micro ATX Intel Motherboard
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813128078

It had numerous references to easy & simple overclocking in the reviews section. such as this:

"
4/28/2008 7:08:28 AM

Rating + 5Rating + 5Rating + 5Rating + 5Rating + 5 Great budget board

"Pros: Feature-laden for mATX, stable, easy to OC, placement of ports. Booted right up out of the box.

Cons: None whatsoever. It's a mATX board, so it doesn't have all the bells & whistles, but these are fully disclosed on the product page, so you only have yourself to blame if it doesn't have what you need & you inexplicably order it anyway.

Other Thoughts: Assembled this with an E6850, 2x1gb Mushkin DDR2-800, & an EVGA 7600GT. Overclocked to 3.6ghz in about 5 minutes; tested stable for 24 hours. Bumped OC up to 3.8ghz, stable for 2 hours thus far. Probably will be able to hit 4ghz.
"



Reply to y2kgtp

Heh...

You really can't go wrong with either.

And if your running Vista64 bit, I'd highly recommend a 4 core CPU.

Vista64 bit will make use of all 4 cores better then XP.

Reply to Grimmy

And vista 64 also runs fine on just 2 cores...

------------------------------ E8500,GA-EP45-UD3R, 8 GIG MUSHKIN, XFX 4890 , ASUS 22", WD 640 X 2, CM 532, CM 650TX
Reply to royalcrown

I'll prob just run Vista Ultimate (32bit) or XP Pro 32bit.....I got a copy of a bunch of x64 installs I wanted to try (XP & 2k3) just have not bothered yet....

Reply to y2kgtp

you're better off with a penryn quad.

Reply to wh3resmycar

wh3resmycar wrote :

you're better off with a penryn quad.



Can I borrow your CC? :lol:

It prob costs more than my entire build +500$ or so.....

Reply to y2kgtp

OC your 8400 @1:1 with ddr2 800 ram is 3.6. It will handle it easy.

Reply to roadrunner197069

roadrunner197069 wrote :

OC your 8400 @1:1 with ddr2 800 ram is 3.6. It will handle it easy.



Sounds good to me :D

I think I will be happy enough for a few days at stock clock....coming from a P4 2.8Ghz....

Reply to y2kgtp

With a small case, there are usually cooling problems that prevent overclocking much. So you will get better performance with an e8400 than a q6600.

------------------------------ Google is your friend and Bob's your uncle
Reply to evongugg

I build atleast one setup like yours every week. Sometimes more. I always slap the mobo on the table with cpu, HS, ram, and turn it on to bios. From there i change the FSB to 400 and ram to 800 then i drop the multi down to 8. Restart and its running 3.2, check temps in Bios to make sure all is well. Then I insatall windows, realtemp, CPU-Z, Prime95 and do some testing. When all is well i bump the multi back to 9, and sometimes bump the FSB and Ram higher if I am using ram that can go higher the 800.

Reply to roadrunner197069

evongugg wrote :

With a small case, there are usually cooling problems that prevent overclocking much. So you will get better performance with an e8400 than a q6600.



Just part of the challenge!

Actually, the case supports 120mm fan in the front, and a 120mm fan in the back....and both will be variable speed with external control. I also have a 80mm fan (also adjustable) that will mount to the side of the case. Not sure if I will use the side fan, or not yet.....

The manufacturer was also unsure if I could fit a 8800GT card inside, but all I see it hitting is part of the drive cage bay, which can be easily modified.

Front intake fan mounts at the bottom.

http://img501.imageshack.us/img501/5982/mypicture1da2.jpg

Reply to y2kgtp

The 8800GT will fit and with room to spare. the case is almost identicle to the ones I use.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by roadrunner197069 on 06-16-2008 at 08:35:08 PM
Reply to roadrunner197069

roadrunner197069 wrote :

The 8800GT will fit and with room to spare. the case is almost identicle to the ones I use.



Thanks for the info..I thought it would fit.....

I was thinking of painting the inside black, as I might do a window of some sort in the future.....

Reply to y2kgtp

If you even think you might paint it, do it now!

Reply to roadrunner197069

roadrunner197069 wrote :

If you even think you might paint it, do it now!



That's what I was thinking.....Case & monitor show up today....rest of the 'box-o-parts' is for tomorrow. Will give me something to do
tonight......

Reply to y2kgtp

I'd go with some UV paint if your gonna do a window.
The bad thing about a window in that case is wire management is difficult in such a case.

Reply to roadrunner197069

roadrunner197069 wrote :

I'd go with some UV paint if your gonna do a window.
The bad thing about a window in that case is wire management is difficult in such a case.



I figured....I have not decided what I want to do, but all the fans are blue LED, including the CPU cooler. might be
nice....

At least it should glow from the vents.....

Reply to y2kgtp

My case and monitor showed up today. I did relieve how big a 22" widescreen was. Waiting for my wife's reaction still as she has not seen it yet.

for 25$, the case is excellent. I decided not to paint, as I just can cut out a window over the mATX board only, thus hiding everything else (drive cage, PSU, etc) This thing will work just fine, and have excellent flow.

Reply to y2kgtp

Cool. I use my 42" TV for my monitor.

Reply to roadrunner197069

Stick with the E8400.

Yes, the Q6600 can improve video encoding speed a little bit if you use the right program and codec. The E8400 has SSE4 the Q6600 doesn't, plus the E8400 clock is higher than the Q6600. Finally, it will dissipate less heat. That's important in a mATX case.

SSE4 are basically multimedia extension that codecs can take advantage of to decrease encoding times; in other words process more frames per second.

Keep the E8400. Period.

------------------------------ Q9450 |Corsair XMS 4GB DDR 800 | ABit IP35 Pro | HD 5850 | Audigy 2 | Seasonic S12 550 | Cooler Master Centurion 532 | NEC LCD2690WUXi and Planar PX2611w | WinXP

Peace on Earth by means of the destruction of all life on Earth.
Reply to jaguarskx
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > Did I make a mistake ordering a e8400?
Go to:

There are 1191 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them