ATI OR NVIDIA

HI there I'm new to this forum and would like to ask a question

I've just bought a xeon quad core cpu with a supermicro mother board with about 5Gb of ram but not sure what graphics card to buy Nvidia or ATI Radeon, I do a lot of 3d work and video editing and I'm not sure weather to go for HD 4870 or GTX260 any recommendations would be a great help.
10 answers Last reply
More about nvidia
  1. 4870
  2. Well it's very app dependant, but I'd say that in general the HD4870 would be the better choice for what you're asking.

    However there are some apps that would be preferential to one or the other so be sure you check into the predific tools you'll be using.

    There's hasn't been much testing of workstation apps on these cards yet (mainly since there is no Quadro and FireGL equivalent yet), but I would hazard a guess that without optimized drivers the HD4870 would outperform the GTS260 just scaling off of the previous generations' performance.
  3. Thank you for the fast reply, I know about the Quadro and FireGL series and that they would have been the better choice out of the two but they are way out of my price range if you know what I mean. Looks like i'll be going for the HD4870 then, I did do some research before posting here and found the HD4870 to be the better choice but I just had to ask personally to confirm it.
  4. ati
  5. ati
  6. shinsan said:
    Thank you for the fast reply, I know about the Quadro and FireGL series and that they would have been the better choice out of the two but they are way out of my price range if you know what I mean. Looks like i'll be going for the HD4870 then, I did do some research before posting here and found the HD4870 to be the better choice but I just had to ask personally to confirm it.


    you can soft mod atleast the Nvidia cards into Quadro cards btw
  7. I would have said NVIDIA in the past, considering how slacking they got after their 8800 series, I would say ATI for now. At least ATI is doing pretty good lately.
  8. apache_lives said:
    you can soft mod atleast the Nvidia cards into Quadro cards btw


    Can you softMod the GTX series yet?

    I didn't think they had support yet, since like the FireGL SoftMod you need an equivalent workstation card to Softmod to before it works.
  9. The Quadro Fx is very expensive, I would like to buy one but are they specifically for 3d Design and work or for both gaming and 3d work
    AND WHY IS IT THAT FireGL V5600 IS A LOT MORE EXPENSIVE THAN ATI RADEON HD4870 AND THE SPECS ON THE HD4870 ARE HIGHER

    ATI RADEON HD4870
    PCI Express x16 (2.0%u5BFE%u5FDC)
    512MB
    256bit
    GDDR5
    750MHz / 3600MHz
    DVI-I x2
    HDTV
    FAN
    DVI to HDMI
    CrossFireX
    HDCP

    FireGL V5600
    PCI Express x16
    512MB
    128bit
    GDDR4
    DVI-I x2
    FAN
    DVI to D-Sub
  10. It's the cost of driver and hardware certification and the customer support that comes with the cards.

    It's like buying an Audi versus an VW, or the old ford Aston/Jaguar, may have similar underlying features but the support levels, quality control, etc. are different and you pay for it.

    UWE covers it briefly in this review;
    http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/opengl-workstation-graphics,1269.html
Ask a new question

Read More

Graphics Cards Nvidia Graphics Product