Rookie question




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : Rookie question
 
Profile: stranger
More Information

Ok I have a novice question. When a graphics board says:

Minimum 550 Watt for SLI mode system.
Minimum recommended power supply with +12 Volt current rating of 34 Amps

Does that mean 34 amps per a +12 rail? That seems pretty high. I'm asking because I run 2 7900GT's on a 450w PSU and believe it's causing poor graphics results in my games.


Message edited by blink on 05-19-2008 at 06:51:46 AM
Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

That would be 34 amps total on the 12 V rails


---------------
Every artist is a cannibal,every poet is a thief,they all kill their inspiration then sing about their grief
Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

34 amps total on the combined 12v rail(s). And that is minimum for the two 7900Gts not including the rest of your system. Basically all the major hardware in your system uses the amperage from the 12v rail.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

badge wrote :

34 amps total on the combined 12v rail(s). And that is minimum for the two 7900Gts not including the rest of your system. Basically all the major hardware in your system uses the amperage from the 12v rail.



No, the 34A is a guideline that includes the whole system. Mathematically, two 7900GTs together can't draw more than 24A, and their actual draw is closer to 16A.

OP, 450W is pushing it even if your PSU is a high quality unit.

-G


---------------
q6600|Asus P5K|2x2GB G.Skill PC6400|2x320MB 7200.10|8800GT SC|Zalman ZM600
Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

Well, your computers main hardware hard drives, RAM, video cards, etc. all draw from the amperage of your 12v rail(s). My statement is correct. I am speaking in general terms. The 34 amps needed is 'minimum', not a 'guideline'. Of course the cards will fluctuate with power usage under load.

Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

Everything I said is absolutely 100% correct. Guidelines? 34 amps is minimum, not a 'guideline'.

jsc
Profile: old hand
More Information

OK: carver_g estimates 16 amps for video cards. I think that's a little high, but I am not certain enough to argue. Besides, you cannot get in trouble overestimating the power needed.

10 amps for the CPU, 15 amps for a really hot, late generation P4
Figure about 3 amps @ 12 volts and 3 amps @ 5 volts for the motherboard, 1.5 amps @ 3.3 volts for each GB of RAM (memory draws from the 3.3.volt rail).

Hard drives need about a amp each at 5 volts and 12 volts. DVD burners need about 2 amps @ 12 volts and 2.5 amps at 5 volts. Figure 1 amp @12 volts for every three or four fans.

For a PC with 2 GB of RAM and single hard and optical drives, that's about 33 amps (372 watts) at 12 volts and 42 watts for everything else. That's about 420 watts. So a good 450 w PSU with 34 - 35 amps on the 12 volt rails would work. I like to add 20% for Mr. Murphy. That takes you to 500 watts.

I would power a system like this with a 600 - 650 watt PSU. I don't like running a PSU at more than a 60 - 70% load - but that's my military background speaking.

So there you go. Several paths to the 34 amp estimate.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information


badge wrote :

Everything I said is absolutely 100% correct.




badge wrote :

34 amps total on the combined 12v rail(s). And that is minimum for the two 7900Gts not including the rest of your system.



That last sentence is absolutely 100% incorrect.


---------------
q6600|Asus P5K|2x2GB G.Skill PC6400|2x320MB 7200.10|8800GT SC|Zalman ZM600
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

badge wrote :

Everything I said is absolutely 100% correct. Guidelines? 34 amps is minimum, not a 'guideline'.



Technically, it's 'minimum recommended'.


---------------
q6600|Asus P5K|2x2GB G.Skill PC6400|2x320MB 7200.10|8800GT SC|Zalman ZM600
Profile: enthusiast
More Information

jsc wrote :

OK: carver_g estimates 16 amps for video cards. I think that's a little high, but I am not certain enough to argue. Besides, you cannot get in trouble overestimating the power needed.

10 amps for the CPU, 15 amps for a really hot, late generation P4
Figure about 3 amps @ 12 volts and 3 amps @ 5 volts for the motherboard, 1.5 amps @ 3.3 volts for each GB of RAM (memory draws from the 3.3.volt rail).

Hard drives need about a amp each at 5 volts and 12 volts. DVD burners need about 2 amps @ 12 volts and 2.5 amps at 5 volts. Figure 1 amp @12 volts for every three or four fans.

For a PC with 2 GB of RAM and single hard and optical drives, that's about 33 amps (372 watts) at 12 volts and 42 watts for everything else. That's about 420 watts. So a good 450 w PSU with 34 - 35 amps on the 12 volt rails would work. I like to add 20% for Mr. Murphy. That takes you to 500 watts.

I would power a system like this with a 600 - 650 watt PSU. I don't like running a PSU at more than a 60 - 70% load - but that's my military background speaking.

So there you go. Several paths to the 34 amp estimate.



That's a fair summary. What the OP really needs to do is use the extreme PSU calculator himself since he didn't list any other of his system components.


---------------
q6600|Asus P5K|2x2GB G.Skill PC6400|2x320MB 7200.10|8800GT SC|Zalman ZM600
Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

Quote :

No, the 34A is a guideline that includes the whole system.



The 34A is the minimum requirement stated by the manufacturer of the 7900GT, and it is not a 'guideline' it is a minimum requirement to run the two graphics cards like I said.


Quote :

Mathematically, two 7900GTs together can't draw more than 24A, and their actual draw is closer to 16A.



Their actual draw will fluctuate with their load. Their 'actual draw' can vary, but if OP has 34A on his 12v rail(s) the two video cards will operate correctly.

Quote :

OP, 450W is pushing it even if your PSU is a high quality unit.



Few 450w PSU's supply 34A on the 12v. I believe, generally speaking, as jsc suggests, at least 500-550w PSU for 34A and 600-650w is recommended.

Profile: Forum Fixture
More Information

Quote :

That last sentence is absolutely 100% incorrect.



Ok, have it your way.

jsc
Profile: old hand
More Information

Thanks, carver_g. But the only extreme PSU calculator I used was the one in my head. It may not be easy, but it is fairly simple:

CPU power consumption - take the TDP and add 10% to allow for losses in the motherboard PWM power supply. Or for any C2D or C2Q CPU, figure 10 amps. Remember, I want conservative over estimates.

GPU's - documented on line mostly.

Drives - calculated from data on labels, or figure 20 watts for a HD and 30 watts for an optical drive.

Motherboard estimates were based on actual measurements on my EP35-DS3P. The power leads on my 650 watt Antec are not sleeved. I cut cable ties so I could separate the various power lines. Then I borrowed a lab calibrated clampon ammeter from work. I was pretty surprised at how little power passes through the mainpower connector. Then I rounded each measurement up to the next amp. For the RAM, for example, I clamped the meter around all of the orange wires (3.3 volts) on the main connector. I measured a little under 3 amps. That's about 10 watts for 2 GB.



Go to:
 

Google Ads
Ad
News

US science teachers pass on climate DVDs

Published on December 07, 2006

Psst! Want 50,000 free DVDs? The US National Science Teachers Association didn't, even though the DVDs in question were of An Inconvenient Truth, the climate change movie that is required viewing for all children in Norway and Sweden. Read more

Intel claims edge over AMD on dual core chips

Published on November 05, 2004

Chip giant Intel is moving heaven and earth to deliver dual core technology, but according to a web cast its president Paul Otellini made to staff, there are limitations on AMD technology which could give the chip giant the edge. Read more

Relevance Of Blu-ray Up In The Air, Says ISuppli

Published on February 25, 2008

Following the recent revelation by Toshiba that it will no longer make any HD DVD products, the death knell of its next-generation, high-definition DVD standard has been sounded - and rival Blu-ray's victory assured. Read more

ATI confirms R580 for January or February - sort of

Published on December 27, 2005

R580, ATI's new high-end graphics processor based on the X1000 architecture has not been quite what one would call a secret for quite some time. Read more

Latest Reviews & Articles

Atom, Athlon, or Nano? Energy-Savers Compared

Published on October 03, 2008

We compared Intel’s Atom 230 and VIA’s Nano L2100 processors hoping to find the best product for low-power applications. VIA is in the vanguard of performance. Is this enough to beat Atom? Read more

Interview: Bigfoot's Killer NIC, Exposed

Published on October 02, 2008

Since its release, the Killer NIC has garnered a reputation for being an extravagant and largely unnecessary add-on for the do-it-yourselfer. Seeking additional insight, we approached the card's designer. Read more

Seagate's 1.5TB Barracuda: Bigger And Better?

Published on October 02, 2008

Seagate is the first hard drive vendor to offer a 1.5 TB drive in the 3.5” form factor. Meanwhile, WD sent us its RAID Edition 3 (RE3) drive. We tell you which is the best HDD choice today. Read more

Updated CPU Charts 2008: AMD Versus Intel

Published on October 01, 2008

The processor is the heart of your PC, and our updated charts for Q3 2008 show 54 of them competing in terms of performance. Using our updated suite of benchmarks, compare your favorite AMD and Intel CPUs after reading this introduction. Read more