Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

24" active matrix vs 28" TN monitor

Tags:
  • Graphics Cards
  • TV
  • Monitors
  • Graphics
Last response: in Graphics & Displays
Share
October 23, 2008 11:45:25 AM

Hi everyone I am looking to buy a new monitor for my pc to play games, watch HD movies and live tv/freeview connect a ps3/xbox360 if i ever get one I was going to buy a LCD tv but someone advised me that a monitor is better because of the resolution

Now i have narrowed down my choices to 2 monitors;

1) is a 24" active matrix monitor by samsung for £260:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/130991/show_product_speci...

2) is a 28" TN panel monitor by hanns-g for £270;
http://www.play.com/PC/PCs/4-/3515619/Hanns-G-HG281DP-2...

3) a 26" lcd tv.

Please help me make the right choice

Also as i wanted to watch live tv i thought this is the best option let me know on this aswell please:
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/113962

Setup:
Asus P5NSLI
E6400 Intel Core 2 Duo 2.13ghz
BFG 8800GT OC 512mb DDR3 @625mhz
2GB DDR2 553 mhz very soon upgrading to 4gb ddr2 @ 667mhz (dono which to buy with or without heatsink)
550W HEC psu

Thanks

More about : active matrix monitor

a c 365 U Graphics card
a b x TV
a c 196 C Monitor
October 23, 2008 3:37:43 PM

All LCDs are now active matrix. Passive matrix LCD panels went the way of the dodo bird many years ago.

The two monitors you are comparing use TN panel tech. While cheap and fast, these monitors have limited viewing angles. The further away you view the monitor from dead center the more washed out the colors will be. In a few extreme cases some TN monitors inverts the colors so black is white, red is blue, it's like looking at a negative film cell.

A 26" LCD HDTV only has a resolution of 1366 x 768 (an old HDTV standard) as opposed to 1920 x 1200 for an LCD monitor and 1920 x 1080 for a larger HDTV (32" or larger LCD, 46" or larger plasma).


Personally I would get a separate HDTV to watch movies and TV.
a b U Graphics card
October 23, 2008 4:03:20 PM

jaguarskx said:
Personally I would get a separate HDTV to watch movies and TV.


Agreed, a seperate HDTV for watching TV and movies and a monitor for the PC is still preferred over a "one-size-fits-all" solution.

While digital convergence is light years ahead of where it was 3 years ago, there is still a significant enough difference between the two to warrant seperate purchases. The fact is, a computer monitor is manufactured with that specific purpose in mind whereas HDTV's are still manufactured primarily as consumer electronics devices.

Now, that's not to say that it can't be done as HDTV's and video cards do have HDMI and DVI-D connections but there is a trade-off, as mentioned by jaguarskx, with viewing angles and resolution. An HTPC is a good example of this trade-off, not quite good enough for a production/workstation/gaming machine but great for watching movies and web-surfing, and even then you have to be sure to have the hardware to push HD and support high resolutions.
Related resources
October 23, 2008 4:24:15 PM

so ur saying buy a tv? but most of the movies i watch are on my pc anyway thats why i thought of a monitor
October 23, 2008 4:50:10 PM

"Agreed, a seperate HDTV for watching TV and movies and a monitor for the PC is still preferred over a "one-size-fits-all" solution. "


Preferred by who?

To the OP: Do what you want to do. I got a Westinghouse L2410NM 24" MVA panel. I don't game on it, but I use it for 1) Software development and 2) watching Hi Def. It is great for use as a monitor for software development (lots of screen space for many windows), and Hi Def looks very good (not quite as good as my LCD TV, but very nearly so). There is very little/no color shift as you get off center from the monitor due to the MVA panel. I love it.

Preferred by who?... it really all depends on your uses. I haven't tried gaming on this monitor, and maybe gaming would not be pretty. But if you are using the monitor to mostly display text windows instead of gaming, a multipurpose monitor should do that quiet well, and would be PREFERRED to a separate monitor/lcd tv... especially if this is your "spare" or "second" TV.
a c 365 U Graphics card
a b x TV
a c 196 C Monitor
October 23, 2008 5:17:02 PM

osiris2k8 said:
so ur saying buy a tv? but most of the movies i watch are on my pc anyway thats why i thought of a monitor


Well, if most of your movies are AVI/DivX/XviD files then, yeah, get a monitor.

If most of your movies are actual DVD/Blu-Ray and you have a standalone player, then I would recommend a separate HDTV.

I prefer a separate monitor and HDTV because I have two PCs. One primary PC for gaming and other things, another PC connected to an older monitor and to my TV which acts as a HTPC (home theater) and backup PC.
October 23, 2008 6:40:36 PM

Why would anyone pay money twice for a LCD TV and a LCD monitor when most if not all LCD TV's double as monitors? I am typing away on a 32" 720p LCD TV/monitor that cost me the same as a much smaller 24" to 26" LCD monitor. Im returning that LCD TV and probably will go with a 1080p verson at 42" size and am going to spend $600-$800 for a new or refurbished one. This is cheaper than buying a seperate 24" monitor and 26" TV and I get to enjoy 42" of beauty!
October 28, 2008 3:02:42 PM

There's no need to buy two separate screens, one for TV one for computer, UNLESS you want the best of both worlds, best gaming monitor, combined with best / biggest TV screen, then yes, you need to buy two separate monitors. But otherwise, i'd suggest getting a high quality 24" flat panel display for your PC and TV viewing (provided you're going to be sitting right in front of the screen when watching TV / Video's on it). Samsung makes some of the best screens, and their all active matrix nowadays.
October 29, 2008 12:05:11 AM

thanks ben7even7 you're more realistic than the others lol so you would take the samsung 24" over the 28" from hanns-g?
February 18, 2009 4:10:52 PM

I just bought a Sanyo 26 inch TV to run on my computer. The colors were spot on but the pixels were big and the text was jagged edged. I loved it for gaming but everything stretched. Couldn't find a compatible resolution. I order the Samsung 24" TN monitor and hope I'll be happy with it. Meanwhile its back to the old CRT. :( 
!