Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Spinpoint, Deskstar or Caviar Green?

Last response: in Storage
Share
September 2, 2010 12:30:37 AM

I have a 2TB Hitachi Deskstar that I used for games and other general storage, and it suddenly died on me (it tripped SMART with "Seek Error Rate"). The three choices I have within a sensible budget (no Caviar Blacks or Barracuda XTs) are another 2TB Deskstar, a 2TB Samsung Spinpoint F4 and a 2TB WD Caviar Green. Of the three, which one should I use to replace the Deskstar?
a c 415 G Storage
September 2, 2010 12:56:55 AM

The deskstar is a 7200rpm drive, the other two are lower-speed low-power drives. That's the largest difference between them. If it's the OS drive, I'd go with the deskstar. Otherwise, choose based on whether performance or low power / low temperature are more important to you.
m
0
l
September 2, 2010 1:08:21 AM

The Deskstar was just for storage, OS is a smaller Caviar Black. I'd prefer performance, although general reliability is the highest priority.

Edit: Wow, just found out I could get a 2TB Caviar Black for cheap. I think I've decided on a hard drive.
m
0
l
Related resources
a c 415 G Storage
September 2, 2010 1:31:43 AM

Other than hearsay, there's nothing to distinguish these drives in terms of reliability. It will be easier to keep the lower-speed drives cool, so that might help.

Here's some hearsay: I've been using WD Green drives for quite a while now, including two 2GB drives I purchased about three months ago, and have been quite happy with them. I use them as bare drives in a USB drive dock, so cooling isn't an issue for me. They get handled a lot more than an internally mounted drive would, but that hasn't caused any problems so far.
m
0
l
September 2, 2010 3:17:14 PM

gendoikari1 said:

Edit: Wow, just found out I could get a 2TB Caviar Black for cheap. I think I've decided on a hard drive.


Where?
m
0
l
!