HDD vs SSD

We are looking to purchase new laptops for some of our developers at work. I believe we should be using SSD (Intel X25-M probably 80Gb) instead of HDD 7200 rpm drives.

My boss bought a solid state laptop over a year ago from dell and he said they are horrible. Keep in mind this is the drive dell put in and not one of the intel's drives. The O/S was also XP and not windows 7.

Does anyone have any good newer comparison links that shows why a X25-M G2 (80Gb or 160Gb) is way better than a generic 7200 rpm drive? I searched and looked around, but most comparisons are SSD vs SSD and not HDD vs SDD.

I found one good link here:
http://www.thebuzzmedia.com/intel-x25-m-160gb-ssd-vs-seagate-cheetah-15k-6-scsi-benchmarks/

Thanks!
2 answers Last reply
More about tomshardware
  1. Generation 2 and 3 SSD with Trim Cmd (Win 7 and in AHCI mode) will BLOW any HDD out of the water. (For XP and Vista must use a 3rd party trim emulator, ie for intel its called SSD toolbox.)
    (1) Never ever buy a loptop with SSD installed, normally they install a low end one and charge as if it's a high end one.

    Most drives a year ago were Generation 1, which DOES not suppoert windows 7 Trim cmd. Old SSD degraded very quickly, many end up performing worst than a HDD. Intel G1 was an exception (However it does not support trim CMD). We are now at 3rd generation (Support Sata 6) Just get a vortex-2

    As to performance - Look at 4 K random read/writes and access times (these two areas are the most important. Access time, SSDs 50 -> 100 times faster. 4K random read/writes: low end SSD approx 10 x faster, Good SSD 20->40 x faster than Mechanical. I have 2 installed in Laptops (a patriot Torqx and a Intel 80) and one in desktop (intel 80 Gig G2) - would never trad back to Mechanical.

    http://www.notebookcheck.net/SSD-versus-HDD-in-comparison.18750.0.html
    Here is one that list the High end WD VelociRaptor In some of the charts. http://www.anandtech.com/show/2808/4

    Here is one on the new C300. Look at random 4 K read/writes. A mechanical HDD would = 1!! on these two charts.
    http://www.anandtech.com/show/3812/the-ssd-diaries-crucials-realssd-c300/2
  2. The simplest thing would be to buy a cheapo laptop and equip it with a good SSD, then compare boot/sleep/hibernation times with the best laptop in the office with a HDD. When the $350 laptop blows the the expensive laptop's times out of the water, your point is made. Charts, just don't compare to pushing the on button and seeing it first hand.
Ask a new question

Read More

SSD Hard Drives Storage