Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

WD Caviar Black vs Caviar Green

Last response: in Storage
Share
October 4, 2010 10:42:30 PM

Regarding the Caviar Black & Caviar Green series of Western Digital HDDs , can anyone provide me with reviews or comparisons between these two series ?
What are the advantages or disadvantages for each of them ? Is there a significant difference in the performance , reading time , writing time , transfer rate .... etc ? Is it worth paying more money to get the BLACK or is it ok with the GREEN ? Which is good value for money ?

Any additional information would be very appreciated ?
a c 415 G Storage
October 4, 2010 10:55:14 PM

The Green drives are optimized for low power usage and as a result they're noticeably poorer performers. In particular, they spin down after several seconds of inactivity so the first access to them after an idle period can take a few seconds.

The Black drives are geared more toward performance and they don't have any power-saving features to slow them down.

Choose a Green drive if you want bulk storage and performance isn't a concern. Green drives are especially good in external enclosures because they run a lot cooler than the Black drives.

If you want a drive that performs well, particularly if you plan to install the OS on it, choose a Black drive.
October 4, 2010 10:59:22 PM

Is the performance difference that much ? or is it little ?
Related resources
a c 415 G Storage
October 4, 2010 11:18:29 PM

You can compare the benchmarks between a black drive (WD10FALS) and a green drive (WD10EACS) here: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/hitachi-western-dig...

Specific models of blacks and greens vary a bit, but this probably reasonably representative for drives using the same platter density. Basically the black drive looks to have an access time and transfer rate that's about 20% faster than a green drive. It's really up to you to decide whether that's significant for your purposes.


October 5, 2010 12:04:02 AM

Another question please : What about the lifespan ?
a b G Storage
October 5, 2010 4:34:14 AM

Well, theorectically, the Green should last longer. Practically, who knows?
a b G Storage
October 5, 2010 6:21:04 AM

The black has 5 year warranty and the green 3 years, if that's a consideration.
a c 415 G Storage
October 5, 2010 6:57:58 AM

For practical purposes I don't think there's any way to know if Green or Black drives in general will last longer - and individual drives vary even more. Lifespan is not something I'd really worry about in terms of choosing a drive. Simply be aware that ANY drive can fail and have a sound backup strategy in place.
October 11, 2010 2:27:54 AM

Thanks a lot
October 11, 2010 4:22:34 PM

Caviar Black all the way! Unless you want to be a tree hugger saving energy, Go Caviar Black :) 
!