ASUS Rampage (X48) vs. ASUS P5Q Pro (P45)

[rflction]

ASUS Rampage (X48) http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131284
or
ASUS P5Q Pro (P45) http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131299


Can't decide which one to pick.

My build: Q9550, HD4870 1 Gig, 4 Gig DDR2 800
I might OC in the future if i need the power.

What will be my benefit of buying the rampage? Does the P45 CF only at 8x while the X48 CF at 16x? Right now I only see a substantial cost difference.

 

[roadrunner197069]

x48 16x, p45 8x, price. If your never gonna crossfire or dont mind a tiny bit of difference get the p45.

 

[jeremyrailton]

the p45 board CFs at 8x8 or runs the full 16 for a single card, but keep in mind that they are PCI-E 2.0 slots, giving them substantially more throughput than a standard 8x8 connection. The reviews I've seen bear very little difference between a true 16x16 and the p45's 8x8. it seems to depend on how much memory the vid card has. check out reviews for yourself and see

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/pci-express-2-0,1915-13.html

If you plan on running a single card, or if you plan on doubling up on the 4870 1gig's, then you will be fine with p45

 

[aevm]

$300 Rampage + $300 HD 4870 1GB is a waste IMO. $120 P5Q Pro + $550 HD 4870 X2 is a lot better for almost the same price. If you can't afford $670 now then at least get the P5E Deluxe, it's still X48 and cheaper. This way you end up paying $220+$300+(hopefully) only $200 for the second card later, so you waste only $50 and get the real performance later but you don't need to have all the money up front.

With a P5Q Pro and HD 4870 1GB Crossfire you would lose some performance, especially at high resolutions. Read this article, and keep in mind they used HD 4850 512MB. With HD 4870 1 GB the bottlenecks will hurt more.
http://www.tweaktown.com/articles/1472/intel_p45_vs_x48_crossfire_performance/index.html

Get a Silencer 750W PSU, it's on sale at Newegg.


Edit: if you don't intend to Crossfire ever, then the P5Q Pro and a 650TX would be perfect.

 

[rflction]

how is the P5E Deluxe w/a Rampage Bios?

 

[Kaldor]

how is the P5E Deluxe w/a Rampage Bios?

Same as a Rampage.... The boards are almost identical electrically minus a couple of extra sensors the Rampage has.

 

[huilun02]

If you're not dead set on overclocking, then you should go for the P45. Much cheaper than the Rampage and has all you need. The biggest difference that sets both apart would be the Rampage's overclocking features, and you wont want to pay a lot more for such features which you might not be using at all. The X48 provides full X16/X16 on Crossfire but it's not significantly better than X8/X8. You know what you want, don't pay for what you don't need.