Heatsink came new, and CPU came new. Nothing was on the heatsink other than a plastic film protecting the Cu finish which I took off. I forgot to put spacers in the assembly (checked a video online), but I assume that is just to protect the motherboard.
Also, I think I left most of the voltages on auto (ram is clocking in at 1400mhz right now) and didn't turn off settings such as hyper threading or extreme performance. Would any of these settings affect the temperature?