Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Solved

Western Digital, Samsung, or Seagate?

Last response: in Storage
Share
November 9, 2009 12:30:49 AM

I plan on building a RAID 0 array consisting of two disks from one of the following hard drive makes. Any opinions/experiences on which is best? They all seem quite similar to me, but I was just wondering if anybody had something to say about one or more of the makes.

Seagate: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E168...

Western Digital: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E168...

Samsung: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E168...




Best solution

November 9, 2009 7:39:44 PM
Share

If you are going to RAID0 then my suggestion would be the Caviar Black or Samsung F3 :

Black :
http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=E...

F3 :
http://www.newegg.com/Product/ProductList.aspx?Submit=E...
November 9, 2009 7:56:05 PM

as a point of preference i would stay as far away from samsung as you can, i bought three drives of theres and had to get three replacements all within like 6-7 months, of the three replacements two died within a few months and one is still kinda running to this day. i decided not to even bother with trying to replace the replacements as they were refurbs anyways. hope thats a help to you!
Related resources
November 9, 2009 8:46:25 PM

Thanks greatly for the replies. andrew66553, that was exactly the kind of experience I was looking for, thanks for the heads up. OvrClkr, do you mind me asking what makes the Samsung F3 better than the others that I listed? When I looked at the specs on newegg, the hard drives seemed to be very similar (besides the capacity. 320gb vs. 500gb).

November 9, 2009 8:55:17 PM

To be honest, when I buy a drive the first thing I look at is reliability and speed. I have built several PC's using Caviar Blacks and have friends that have built with the F3's and to this date I have not seen/heard of any issues so far. When you buy a platter drive you always have a small % of failure rate no matter what. So try to get a brand/model that has a good track record and you should be fine. Last time I built a PC with a seagate drive it had bad sectors and ended up RMA'ing the drive. Since then it's been all Western Digital for me...

My suggestion is a Caviar Black, they just work.... F3's have a good track record also, I guess its a matter of taste. To this date I have purchased around 10 Black drives for raid arays and (knock on wood) not one issue so far...

Look at the reviews and you will see what I mean =)
November 9, 2009 9:15:46 PM

Ah, now I understand. Thanks very much for the recommendation.
November 9, 2009 9:36:46 PM

Western Digital got the more reliable hard drive right now. Still, it will never match the old Seagate... but the new Seagate... how can a company goes from the best to the worst manufacturer?
a b G Storage
November 9, 2009 9:50:22 PM

I've been using WD exclusively for qbout 15 years and never lost a byte of data that wasn't my fault.
November 9, 2009 9:53:39 PM

+1^^ lol , IDK what the hell happen... Seagates were tier 1 drives back in the day... Of course this does not apply to all seagates, there are many that have 0 issues as well, I just don't want to take that chance again...

a b G Storage
November 9, 2009 11:18:06 PM

Another +1 for the WD Blacks. The F3s do look good tho...

PS: Just make sure you have good backups. RAID0 offers no redundancy.
November 10, 2009 11:21:53 PM

Shadow703793 said:
Another +1 for the WD Blacks. The F3s do look good tho...

PS: Just make sure you have good backups. RAID0 offers no redundancy.


Yeah, that's why I am having a separate 500gb hard drive off my RAID 0 array for my precious music and movie files. I'm going to install only the OS (including games and programs) on my array. It's of my understanding though, that RAID 0 arrays have higher chances of failing and eminently lose data, but I'm assuming this phenomena doesn't occur often. Especially when one buys decent hard drives. Am I wrong on this one?
November 10, 2009 11:36:29 PM

My 640's have been in Raid0 since x-mas of last year and not one hiccup so far....
November 11, 2009 12:04:37 AM

Ok, cool. That's very reassuring. Thank you.
!