Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > Upgrade to what from 8800gtx

Upgrade to what from 8800gtx

Forum Graphic & Displays : Graphics Cards - Upgrade to what from 8800gtx

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

I have a ASUS p5w-dh delux Mobo

- IntelĀ® Quad-core CPU Ready
- LGA775 socket for Intel Core2 Duo, Core2 Extreme
- Intel 975X +Intel ICH7R 1066/800MHz
- Dual-channel DDR2 800/667/ 533 max 8GB
- 2 x PCI-E x 16 / 2 x PCI-E x 1/ 3 x PCI
- Support ATI CrossFire graphics cards




and i have 4 gigs ram with vista 64 bit with an 8800gtx grfx card,

i am looking for a better gpu. As my Mobo only has pci-e x 16 and not the new pci 2.0 i cant do the gforce 200 serires.

So what are my options? Go with a GeForce 9800 GX2 that has been discontuned and not suported or what?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

2.0 is backwards compatible.

What resolution?

Reply to theAnimal

right now i play wow with 1152 x 864 with all settings on high and it plays nice. o and forgot price range im looking for options from $200 - $500 as this is a hard core gaming comp i dont need to go cheap.

Reply to ptcrash3814

theAnimal wrote :

2.0 is backwards compatible.

What resolution?




so are you saying i can put a pci- 2.0 card into a pci-e x 16 slot and get same power from it?


the mobo says its ait crosfire suported so im taking it i can put in an ati card? I have never used ati i have been an nivida user for yeares and years. Whats my options there?

Reply to ptcrash3814
- 0 +

Yes, you can put a new 2.0 graphics card in your board and it'll work just fine. Numerous sites have tested the differences between the old x16 and the new 2.0 standard and found at most a 5% difference. Usually less.

As for which graphics card to upgrade to.. I can't really say you're really going to see much of an improvement from ANY card in most circumstances. The resolution you're running is quite low, about the eq. of 720p.

Reply to itheral
- 0 +

i suggest u go for 4870 1GB as u not Playing over 1152 x 864 .
at that res 4870 1GB will be enough for u at less 2 years from now .
u can find it around 225$ ~270$..

Reply to salem80

i can change my rez to most anything really. atm im only playing WOW but am gona go back to crysys and bf2 soon. What kind os rez should i use? the numbers i gave are the games settings is that what we talkign about or somethign else? Want to make sure we on same page.

Reply to ptcrash3814
- 0 +

A faster card would most likely be CPU bound (limited by the CPU speed) at your current resoloution, so unless the card is failing, or plan on getting a bigger display, stay where you are.
And, much as it pains me as an ATI user to type this; If you`re using WOW stick with Nvidia.

Reply to coozie7
- 0 +

OK, I need to type faster.
What is the maximum resoloution of your display?

Reply to coozie7
- 0 +

salem80 wrote :

i suggest u go for 4870 1GB as u not Playing over 1152 x 864 .
at that res 4870 1GB will be enough for u at less 2 years from now .
u can find it around 225$ ~270$..




How can you predict the market like? What if all games choose to use the Crytek engine? Or another demanding engine? 2 years is a long time. Just because it happened with the 8800 GTX doesn't mean its going to happen with the new cards. You can't predict it that simply.

A 4870 1 gig would be a safe haven, but you can't expect to max out all settings for 4 years. I mean look at the 280 GTX. It has trouble with a game as simple as stalker. Pushing like 30-40 frames....

We still don't have a card that can keep Crysis playing as smoother as butter, even at 1280x1024. On very high with out AA. You'll always have those 20 fps dips, even though the avg might be high.

I do second a 4870 1 gig purchase since you can find it soo cheap, but I wouldn't go as far as predicting the year.

P.S

though the resolution is really low, and 1 gig seems like overdoing it, trust me it won't as textures become more detailed and AA becomes hard to output;)


Message edited by L1qu1d on 02-07-2009 at 10:08:36 PM
------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

Ok i set it to maxx for the game. 1280 x 1024 24bit color 24 bit depth 8x multyshading. im getting around 50 fps in full screen mode in window mode im get around 30 fps. forgot to change to maxx before starting topic my bad.

 


Message edited by ptcrash3814 on 02-07-2009 at 10:17:45 PM
Reply to ptcrash3814

Really i dont have a bad card. Im just looking for upgrade options. Im looking at installing this gpu into wifes comp and getting a new one for my self.

Reply to ptcrash3814
- 0 +

why go for Nvidia when your motherboard support crossfire? lol:P

Unless you want to stay with single GPU, which some ppl prefer. If I had a an ATi motherboard I'd buy ATi (unless the company had crap cards out) and the same thing for Nvidia.

:)

------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

Thats what im wanting to know right there. As i have only used nivida in the past i have allways used them. I know them and trust them. So can i get a better nivida card or should i go with an ati card? If i go ati should i go with crossfire and get 2 cards or not? The mobo it self works with both ati and nivida cards.
when i built this thing the 8800gtx was the top card out thats why i went with it. same for the ram and cpu. i only got the best of the best of the time except for the cpu i could of got the quad but it was liek 2k at the time vrs 600 for a dual.


Message edited by ptcrash3814 on 02-07-2009 at 10:27:30 PM
Reply to ptcrash3814
- 0 +

well the top card now is the 285 GTX. THe top dual GPU card is the 295 GTX, Judging by your system I would go MAX 1 4870 X2, and at the resolution you play at, I wouldn't be crazy enough to recommend it unless you love seeing the hundreds.

I would go wit 4850 or 4870, or even the 4850 X2 would be a good choice, though I don't beleive its supported by ATI, as its a Saphire exclusive (don't quote me on that).

I would do a 4870 1 gig, that way you have top of the line from ati (with out stepping into the dual GPU yet).

Or if you really want to play it safe with your cash for now, grab a 1 gig 4850 if you can and wait and see how the market shifts. Though the GDDR3 doesn't do justice for the 4850 1 gig version.

I think more ppl will agree with me and tell you to go ATI. I would stick to a 4850 or 4870 :)

Cheers.

BTW

Post your CPU specs.

------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

here is my cpu-z link http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/502411.png

and a side note im running liquid cooled case with upgraded pump

Yea im reading abotu the 295 and finding that you can not play wow with it. There is somethign about the dual procsers it dont like at all.

Reply to ptcrash3814

Ok i have looked at the 4870 1 gig and the core and mem speeds are both faster then the 8800gtx i have. What would be the realistic advantages of goign with a 2 gig mem card?

Reply to ptcrash3814

ok i see that to get the 2 gig mem we are steping intot the dual gpu agin that my game will not suport. so maby the 4870 1 gig is my best choise. and its 1/2 the price i was willing to spend. Is there a even bigger one then that wile staying with in the 1 cpu range? also what about running 2 cards as i have that ablity? can i get more out of 2 cheaper cards then just 1 4870?


Message edited by ptcrash3814 on 02-07-2009 at 11:22:00 PM
Reply to ptcrash3814
- 0 +

you can, but its not really futureproofing, since your already running into whats supposed to be the extended life of the card.

Sli and Crossfire was meant to extend the life, not to make it its life...so I dunno what these stupid dual GPU cards came out:P.

I would go with 1 4870 1 gig. GDDR5, 55 nm technology and DX 10.1. Also can oc really well.

I would suggest grabbing the ICEQ versions.:)

------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

ok thanks, that was my next question what brand to get. mow the question is to water cool or not? As water cooling will more then likly void any warenty. Then agin maby do it after the warenty is gone? Thoughts?

Reply to ptcrash3814

ptcrash3814 wrote :

ok thanks, that was my next question what brand to get. mow the question is to water cool or not? As water cooling will more then likly void any warenty. Then agin maby do it after the warenty is gone? Thoughts?



I think XFX allows you to change the cooling, plus they have a double lifetime warranty.

Reply to theAnimal

BTW, just be aware that your MoBo does not in fact support Quad-core. I know, I know, the Asus website says it does, but believe me (having bought a quad - Q9550) I couldn't get it to work. After much searching on the web, I found that the issue is that the fsb on the mobo can't keep up with the cpu requirements.

As luck would have it, the wife unplugged the computer and the psu and mobo took some damage. Enter stage left a new mobo and a GTX295 - because the opportunity presented itself. I have to say though the this is pure extravagence. The P5W DH with a 8800 GTX is pretty good.

Whilst I'm always keen to get the latest thing (though I didn't go for Core i7), you really do have a pretty good system already. Consider a "cheap" replacement for her computer, you keep the 8800 GTX and buy some flowers - noting of course that you're saving the money for another day (get that marker down). Then when yours does become tired, hit the big time again.....

Also \, like you I'm an NVidia man. I did have an ATI way back but didn't like the drivers - can't remember which card but it was years ago. I think it is fair to say that both are good and it really comes down to what you're used to.

Just a few thoughts.

Good luck.

Reply to WigitWarrior
- 0 +

WigitWarrior wrote :

BTW, just be aware that your MoBo does not in fact support Quad-core. I know, I know, the Asus website says it does, but believe me (having bought a quad - Q9550) I couldn't get it to work. After much searching on the web, I found that the issue is that the fsb on the mobo can't keep up with the cpu requirements.
.


Q9550 wasn't work because u don't update the BIOS :sarcastic:
just take look n ASUS website again
http://www.asus.com/products.aspx? [...] 3=248&l4=0
u can latest one here same thing to ptcrash3814
http://support.asus.com/download/d [...] H%20Deluxe

 

http://support.asus.com/cpusupport [...] ct=1&os=17

 

:hello:


Message edited by salem80 on 02-11-2009 at 01:12:29 AM
Reply to salem80
- 0 +

If you want one with a strong stock cooler go with a Sapphire (4870). Mine stays at 30-35c idle and 45-55c load, (depending on the game) overclocked to 785/1000, fan on 40%.

Reply to Raidur
- 0 +

I really want to see these 30 degree idle video cards:P haven't seen 1 to date:) On air that is:D

This is one of the better 4870 cooled cards :http://www.guru3d.com/article/his-radeon-4870-iceq4-turbo-review/5 and it only manages 45 degrees:S

Which Saphire 4870 do you have?

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by L1qu1d on 02-11-2009 at 04:08:30 AM
------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

L1qu1d wrote :

I really want to see these 30 degree idle video cards:P haven't seen 1 to date:) On air that is:D

This is one of the better 4870 cooled cards :http://www.guru3d.com/article/his-radeon-4870-iceq4-turbo-review/5 and it only manages 45 degrees:S

Which Saphire 4870 do you have?




My 4870 is currently idling at 32 degrees... weird. Actually I've never turned the Fan above 35% and even OC'd it doesn't heat up much.

Problem is it can't run Fallout 3 and several other games to my expectations!

Reply to cokenbeer
- 0 +

u still didn't answer my question which Sapphire do you have? :)

------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

L1qu1d wrote :

u still didn't answer my question which Sapphire do you have? :)



Sorry, it's the old reference design. Right now my fan is set to 25% and I'm at 41 degrees while watching a movie.

Reply to cokenbeer
- 0 +

1 gig reference? old 1? is their anyway you can screen shot gpuz + gpuz sensor idle?

Sorry its just that the reference 4870 always ran around 50 degrees idle, which kinda shocks me. My friend has a 4870 512 reference and my cousin has a 4870 1 gig both of which are reference sapphire, and none of which run that cold:S

Screentshot the GPUz plz I'm really curious:D

------------------------------ Folding@HOME Team: 163116
http://pid.us.playstation.com//user/L1qu1dat1on.jpg
Lapped CPU
http://valid.canardpc.com/cache/banner/501789.png
Reply to L1qu1d

I suggest you wait until the next generation of GPU's are released. I'm using a 8800gts (g92) 512mb OC 770/1008/1848 and i'm able to play most of the latest games on max or high quality at 1920x1200. The 8800gtx outperforms my card and your running at a lower resolution. Until your unable to play the games to your liking, theres really no need to upgrade.

Reply to Mrbumbum

I'd have to agree with mrbumbum here. The 8800GTX still does phenomenally well in most games nowadays (bar maxing Crysis, Warhead, GTA IV and possibly STALKER: Clear Skies, obviously) and anything else at your 1280x1024 resolution is overkill.

Why not spend the money on a bigger and better monitor? 22" monitors (1680x1050) are somewhere between $150-200 nowadays, and you can occasionally find a 24" (1920x1200) for not too much more than $250. The 8800GTX should do just fine at those resolutions as well, barring the few games I've previously mentioned.

Reply to trkorecky
- 0 +

ptcrash3814 wrote :

ok thanks, that was my next question what brand to get. mow the question is to water cool or not? As water cooling will more then likly void any warenty. Then agin maby do it after the warenty is gone? Thoughts?



Different manufacturers are making some nice cooling units for their cards, Asus' "Dark Knight" line of cards, for example. Die shrinks are also good for producing less heat.

I have an Asus 9800GTX+ DK on an E6600 C2D. A die shrunk 9800GTX (55nm). It idles at 44, and I've never seen it go above 60 on 3D Mark (+ 3K over 7950GX2), BF2.

No matter which card you choose, there is lots to consider aside of price. I wish I would've considered cooling more on that 7950GX2 egg fryer. Oh, well. :hello:

Reply to Wrecks

8800GTX? For that resolution spells overkill.
Runs all new games well at that resolution.
Upgrading to a 4870 won't see a lot of performance increase(but may help save some money on bills.)
I'd rather wait for some great leap if I were you.


Message edited by romulus47plus1 on 02-12-2009 at 03:57:58 AM
------------------------------ Needs a job...
Reply to romulus47plus1

As others have said, at the resolution you are playing at an 8800GTX is more than adequate, and you may well have a CPU bottleneck too.

I run a 8800GTS 512 and play at 1280 x 1024 and I'm not even considering an upgrade until 40nm cards are out and established, and probably not even until DX11 cards come out.

Reply to crusoe74
- 0 +

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814102801

Thats the low temp 4870 1GB I'm using, with stock cooling. I'll take screenies when I get home.

Reply to Raidur
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > Upgrade to what from 8800gtx
Go to:

There are 930 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them