Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > ATI > Better cooling for 4850/4870?

Better cooling for 4850/4870?

Forum Graphic & Displays : ATI - Better cooling for 4850/4870?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Some reviews are reporting 70-80+ C in testing, which quite frankly, scares the *$*@ out of me.

Any thoughts on having better case cooling, or waiting for a company to just put a better than stock cooler on a card to sell retail?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Damn, I can't remember where I read it, but I read a review where they installed a V1000 (from Zalman) on a 4850. I remember that it had a huge impact on the core temperature, which is what one would expect.

Sorry I don't remember where I read it though. I tried Gizoogling it, but it's so recent that it doesn't find it.

------------------------------ Don't go away mad, just go away!
Reply to techgeek

Heat issues will be fixed with a update to raise fan speed or a utility to control fans is updated for these cards, the cooling on it is fine.

Reply to boredatcanon

similar fan problems with launch of the 38xx cards. Fans were fine, the bios needed updating. The later versions 38xx fans work great.

Still tho. you'd think ATI would do a better job with fans, especially considering the big heat/fan issues the 29xx series and the fans speed problems of the 38xx series.

------------------------------ gigabyte GA-EX38-DS4|Intel C2Q Q9550 @ 3.4G | Sapphire Vapor-x 4870 1G CCC 9.6|4G PNY DDR2 800MHz 5-5-5-12|500G Seagate SATA II HD|Sunbeam core contact cooler 120mm|BFG Tech 800w| Win XP sp2| Antec 1200
Reply to 50bmg

Thanks for the replies.

I cannot believe how appealing these cards are looking, and I am well past due with my AGP 6600GT and much older P4 2.6C :o

Reply to kenratboy

kenratboy wrote :

Thanks for the replies.

I cannot believe how appealing these cards are looking, and I am well past due with my AGP 6600GT and much older P4 2.6C :o



That looks strikingly similar to my rig from three years ago. But I had a clawhammer 3700+ 2.4ghz with socket 754.

------------------------------ // Intel C2D E6750 @ 3.2ghz 1.35v // Asus P5K P35 // 2gb Patriot 1000mhz // Sapphire HD4850 @700core 1100mem // Antec neo 500 HE // Antec 900 // SB X-FI // WD 250gb Sata-2 //
Reply to terror112

Yeah, I built my current 'gaming rig' in December 2003, and only changed the video card after the fact.

Needless to say, I am probably going to poop my pants with joy if I do something like a Q9450 and a 4870 or 9800

Reply to kenratboy

http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/for [...] ew-21.html

that one site. i saw another that said the mounting holes are the standard holes and they mounted an AC Accelero S2 and posted temps in high 30's low 40's LOAD.

Reply to the last resort

http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/for [...] eview.html

there's a review, and the cooling is at the end... I apologize if someone already posted.

------------------------------ AMD 5000+BE Brisbane: Arctic Cooling Freezer Pro 64: Raidmax Smilodon w/500w PSU: Gigabyte HD 3870 w/Ultra Durable 2: 2x 1gig G-Skill DDR2 800: Gigabyte GA-M57SLI-S4: Samsung Spinpoint hd321kj: samsug dvd burner: Wireless logitech perfs, thumb ball mouse:
Reply to nachowarrior

Ummm remember the x1900's? 90C+ on load. Come on its a GPU not a CPU!

------------------------------ Big Brother Rules with an Iron Fist
Reply to jay2tall

Wow, that Thermalright is a monster. I assume the non-GPU parts are still getting adequate cooling?

Reply to kenratboy

They probably just wanted lower fan speeds for quietness during all of the reviews so that they don't go down in history as the loudest vga.

Reply to SpinachEater

Well, thats it. Maybe they could speed the fans up for lower temps...but I don't want the noise. I have the nice all-copper Zalman on my 6600GT. Quiet, cool, and look awesome.

Reply to kenratboy

This is the only reason I haven't ordered a 4870 yet. I'm waiting to see if we get any better cooling solutions soon.

Reply to Darkmatterx

4870 does not suffer from a poor cooler... It has the second slot cooler that at the most needs a BIOS update to run the fan faster. On my Visiontek 4850 I flashed to an Asus and use their software utilities to turn the fan from 14% to 50%. Blends right in with my Antec 900 fans on medium.

Reply to danbfree

my gpsu (2 4850 in crossfire are runing at 105 C with stock on 100% fan speeds if its hot in my room.
my case is not poorly cooled but the GPUs are kinda closed in since i use some noise reduction kits.

Apart from waht i "want" beeing aquagratix 4850 waterblock fullcover, id go with DuOrb (all copper version), or some thermalright (but those hardly will work in corssfire if u use most of your PCI slots).

Reply to cats_paw

cats_paw wrote :

my gpsu (2 4850 in crossfire are runing at 105 C with stock on 100% fan speeds if its hot in my room.
my case is not poorly cooled but the GPUs are kinda closed in since i use some noise reduction kits.

Apart from waht i "want" beeing aquagratix 4850 waterblock fullcover, id go with DuOrb (all copper version), or some thermalright (but those hardly will work in corssfire if u use most of your PCI slots).



Are you serious? Wtf...

I'm currently at 40% fan speed with a temp of 41c. Using an Antec 900 at lowest fan speed.

Reply to IndigoMoss

it sounds promising but it looks just like the reference coolers. I wonder why and how it can achieve stunning results.

Reply to murdoc

I have a Diamond 4870 with their factory heatpipe heatsink.....and I set in CCC the fan to 60 percent and get 53 deg C and it doesn't hit over 63 in games.....Granted its not the stock ati fan either

------------------------------ Q6600...4870oc
XFX 680i LT Sli...VISTA 64
4g Corsair XMS
Antec P180/550 psu
Reply to jackieboy

jackieboy wrote :

I have a Diamond 4870 with their factory heatpipe heatsink.....and I set in CCC the fan to 60 percent and get 53 deg C and it doesn't hit over 63 in games.....Granted its not the stock ati fan either



I have the diamond 4870 1gb edition and yes they are using ATI referenced design meaning their stock fans. They didn't change their coolers. I wouldn't run the fan at 60% that's insane! It sounds like a jet is taking off. I can't stand it! Most I would put it at is 30% and if i'm OCing 40ish% tops!

Reply to murdoc

murdoc wrote :

I have the diamond 4870 1gb edition and yes they are using ATI referenced design meaning their stock fans. They didn't change their coolers. I wouldn't run the fan at 60% that's insane! It sounds like a jet is taking off. I can't stand it! Most I would put it at is 30% and if i'm OCing 40ish% tops!





http://www.diamondmm.com/4870PE5512DT.php


You don't have a fan like this

Reply to jackieboy



ah!! Ic... yeah I don't have that one.. Is it loud when you set it to 60% fan speed?

Reply to murdoc

I have a gigabyte 4850 and it idles at around 68 C when i set the fan speed to 55%...but when I game, the temp goes up to about 103 C, which really worries me...would a pci slot cooler underneath the video help solve this problem?

------------------------------ AMD64 X2 6000 + Biostar Tseries 770 + 4gb DDR2 800 G.Skill + Thermaltake WingRS case + Raidmax 530w modular PSU + 200gig internal WD HD + 250gig external WD HD + 500gig external Simpletech HDD + Belkin Wireless G PCI receiver + Gigabyte ATI Radeon HD4850
Reply to ahslan

I have a saphire 4850 overclocked. i just reached 88 celcius running a gpu stress test. and mind you thats with fan at 100% the whole time. i also applied artic silver 5 to it yesterday. im definitely looking for an after market cooler but im not sure if i should waste money on it.

Reply to werxen

danbfree wrote :

4870 does not suffer from a poor cooler... It has the second slot cooler that at the most needs a BIOS update to run the fan faster. On my Visiontek 4850 I flashed to an Asus and use their software utilities to turn the fan from 14% to 50%. Blends right in with my Antec 900 fans on medium.



ati overdrive fan adjustment ftw! 35% fan speed=best gpu cooler ever!

Reply to spoonboy

murdoc wrote :

ah!! Ic... yeah I don't have that one.. Is it loud when you set it to 60% fan speed?




No its not.....its quieter than my old 8800gt



Reply to jackieboy

jackieboy wrote :

No its not.....its quieter than my old 8800gt



damn.. I wish the 4870 1gB edition had those special coolers :( I don't want to spend more on it though... If I successfully get a job on this next job that I apply for, then I will just sell 4870 and buy 5870 when it comes out. I guess I can live with the noise for now.

Reply to murdoc

My visiontek 4870 has stock HSF and with fan at 30% the idle is 42C and at 40% the idle is at 38C. Load never goes over 60C And its OC to 765/1000

Reply to geckoar

How much memory do you have?

I think since I have 1gb, the density of the rams increased and so temperature increases.

I have it set to 30% right now and idle is around 42ish.. and on load it goes to around 65 - 70.

Reply to murdoc

i ve read a good review about the AC accelero S2(heatsink system).. you can also add "turbo module" which is 2 additional fans over the accelero s2... those 2 things are bout 40$ so i might get a cheap diamond 4850 and add either the S2 only, and use some homemade fan setup...
thats cheaper than the HIS ICeQ4 4850 but im still in a dillema, wut do u guys think?
problem with S2 + turbo module is that it takes 3 slots :( thats freakin a lot)

Reply to fwogiz

as all ready stated this http://www.overclockers.co.uk/show [...] -AK&tool=3 has just about the best cooling for the 4850/4870 and its cheap

Reply to rangers

co.uk >_>
wut bout .ca? :P

Reply to fwogiz

ahslan wrote :

I have a gigabyte 4850 and it idles at around 68 C when i set the fan speed to 55%...but when I game, the temp goes up to about 103 C, which really worries me...would a pci slot cooler underneath the video help solve this problem?




It might help but not for certain.....case airflow and many other factors can cause the heat you have.....don't overclock it at all

Reply to jackieboy

I don't think the S2 helps cool ram which the default HSF does.... you may get reduced performance that way.

Reply to murdoc

S2 is only copper heatsinks or wutever the terms are, i beleive so yeah maybe... but if the case airflow (which is really good in mine) is good, then shouldnt it be enough??
what about the HIS IceQ4 Turbo 4850 card??!! would that be enough??
my dilemma is between HIS IceQ4 or diamond 4850 +S2 ........
id like to get that other fan over the co.uk website, but i cant even buy stuffs from newegg.com :X doomed to ncix.com (canada)
that thermalright cooler seems to be quite big?? how many slots does it take?? also its freakin 55$ >_>


Message edited by fwogiz on 11-21-2008 at 11:03:28 PM
Reply to fwogiz

so now im running into some serious problems....my 4850 overheats sometimes and now causes my comp to restart (even when i manually set the fan speed to 100%)...i definitely need to get rid of this stock cooling but i dont want to spend too much money on an aftermarket cooler...my computer does have adequate cooling (2 120mm fans...one intake, other output, and have a pci slot fan under gpu)

Reply to ahslan
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > ATI > Better cooling for 4850/4870?
Go to:

There are 1289 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them