Background
I've recently been needing to expand my storage on my local machine, and decided to invest in a RAID solution for home use.
I wanted a number of things though out of this,
■I wanted something that will survive hard disk failures. Touch wood, my 1TB hard disk that I've filled has not failed. But losing over 1 TB of data seems insane.
■I really wanted something with a lot of space. So going from 1 TB to 2, just seemed like the need to upgrade in less than a couple of years.
■DLNA looks like an amazing suite of technologies. The whole point of NAS is streaming media, with DLNA support I can play it back over my PS3 or XBOX 360 that are already hooked up to my T.V.
I looked around, and initially went with the Buffalo Linkstation Quad. RAID5, DLNA, and 3 TBs of usable disk space.
For approximately 4 weeks it worked a treat. DLNA to PS3 worked a treat, although transfer rates were a bit poor if you ask me 10 MB/s (I was on a hundred mbit connection at the time).
After those 4 blissful weeks, streaming to my PS3 just stopped working. I mean everything worked fine, just it did like a frame every 20 seconds or so in standard definition videos, let alone HD...
Two weeks of attempted troubleshooting, and support cases with Buffalo, the Quad has been safely returned to Amazon (kudos to them for accepting a return after 6 weeks), and I am now in the market for a NAs solution again.
So with all of these lessons learned, these are going to be my new requirements
Requirements
■RAID 5 still seems like a must. So minimum 3 drives
■Minimum 3 TBs usable space
■I liked the Buffalo's small form factor. Mini-ITX or smaller is the way forward
■I liked the Buffalo's quiet demeanor, the more silent the better.
■One of the troubleshooting steps was the purchase of a gig-e switch. 10-20 MB/s on a gig-e connection is just taking the piss, specially when I know wire speed is 80 MB/s +, and 3-4 disks can easily sustain that.
■Can not be proprietary. if I can't login and run ethereal + top/taskmgr to figure out wtf is draining the NAS device's performance from DLNA, I ain't using it.
■The days of working DLNA were like a sweet dream, I'd really like them back.
So after a huge amount of research here is what I've come down to
1. For small form factor, and quiet, I want an Atom motherboard
2. For decent speed, I want either a
a. Decent RAID controller that can handle 4 drives, OR
b. 3 or 5 drives so I can setup the block size / stripe size just right, align up the stars, and get my gig-e wire speed.
3. For non proprietary, and DLNA, I want Linux support and PS3 Media server
4. For 3 TBs of disk space I can,
a. Use 3 1.5 TB disks
b. 4 or 5 1 TB disks (I have two already so this would be cheaper for me)
c. If form factor is an issue, do something silly like 2 x 2.5 inch drives in every 3.5 inch drive bay. E.g. 6/8 2.5 inch drives will meet the requirements
Hardware
Case will be Chenbro ES34069. Meets requirement 1, and the largest mini itx case I could find in terms of number of drive bays for requirements 2 and 4
Mobo, I'm really torn on this,
■ Jetway JNC92-330 + Jetway 4x SATA Daughterboard, meets requirements + 5 3.5 inch disks + CF for OS disk. Meets 2b, and 4, assumes I can do RAID 5 across controllers in software, assumes tha Atom RAID 5 in software is decent, and assumes I can somehow magically fit 5 3.5 inch drives in the 4 bay case...
■ MSI IM-945GC-A + 4 3.5 inch disks + CF for OS disk, Meets 2a, and 4. Assumes that software RAID 5 on an ICH7 (note the absence of R in the name) will perform fine. Intel storage controllers are supposed to perform ok even when the stars don't line up.
■Some ION mobo (POV for e.g.), + 3 x 1.5 TB disks + CF for OS disk. Meets 2b, and 4. Assumes that there is an ION board with 3 SATA ports, and an IDE for CF. Good news is there are no physical constraints by the case, but I am back to stars aligning for decent RAID 5 performance.
Note that I had to eliminate decent hardware RAID 5 because of the case size. So the beautiful Adaptec SATA RAID 5 controllers are a no no unless someone can conjure up a better case than the Chenbro.
Anyhow long post over, I'm interested in hearing all ideas about the above, experiences and thoughts. If you don't like my ideas you know what I'm after so please post away.
PS. If you don't know what I mean by stars aligning for decent RAID 5 performance, read this exceptional and amazing post, http://forums.storagereview.net/index.php?showtopic=25786
[Edit]
Updated for drunkness
I've recently been needing to expand my storage on my local machine, and decided to invest in a RAID solution for home use.
I wanted a number of things though out of this,
■I wanted something that will survive hard disk failures. Touch wood, my 1TB hard disk that I've filled has not failed. But losing over 1 TB of data seems insane.
■I really wanted something with a lot of space. So going from 1 TB to 2, just seemed like the need to upgrade in less than a couple of years.
■DLNA looks like an amazing suite of technologies. The whole point of NAS is streaming media, with DLNA support I can play it back over my PS3 or XBOX 360 that are already hooked up to my T.V.
I looked around, and initially went with the Buffalo Linkstation Quad. RAID5, DLNA, and 3 TBs of usable disk space.
For approximately 4 weeks it worked a treat. DLNA to PS3 worked a treat, although transfer rates were a bit poor if you ask me 10 MB/s (I was on a hundred mbit connection at the time).
After those 4 blissful weeks, streaming to my PS3 just stopped working. I mean everything worked fine, just it did like a frame every 20 seconds or so in standard definition videos, let alone HD...
Two weeks of attempted troubleshooting, and support cases with Buffalo, the Quad has been safely returned to Amazon (kudos to them for accepting a return after 6 weeks), and I am now in the market for a NAs solution again.
So with all of these lessons learned, these are going to be my new requirements
Requirements
■RAID 5 still seems like a must. So minimum 3 drives
■Minimum 3 TBs usable space
■I liked the Buffalo's small form factor. Mini-ITX or smaller is the way forward
■I liked the Buffalo's quiet demeanor, the more silent the better.
■One of the troubleshooting steps was the purchase of a gig-e switch. 10-20 MB/s on a gig-e connection is just taking the piss, specially when I know wire speed is 80 MB/s +, and 3-4 disks can easily sustain that.
■Can not be proprietary. if I can't login and run ethereal + top/taskmgr to figure out wtf is draining the NAS device's performance from DLNA, I ain't using it.
■The days of working DLNA were like a sweet dream, I'd really like them back.
So after a huge amount of research here is what I've come down to
1. For small form factor, and quiet, I want an Atom motherboard
2. For decent speed, I want either a
a. Decent RAID controller that can handle 4 drives, OR
b. 3 or 5 drives so I can setup the block size / stripe size just right, align up the stars, and get my gig-e wire speed.
3. For non proprietary, and DLNA, I want Linux support and PS3 Media server
4. For 3 TBs of disk space I can,
a. Use 3 1.5 TB disks
b. 4 or 5 1 TB disks (I have two already so this would be cheaper for me)
c. If form factor is an issue, do something silly like 2 x 2.5 inch drives in every 3.5 inch drive bay. E.g. 6/8 2.5 inch drives will meet the requirements
Hardware
Case will be Chenbro ES34069. Meets requirement 1, and the largest mini itx case I could find in terms of number of drive bays for requirements 2 and 4
Mobo, I'm really torn on this,
■ Jetway JNC92-330 + Jetway 4x SATA Daughterboard, meets requirements + 5 3.5 inch disks + CF for OS disk. Meets 2b, and 4, assumes I can do RAID 5 across controllers in software, assumes tha Atom RAID 5 in software is decent, and assumes I can somehow magically fit 5 3.5 inch drives in the 4 bay case...
■ MSI IM-945GC-A + 4 3.5 inch disks + CF for OS disk, Meets 2a, and 4. Assumes that software RAID 5 on an ICH7 (note the absence of R in the name) will perform fine. Intel storage controllers are supposed to perform ok even when the stars don't line up.
■Some ION mobo (POV for e.g.), + 3 x 1.5 TB disks + CF for OS disk. Meets 2b, and 4. Assumes that there is an ION board with 3 SATA ports, and an IDE for CF. Good news is there are no physical constraints by the case, but I am back to stars aligning for decent RAID 5 performance.
Note that I had to eliminate decent hardware RAID 5 because of the case size. So the beautiful Adaptec SATA RAID 5 controllers are a no no unless someone can conjure up a better case than the Chenbro.
Anyhow long post over, I'm interested in hearing all ideas about the above, experiences and thoughts. If you don't like my ideas you know what I'm after so please post away.
PS. If you don't know what I mean by stars aligning for decent RAID 5 performance, read this exceptional and amazing post, http://forums.storagereview.net/index.php?showtopic=25786
[Edit]
Updated for drunkness