Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > AMD PII X4 955, or Intel Q9550?
Word :    Username :           
 

I am hopefully going to build a new computer here pretty soon. The machine will be used for all of my school work, a lot of web browsing, LITTLE audo/video rendering, and gaming is probably the most important on there.

I do plan on oc'ing at least some, so which of these is easier to oc?

What do you guys think? AMD or Intel? The two builds i have on Newegg come out to be the same price so price isn't a deciding factor.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Yes the i7 is only $20 more, but the mobo and memory are also a bit more expensive. I ask because someone suggested that particular intel quad core over the amd PII X4 955 build that i had posted. I was just curious on which one performed better.

Reply to touchdowntexas13

touchdowntexas13 wrote :

Yes the i7 is only $20 more, but the mobo and memory are also a bit more expensive. I ask because someone suggested that particular intel quad core over the amd PII X4 955 build that i had posted. I was just curious on which one performed better.




I understand about the mobo and memory being expensive. I was just giving you crap. :lol:

In the thread i'm going to link below. The Q is very good for overclocking but the 955 is very close being.

http://www.overclock.net/amd-cpus/ [...] 5-a-2.html

------------------------------ Core I7 920 D0 @ 4.2Ghz
MSI X58 Pro-E
32GB SSD, WD Blacks In R0
Sapphire HD 5870's In XFire
Reply to PsychoSaysDie

oh ok. I'm not inclined to overclock to 4 GHz or anything. If i could get the 955 to 3.6 i would be happy.

Reply to touchdowntexas13
- 1 +

I'd go with the 955 then.

------------------------------ Asus P6T deluxe
i7 965 @ 4.2GHz (200*21), 1.384V
12GB Corsair Dominator DDR3-1600 CAS 7
Reply to cjl

cjl wrote :

I'd go with the 955 then.




Agreed

------------------------------ Core I7 920 D0 @ 4.2Ghz
MSI X58 Pro-E
32GB SSD, WD Blacks In R0
Sapphire HD 5870's In XFire
Reply to PsychoSaysDie

I think so as well.

------------------------------ Phenom II X2 unlocked to four cores @ 3.8gHz,1.45V. 4GB DDR3-1600 Gigabyte 785g ATi Radeon HD4870 1GB
Run Folding@Home! Support Toms Hardware Guide, Team 40051!
CPU Buyer's Guide
Reply to smithereen

that's what i will do then. thanks guys.

Reply to touchdowntexas13

I'd check out THIS article first, before making any final decision..

Reply to fazers_on_stun

There is an article here on Tom's that slightly contradicts that i think. One of the statements made in the article you linked though, was that you would only notice the performance difference in games when you owned a really expensive gpu setup (sli/cf).

I know that the article on Tom's stated that for gaming, the processors perform about the same. When the graphical settings were cranked up, there was minimal difference.

Reply to touchdowntexas13

So one thing i didn't know was that the Q9550 could use ddr3 memory...

When i make a build for both the Q9550 and PII X4 955 they come out to be the same price.

This makes me think that maybe the Q9550 might not be a bad idea after all.

Anyone else with a good opinion/advice?

Reply to touchdowntexas13

An AM3 system will be upgradable longer and have similar performance and a slightly lower price. AMD chipsets rock for cheap, Intel DDR3 chipsets are expensive. Anyways, once you equip either of them with DDR3 you're starting to get into i7 price ranges.


Message edited by smithereen on 05-20-2009 at 02:42:08 AM
------------------------------ Phenom II X2 unlocked to four cores @ 3.8gHz,1.45V. 4GB DDR3-1600 Gigabyte 785g ATi Radeon HD4870 1GB
Run Folding@Home! Support Toms Hardware Guide, Team 40051!
CPU Buyer's Guide
Reply to smithereen
- 0 +

touchdowntexas13 wrote :

So one thing i didn't know was that the Q9550 could use ddr3 memory...

When i make a build for both the Q9550 and PII X4 955 they come out to be the same price.

This makes me think that maybe the Q9550 might not be a bad idea after all.

Anyone else with a good opinion/advice?


The Q9550 can't really fully use DDR3 though. The front side bus architecture limits the gains from faster memory on the older Core 2 series CPUs. The i7 and Phenom II can better use the bandwidth of DDR3, so they are the only systems I would consider DDR3 to be worthwhile on.

------------------------------ Asus P6T deluxe
i7 965 @ 4.2GHz (200*21), 1.384V
12GB Corsair Dominator DDR3-1600 CAS 7
Reply to cjl

alright well then i think i am gonna stick with am3 at this point. Thanks for all of ya'lls advice. This should be fun :)

Reply to touchdowntexas13

775 isn't technically a "dead socket" since it will still be supported until 2011. By that time, the 1366 and i7s would be old and outdated as well.

------------------------------ i7 920, E5300
GTX260, HD4870, HD4830
Reply to BlueScreenDeath

From what i have been reading, it won't be "dead", but there won't be anything new coming out for it. There will just be lower prices on the processors that run on that socket. I could be mistaken, but that's what i have been reading.

Reply to touchdowntexas13

Be surprised if you see any new CPUs for it.

------------------------------ Phenom II X2 unlocked to four cores @ 3.8gHz,1.45V. 4GB DDR3-1600 Gigabyte 785g ATi Radeon HD4870 1GB
Run Folding@Home! Support Toms Hardware Guide, Team 40051!
CPU Buyer's Guide
Reply to smithereen

955 because their will be faster cpu's coming out in AM3.
Q9550 is as fast as its gonna get (non upgradeable)

------------------------------ P965/Q6700@3.2 8MB HD4850 OC Edition
4GB Corsair XMS 800
Vista64/Win7
Fatality 550w/Antec 300
Reply to zipzoomflyhigh

^ well there might be some Q9770's floating around on ebay for $100 or something by 2011 but otherwise it's gonna be the fastest cpu you would be able to find.

Reply to Helloworld_98

cjl wrote :

I'd go with the 955 then.



I also agree.

Reply to deredita

Anandtech: Phenom II X3 720BE & CrossFire X Performance
http://www.anandtech.com/mb/showdo [...] i=3533&p=9

PhII 720BE combo deals ---->>
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] =10&page=1


Your choice as to DDR2 or DDR3. For you needs won't really matter. The Gigabyte GA-MA790X-UD4P combo gets my vote for $219 - or maybe the Asus 790FX if that's yer thang.

Pump the extra bucks into your vid card(s)

Reply to wisecracker
- 0 +

everyone says 955. I do to but i think its so strange to see all the AMD support. Honestly they need it. Its just nice having something new and different to advise ppl to get. And the Phenom 2 is a great cpu to advise on. I just got so tired of all these intel builds I done for like the last 3 yrs, The 955 will be everything you need plus its fun with the unlocked multiplier. Just a different age, I hope things stay with a little more options. I mean you cant just say one over the other anymore, there is a real option again. Its pleasing to see this.

------------------------------ Always remember: the Truth is another LIE!
Reply to ocre

I still haven't forgiven AMD for pulling the 939 series because I'm a gnarly old bastard. :lol:

Reply to mousemonkey
- -1 +

you could get a Core I7 920 @ Micro Center for $200.00.

------------------------------ My Pride & Joy: Intel Core I7 920 @ 3.6 GHZ w. Xigmatek DK S1283V / MSI X58M / Patriot Viper DDR3 1600 / 2x Super Talent ME 64GB SSD in raid 0 / WD 750GB HDD / 2 x XFX 4870 1GB in CFX / NZXT ROGUE case with 5x 120mm fans / Corsair 750HX 750w PSU
Reply to peanutpc

mousemonkey wrote :

I still haven't forgiven AMD for pulling the 939 series because I'm a gnarly old bastard. :lol:



Yeah, dissapointed me a bit too that the upper limit of skt939 was a 4800x2 (if I remember right)... even more dissappointing was the relatively quick phase out time of even these chips.


I upgraded my K8 to a 4600x2 a couple of years back - I had to bring it forward as they were getting increasingly hard to find and prices were starting to climb. Does the job nicely.



I do have another machine based on the legendary Q6600 though. :)

Reply to Amiga500

939 was the fx-60 i believe or maybe there were one of two other can't remember.

------------------------------ I'm a git, deal with it.

Antec 1200,PC Power & Cooling 750,Gigabyte DS4-x48,Intel Q9550@3.4 W/Xigmatek S1283,8GB OCZ DDR2 800,ATI 4870X2,X-FI>CA 640C amp>Tannoy R300/Senn 595's
Reply to strangestranger

For all of the people suggesting the 955...

Do you guys find that you wish you had SLI support on your mobos?

I didn't know that SLI wasn't supported with AM3, and that is kind of disappointing to me. I'm not necessarily the kind of person that wants to put multiple GPU's in a system, but with the release of the new 4770's sometimes the best deal is to CF/SLI two weaker components. I just don't want to not have that option if Nvidia came out with a gpu with similar value as the new 4770 down the road.

One good thing is that I am pretty sure i will never want more than two GPU's (at least not for a long while) so since they are coming out with these dual-GPU cards I could get away with buying one of those cards and not worrying about SLI support on the mobo.

I'm not saying that I only want Nvidia products, but i do want the option of getting the best value/performance parts when they come out, and if that happens to be two Nvidia cards in SLI...

Anybody worried or disappointed about that factor in their systems?

Reply to touchdowntexas13

I can't even find an i7 920 on Micro Center's site...

Reply to touchdowntexas13

Everyone waves around the $200 Micro Center i7 as if everyone lives near a Micro Center. Heck, I live in a large city (Charlotte), and I'd never even HEARD of Micro Center before I started visiting Tom's / Anand / Hard regularly.

------------------------------ Antec 1200 - Corsair 1000HX - Intel Core i7 920 (4GHz) - MSi Eclipse Plus - 12GB Corsair DDR3 1600 XMS3 - 2x Radeon 4870x2 QuadFire w/ Arctic Cooling Accelero XTREME - 2x 300GB WD VelociRaptor RAID 0 - 1x 1TB WD Caviar Black - Windows 7 RC 64-bit
Reply to EQPlayer

well there is a microcenter about 45 minutes from where i live. I'm not sure if that's worth the 80 bucks saved when you factor in time and gas cost...

Reply to touchdowntexas13
- 0 +

@touchdown...

Since hd4770 is already out... I dunno why you brought up the option of the possibility of an equivalent NVidia gpu. It may never happened. Even if it does, a 955 or i7 could probably get old by then.

Just get the 955 and a 4770 right NOW and be happy with it. Get them and enjoy... no need to come back here to read more reviews of newer product. It wont make your joy last long. lol

Reply to Ken168

^^^What he said

------------------------------ Phenom II X2 unlocked to four cores @ 3.8gHz,1.45V. 4GB DDR3-1600 Gigabyte 785g ATi Radeon HD4870 1GB
Run Folding@Home! Support Toms Hardware Guide, Team 40051!
CPU Buyer's Guide
Reply to smithereen

@Ken

I don't really understand what you are saying. Yes i would be getting the 4770's NOW, but later down the road NVIDIA might have the better value.

THEREFORE...
I want the option of both SLI and Crossfire.

Does that make any sense or am i just crazy?

Reply to touchdowntexas13

He is saying that you shouldn't worry so much about what might be. Get the 4770 now and enjoy them. They will be more than good enough.

------------------------------ Phenom II X2 unlocked to four cores @ 3.8gHz,1.45V. 4GB DDR3-1600 Gigabyte 785g ATi Radeon HD4870 1GB
Run Folding@Home! Support Toms Hardware Guide, Team 40051!
CPU Buyer's Guide
Reply to smithereen
- 0 +

@touchdown...

I used AMD64 3000+ (socket 939) for 6 years. I had been in the market for Core2Duo Q6600... and then I heard of 45nm processor (supposed to be cooler and higher clock, more overcloking ability etc), so i waited. Before I picked any of those... rumour or Nehalem was out.. so i waited again.

Read the review at launch... it was amazing. But then you hear about the awesomeness of Phenom 2... since I already waited for like 2 years... thought I should wait for another month to see what AMD have with their latest cpu.
It endless... in the end I bought an AMD Phenom 2 940BE and just bought the Ati hd4770 few weeks ago. I am very happy with my choice. I didnt have to wait for AM3 processor and I bought the gpu the instant it is available in my area.

I hope you see where I'm coming from. If you want to have the option... i wish you goodluck in waiting OR just take what available TODAY.

goodluck

Reply to Ken168

why does everyone think i am waiting for something???

 

i am not waiting on anything, i am simply saying when i UPGRADE (upgrading is when you buy new parts for a system you have already built) i would like to have the option to crossfire/sli. WHAT IS SO HARD ABOUT THAT?

 

In other words, i will build a system NOW that has the ability to utilize both crossfire and sli for when i need to UPGRADE in the FUTURE. I don't think i can make myself any clearer. I'm starting to think people are just getting on here reading the last post and somehow get this idea that i am waiting for something better to come out???

 

sorry, i know better than that. thanks anyways guys. i know you were just trying to help. sorry if i was being rude, but i was starting to get a little frustrated.


Message edited by touchdowntexas13 on 05-24-2009 at 08:21:59 AM
Reply to touchdowntexas13
- 0 +

sounds like you want i7 then.

Reply to BadTRip

I just wanted someone to tell me their experience on whether or not they felt they were missing out on SLI by going with the AMD processor/mobo...

but yes i will probably go i7 unless someone can convince me otherwise.

Reply to touchdowntexas13
- 0 +

if you want both x-fire and sli, and have the budget then there is no convincing necessary

Reply to BadTRip

do all x58 boards support cf and sli?

Reply to noodle64
- 0 +

No. They all support CF, but SLI support is more limited.

------------------------------ Asus P6T deluxe
i7 965 @ 4.2GHz (200*21), 1.384V
12GB Corsair Dominator DDR3-1600 CAS 7
Reply to cjl
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > AMD PII X4 955, or Intel Q9550?
Go to:

There are 698 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them