( ASUS EAH4870X2TOP/HTDI/2G Radeon HD 4870 X2 2GB 512-bit GDDR5 PCI Express 2.0 x16 HDCP Ready CrossFire Supported Video Card - Retail )
Help me choose which one would be the best for highest performance/FPS, or a card that would give me a higher FPS if there is one. Also i need help deciding on the motherboard, these are the two that i am thinking of buying.
Best possible performance can cost a lot; any budget limit? What resolution/monitor (model # please) will you game with? You want single/dual/triple/quad GPU, one 1-2-3 cards?
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar
well since ur willing to spend the kind of money i would go with a quad-core, either the AMD Phenom II or Intel i7......
as for the video cards....to me it looks like you went and found the most expensive cards from ati and nvidia and are assuming that they are they best well thats not exactly true, heres my suggestions:
Well i run my resolution at 1680X1050 for my desktop, which im assuming is the same for gaming.. (CSS) and dosent really matter on my budget right now, and that processor is DAMN EXPENSIVE, but im sure it will be the best one possible, but as for the video card (i want intel, not amd ) are you sure thats the best card? i thought for sure that the 4870X2 would be better than that, and the 295 also.. and I actually diden't look just for the most expensive , my friend has a 4850, and has the highest resolution possible, i think. because he plays on his 40 inch hd tv, and gets 300FPS.. so i figured that if i got a 4870X2 (not 2 cards but one card with 2 built in... i think) i would get like around 500-600 fps with 1680X1050.
P.S i can buy a new monitor to.. if that affects my FPS (which i highly doubt it does)
If you want great performance for your money, get an i7 920, get a single GTX285 and get a PSU that would support a 2nd one (~750-850W). You will same a ton of money and if you need the extra FPS, which I doubt at 1680x1050, you can always SLI a 2nd one.
You asked for the best, that is what you got ... doesn't mean that a system that would cost 25% of that won't perform 90% on par
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar
my friend has a 4850, and has the highest resolution possible, i think. because he plays on his 40 inch hd tv, and gets 300FPS.. so i figured that if i got a 4870X2 (not 2 cards but one card with 2 built in... i think) i would get like around 500-600 fps with 1680X1050.
The amount of FPS depends on the game and the resolution; 1000$ of video card still ave trouble coping with Crysis @ 2560x1600 for example...
BTW, there is no point in maxing FPS to that limit, the brain able to decode only about 60FPS and the eye itself is limited to about 100FPS.
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar
Well, id rather order it all from newegg.ca (i live in canada so shipping will cost A LOT less) and also so it all comes at once.. but thanks, that new PSU looks better, and brought the overall price down, and about the CPU cooler, the tuniq tower, my friend has it and its massive, it works very very well, so i think that it would do some good to this computer too, and yes CSS is my main game, but i also want a very very good computer, to run the newer games (crysis, far cry 2) and so on.. and are you sure 850W would be enough to power all that?
And also i read some reviews on some websites.. i googled gtx 295 vs 4870X2, and it looks like the 295 is more powerful then the 4870.. so im leaning towards the gtx 295, but i still want to know which one would be better.
For canadian prices/store, check www.shopbot.ca (price check) and also check www.directcanada.com, they don't charge shipping for orders over 300$ including cases; it can be a 35-50$ saving. Some store also don't charge provincial taxes, only federal. All that can sum-up to a big difference.
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar
Well, id rather order it all from newegg.ca (i live in canada so shipping will cost A LOT less) and also so it all comes at once.. but thanks, that new PSU looks better, and brought the overall price down, and about the CPU cooler, the tuniq tower, my friend has it and its massive, it works very very well, so i think that it would do some good to this computer too, and yes CSS is my main game, but i also want a very very good computer, to run the newer games (crysis, far cry 2) and so on.. and are you sure 850W would be enough to power all that?
And also i read some reviews on some websites.. i googled gtx 295 vs 4870X2, and it looks like the 295 is more powerful then the 4870.. so im leaning towards the gtx 295, but i still want to know which one would be better.
Also, the GTX 295 flattens the 4870 X2, though the price is alot steeper.
No, it doesn't.
The 4870x2 'flattened' the gtx280. That was a dual gpu vs a single gpu and was to be expected. The gtx295 isn't that much better than the 4870x2. Better yes, flatten? No.
One benefit in getting the GTX295 over the 4870 X2 is that the X2 HAS to run in crossfire mode, which I gather can have some setup issues (as does SLI) while the 295 is a single GPU.
However, for your purposes, you don't need huge video performance with that monitor... the monitor DOES matter, not because of the screen size, but because of the standard resolution... for example a 1920x1200 needs to do at least 4 times the calculations of a 960x600 screen.
In practice, since you are building from scratch, you are probably better off getting an i7-920. Get 6 or 12 GB of memory, a decent SSD with a 1TB Data Disk and a single GTX295. You can then upgrade your graphics easily in a year or two when/if you want to play something that exceeds its capabilities. The Phenom II is a nice option if you are on a budget, but why go to Sizzlers when you can afford Ruths Chris ?
I assume by when you say memory, you mean RAM, and getting 6 or 12 gbs, i heard that windows xp can only use 4 gbs, but if i get XP 64.. but then if i also get windows xp 64 then i might have problems with the stuff i am getting?
One benefit in getting the GTX295 over the 4870 X2 is that the X2 HAS to run in crossfire mode, which I gather can have some setup issues (as does SLI) while the 295 is a single GPU.
However, for your purposes, you don't need huge video performance with that monitor... the monitor DOES matter, not because of the screen size, but because of the standard resolution... for example a 1920x1200 needs to do at least 4 times the calculations of a 960x600 screen.
In practice, since you are building from scratch, you are probably better off getting an i7-920. Get 6 or 12 GB of memory, a decent SSD with a 1TB Data Disk and a single GTX295. You can then upgrade your graphics easily in a year or two when/if you want to play something that exceeds its capabilities. The Phenom II is a nice option if you are on a budget, but why go to Sizzlers when you can afford Ruths Chris ?
The 295 is two GPUs as well so still uses an internal SLi bridge, there's no difference in the set-up of the two cards. The 285 is the single GPU version.
As ixion said, the GTX295 is a dual-GPU card, some kind of GTX260x2 I think (die-shrinked + some extras). For the best single-GPU, you have to get the GTX285.
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar
TOTAL = $ 2,090.00 (Does Not Include Shipping or Tax, Approx. $2,200 - $2,300 with Shipping & Tax)
This build is made assuming that you do not need a Monitor, Keyboard, Mouse, Speakers, or Operating System. So let me know if u need any other suggestions.
TOTAL = $ 2,090.00 (Does Not Include Shipping or Tax, Approx. $2,200 - $2,300 with Shipping & Tax)
This build is made assuming that you do not need a Monitor, Keyboard, Mouse, Speakers, or Operating System. So let me know if u need any other suggestions.
If i used this build.. what kind of FPS would i get..? (on 1680X1050, highest settings everything on css?) and are you sure 700W would be enough to power this beast?
And, i would want a top of the line motherboard, (if that isen't already) and a REALLY good video card.
Message edited by Arigo on 03-26-2009 at 09:22:02 PM
the build is suggested above is overkill for css, the build above is more for games like crysis. i dont really know the exact numbers but believe me that system will run css above and beyond what anyone would need.
the motherboard and video card that i suggested in the build are both very high quality products, msi and gigabyte are pretty good brands.
700W should be plenty but im not 100%, maybe someone else can answer that question better.
the build is suggested above is overkill for css, the build above is more for games like crysis. i dont really know the exact numbers but believe me that system will run css above and beyond what anyone would need.
the motherboard and video card that i suggested in the build are both very high quality products, msi and gigabyte are pretty good brands.
700W should be plenty but im not 100%, maybe someone else can answer that question better.
would that mobo be better then the Asus Striker II Extreme, because that board looks SICK, and if i was to use the striker, would i be able to put an AMD processor on it ( http://www.newegg.ca/Product/Produ [...] 6819103471 ) and a gtx 295.? because right now, that AMD processor looks REALLY good.. that 1300 dollar intel processor ( 3.2 ghz quad core) compared to the 3.0 ghz quad core AMD one.. for only 380 dollars.. i think i would want the AMD processor.. So my question right now is.
Is the Asus striker II extreme, better then the mobo you just told me to get? and
Could i run an, AMD Phenom II with a Asus striker II extreme, and a GTX 295? thanks!
Message edited by Arigo on 03-26-2009 at 10:20:00 PM
The striker II is an Intel core 17 board so no you can not run a Phenom II. You are going way overkill for the game you want to play. You can run a 9800+ at the res you want to and get same results as a gtx 295. If you are going core i7 you do not need anything over a 920. If you want you can oc it to compete with the 965.
The striker II is an Intel core 17 board so no you can not run a Phenom II. You are going way overkill for the game you want to play. You can run a 9800+ at the res you want to and get same results as a gtx 295. If you are going core i7 you do not need anything over a 920. If you want you can oc it to compete with the 965.
He also wants to be able to play Crysis and Farcry 2 at high detail levels. I was going to say something similar in regards to the serious overkill this would be to just play CS:S, but kept reading... And technically, 7-series nVidia and X1XX ATI cards have more than ample power to play CS:S. A 9800 begins to become overkill for that game, even with the modifications over the years.
While I truly admire the power of Core i7, the price of an i7 system, complete with X58 mobo, tri-DDR3, just plain pushes me away. I'd sacrifice the performance hit going to a Phenom II vs i7 setup if it would save me a couple hundred bennies, and it would, easily.
Ther is only one nipple on the gtx 295 thus only able to run one sli bridge. For multi card sli a bridge has to be attached to all the cards which requires 3 bridges or 1 bridge with 6 connectors on it. It is a hardware limit.
Message edited by chef7734 on 03-27-2009 at 04:54:39 AM
cards are perfectly capable of communicating across the pcie bus, it was just nv's decision not to. as a matter of fact, how do you think all these lovely utilitis alter your fan speed or windows knows all about your card.
cards are perfectly capable of communicating across the pcie bus, it was just nv's decision not to. as a matter of fact, how do you think all these lovely utilitis alter your fan speed or windows knows all about your card.
Not just MV but you are requited a crossfire bridge to link 2 cards also. Ohh and the 3dfx voodoo sli also required a bridge.
It is defently dependent on whether the game takes advantage of it or not. Kinda sucks if you pay 1200 on cards and the game you play does not use it. He would really be wasting money if he purchased anything in this level if all he plays cs source.
Quad sli is 2 dual gpu cards. Basically what you are getting is 4 260's. I am not sure if it has anything to do with bandwidth across the bus as you can only put 2 4870x2 also but can use 3 4870 something to research.
okay,well now that i know i cant run those togheter, i either have to give up the motherboard.. or the processor.. should i keep the Asus striker II extreme? or should i keep the phenom II and make an AMD based build..
If i keep the phenom.. what would be the best mobo that would work with it, and also the best graphics card that would work with it?
TOTAL = $ 1,640.00 (Does Not Include Shipping or Tax, Approx. $1,740 with Shipping & Tax)
This build is made assuming that you do not need a Monitor, Keyboard, Mouse, Speakers, or Operating System. So let me know if u need any other suggestions.
TOTAL = $ 1,640.00 (Does Not Include Shipping or Tax, Approx. $1,740 with Shipping & Tax)
okay that build is looking very good to me... but i was wondering.. could i put a gtx 295 in there? if i couldn't could i put 2 4870X2's?? and could you give a different case? because my friends got the same case, and i dont wanna get the same thing.. (cost under 200$) and pick out a nice lookin one.. and make sure its got good airflow, etc fans and what not This build is made assuming that you do not need a Monitor, Keyboard, Mouse, Speakers, or Operating System. So let me know if u need any other suggestions.
Message edited by Arigo on 03-27-2009 at 08:48:35 PM
You can always get the Antec Nine Hundred Two, but you will pay twice as much for it (205$). This case is more like the Antec 1200 but smaller and comes with air filters.
HOWEVER, if you buy from DirectCanada, it costs ~150$ and, if you get your order to 300$ (by getting a PSU for example, the Corsais are often cheaper than on NewEgg anyway) you get free shipping.
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar
I don't think you will have any trouble fitting any video card in there. I would vote against two 4870x2, more than 2 GPU don't scale well. If you want more than the GTX295, you will have to go for two GTX285 in SLI.
------------------------------The capacity to learn is a gift; The ability to learn is a skill; The willingness to learn is a choice. - Rebec of Ginaz
Reply to Zenthar