Casual Gamer: Q6700 bottleneck?

singingigo

Distinguished
Aug 13, 2007
281
0
18,790
I'm a power user, but only game casually. I like to game at high resolutions, I play Civilizations IV Colinizations, Age of the Empires III, Madden 2008, TrackManiaNations, and a little Call of Duty 4/Battlefield 2.

My current rig:
Q6700 (stock cooling, undervolted .125volt)
Foxconn Geforce 256MB 7900 GS-OC (factory overclocked almost 50%)
2x2GB Gskill PC2-8500 1066MHZ CL5.5.5.15
Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L 2.0
Windows XP SP3/Windows 7 Dual boot
24" 1920x1200 LCD Monitor

I use Office 2003/2007, Adobe Design CS4, and a bunch of networking tools (VPN/SSH/RDP)

My games run decent. I know simply putting in a better graphics card will help somewhat in the games, but I want to increase overall system performance. I'm wondering if how much I would have to spend to get a decent upgrade, or if I should invest in a better CPU cooler and try overclocking. Energy costs & noise are an issue, so I haven't done much with overclocking.

I saw this one on the Egg...Would it be much of an upgrade?

E8500: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115036
Q9200S:
 

singingigo

Distinguished
Aug 13, 2007
281
0
18,790


I know the graphics is bottlenecking. I'm asking about the CPU. Is that bottlenecking me much? I'm not just concerned about graphics performance, but overall system performance. I'm not one of those diehards that keeps my system processes to a minimum. It's a home/work PC so I run ~70 processes. Am I going to see much of a boost with a E8500 (going from 4 cores to 2 cores) or a Q8xxx or 9xxx?
 

mi1ez

Splendid
No, no, no! stick with the Q6700, spend a bit of cash on a decent cooler and It should push to at least 3/3.2. What stepping have you got. did they do a G0 Q6700?
 

singingigo

Distinguished
Aug 13, 2007
281
0
18,790
What is that going to do for my energy costs & noise? I.E if I have to overvolt it and use bigger HSF, would it be cheaper over the course of 2 years to by a faster, more energy efficient model?
 

Kraynor

Distinguished
Aug 10, 2007
829
0
19,010
mi1ez I want your Q6600... mine cries at 3.3 :(
Anyway, energy cost won't go up all that much compared to what your system already sucks down, noise won't go up at all because the S1283 is quieter than the stock intel HSF (larger fans are generally quieter).

Buying a new, more energy efficient CPU won't pay for itself in the home environment if you're replacing an existing CPU, they're mainly targetted at either new systems, or places where you've got dozens of systems running.
 

B-Unit

Distinguished
Oct 13, 2006
1,837
1
19,810
Agreed, do NOT upgrade your CPU. You would see only marginal gains and it would cost you $250+ to get them. Overclocking or the move to 8GB/64-bit are your two best options.
 

singingigo

Distinguished
Aug 13, 2007
281
0
18,790
I'm looking at that XIGMATEK HDT-S1283 heatsink. I'm wonding if it will fit in my case. I have an Antec Sonata 500. If not, does anyone have any other suggestions that would fit into my case and allow for overclocking?

HSF: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835233003
Case: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811129036

Also, I have XP 32 bit (not going to reinstall for 64 bit) and Windows 7 Beta (I'd go 64 bit). I have a copy of Vista but forgot to install it before I put Windows 7 on, and now I don't know if I can setup a triple boot from the vista install disk. And I'm not too keen on installing a Linux GRUB bootloader...
 

Kraynor

Distinguished
Aug 10, 2007
829
0
19,010
http://www.frostytech.com is probably the best place for heatsink reviews. Not sure if it'd fit in your case because I'm too lazy to look up the specs... it fits in my Antec 1200 though... not that it's much help knowing that because the 1200 is huge... ^^;
 

Kraynor

Distinguished
Aug 10, 2007
829
0
19,010
Just noticed the video card... at those resolutions you really want something with upwards of 1GB RAM... Personally recommend the ATI HD4890, if it's better than the 4870 then that's one hell of a card (get a 4870 if the 90 is outside your budget range)