Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Storage > General Discussion > [Solved] Going to buy 1TB internal hdd,seagate or samsung or wd?

[Solved] Going to buy 1TB internal hdd,seagate or samsung or wd?

Forum Storage : General Discussion [Solved] Going to buy 1TB internal hdd,seagate or samsung or wd?

Best answer from Ubrales.

Word :    Username :           
 

Hi guys,
i am going to buy a new 1tb internal hdd for my desktop,here only seagate ,samsung and wd are available,he gave me a samsung ecogreen 1tb with32mb cache and 5400rpm,I refused it and should i go wit seagate 32mb/7200/1000gb?
I am using segate for 4yrs and was working well,many says that segate is not good,wat is your opinion?


Thanks!

Reply to Aneesh@4GHz
Register or log in to remove.

Maybe he has a bigger profit margin on the Samsung, I'm not saying it's no good as there are lots using them and quite happy with them.
As for brand choice, ask 10 people and you are likely to get 5 different answers.
I use WD's in mine, why? simply because I have used them for many years with no problems as in earlier years they were a fair bit cheaper then Seagate. Have I had problems with Seagate? no I just havn't used them for many a year.
Stick to what works for you. I would get the faster drive, but the Samsung is quieter.

Reply to Jonmor68
Best answer

Aneesh, never follow store clerk's advice. He has a vested interest in selling you what he wants to off-load.

My choice would be Seagate. Why? Because I have used Seagate over the years. I know that WD drives are also very good drives.

Hard drives are not serviceable items, so go with whatever is available at a good price - Seagate or WD 7200 RPM (the Samsung is 5400 RPM).

------------------------------ All things cometh to he that waiteth - provided he that waiteth, worketh like hell while he waiteth!
Reply to Ubrales

One more doubt,drive with 7200rpm and 16mb cache or 32mb with 5400rpm?

Reply to Aneesh@4GHz

The 7200 RPM will have faster data transfer because it is spinning faster than the 5400 RPM. Also, some of the 5400 RPM also have control features to lower the power consumption.

My choice would be time proven 7200 RPM drives, and my personal preference is Seagate. Please keep in mind that Western Digital drives are also great drives.

------------------------------ All things cometh to he that waiteth - provided he that waiteth, worketh like hell while he waiteth!
Reply to Ubrales

do we feel speed differences between those 2 drives?

Reply to Aneesh@4GHz

I'd choose the WD.

I've heard some Seagates have bad sectors over time.

The Samsung might work if you find it for a good price.

Reply to MechaNintendoMaster

Aneesh, for most practical purposes, one never notices the speed differences between 7200 RPM and 5400 RPM. The only time it will make a difference is while doing a Backup operation. Backups take hours, therefore I do my Backups just before going to bed. So, I don't know whether it takes 4 hours or 6 hours!

 

Please do Backups regularly. Win 7 "Backup and Restore" in the Control Panel will explain more. Also Disk Image, and Recovery disk. Store the backup on an EXTERNAL disk in a different location.


Message edited by Ubrales on 07-23-2010 at 10:27:43 PM
------------------------------ All things cometh to he that waiteth - provided he that waiteth, worketh like hell while he waiteth!
Reply to Ubrales

I would agree seagate and WD are pretty good drives and I would buy either one. Stick with 7200 RPM drive or if you want to spent the money get the WD Velocity raptor thats' a 10k drive.

Reply to xxsk8er101xx
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Storage > General Discussion > [Solved] Going to buy 1TB internal hdd,seagate or samsung or wd?
Go to:

There are 1465 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
Connecting a Laptop Hard disk directly to Desktop (SATA)
By RetiredChief, 5 hours ago:

fantastik250 - Sata interface is only for data. Does not adjust any voltages. power is...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
Top experts