WD Passport or Seagate Freeagent?

Errr, why'd you delete your original thread?

Anyways, like I said, go for the Passport. From personal experience in terms of HD failures, it's WD none, Seagate two. Hope this helps!

Alright, thanks! Will keep that in mind. Any other opinions here?  

either one is fine....just make sure you use the remove hardware safely option and let the hdd spin down for at least 10 seconds before unplugging and moving it around. most of the hdds get messed up because people move them while they are spinning.