Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > AM3 CPU in AM2+ Mobo = significant bottleneck or no?

AM3 CPU in AM2+ Mobo = significant bottleneck or no?

Forum CPU & Components : CPUs - AM3 CPU in AM2+ Mobo = significant bottleneck or no?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

It's pretty obvious that it hinders its abilities, but how much exactly? I plan on using an AMD Phenom II X4 in a slightly basic gaming computer (dunno if you know what I mean by "slightly" basic), and would rather save some money by NOT buying one of the more expensive AM3 mobos, and getting an AM2+ one. What do you think I should do? I would be using this computer for basic video editing and basic gaming (blizzard games, and they are generally known for considering weaker computers). Thanks a lot in advance for the help.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

An AM3 Phenom II X4 will run the same in an AM2+ board as it does an AM3 board, the only difference is the memory you can use. There is a very minimal performance difference in DDR2 and DDR3, you'll loose at most 5% performance.

Reply to loneninja

loneninja wrote :

An AM3 Phenom II X4 will run the same in an AM2+ board as it does an AM3 board, the only difference is the memory you can use. There is a very minimal performance difference in DDR2 and DDR3, you'll loose at most 5% performance.



thanks a lot. however, lol dont take this as an insult, but how do you know this? because others have said that it bottle necks it and others say it doesn't. it's just that im trying to build a pc without costing too much, but more than that i don't want to sacrifice performance for cost, that is, performance that I would actually use.

Reply to skyturnred

i current run a
AM3 Phenom II X3 TripleCore 720 3.9GHZ cpu in a
GA-MA770-US3 am2+motherboard
with 12 gig DDR2-1066
so the answer to your question is no it wont bottleneck it at all as long as the ram u pick is (DDR2-800) and above that is good
cause the ddr2-667 and 533 seem to bottleneck it a bit
in benchmarking i ran the
DDR2-533
DDr2-667
DDr2-800 id say this is min for AM3 chip set before u notice performance difference
DDr2-1066 between this and the 533-667 was a massive improvement in speed +benchmark stats so yea
DDr3-1333
DDR3-1600 -not much noticeable difference between the 2 and the ddr2-1066

 

so if picking ram go with thee DDR2-800 or 1066 if u don't want to spend alot 1066 for max performance for $$

 

so hope this helps :D


Message edited by viper200 on 06-30-2009 at 12:27:28 PM
Reply to viper200
- 0 +

The bottleneck existed when you installed an older phenom (9950,9850, etc) which was AM2+ into an AM2 motherboard, so the HT was not full speed.
THe only difference between AM2+ and AM3 is memory supported, so there is no "bottleneck" but a potential performance gain (minimal) if you upgraded to DDR3.

Reply to sanchz

well, i don't think that the motherboard itself is more expensive, i think the ram is and its not that much, btw you should get DDR3 board, the memory is getting cheaper and DDR2 is getting more expensive and in the future if you want to upgrade your ram you might be SOL because of price (look at DDR prices compared to DDR2 and DDR3)

Reply to mindless728

k thanks everyone a lot

Reply to skyturnred

Not much of a bottleneck - but go AM3

It's only a matter of time before AMD drops the DDR2 memory controllers in AM3 CPUs - dang nice of them to make the effort but they won't do it forever.

And we don't want to hear you in a year complain about that new AM3 CPU that won't work in your AM2+ mobo - LOL

Reply to wisecracker

This price difference between a 940 and a 955 is $55. That's significant.

------------------------------ Phenom II X2 unlocked to four cores @ 3.8gHz,1.45V. 4GB DDR3-1600 Gigabyte 785g ATi Radeon HD4870 1GB
Run Folding@Home! Support Toms Hardware Guide, Team 40051!
CPU Buyer's Guide
Reply to smithereen

Do AM3 CPUs work in all AM2+ motherboards?

Reply to Andy1633

Andy1633 wrote :

Do AM3 CPUs work in all AM2+ motherboards?



Before I answer, I am no computer tech. I am new to building pcs.

I think you can use am3 cpus in ALMOSt all am2 mobos, because they generally release a bios update that permits it.

Reply to skyturnred

Andy1633 wrote :

Do AM3 CPUs work in all AM2+ motherboards?



Most AM2+ motherboards have had BIOS updates released to allow the use of AM3 processors, but to be sure you'll need to check your motherboards cpu support list which can be found on the manufacturers website. You also need to consider that a high number of entry level AM2+ boards only support 95W processors, so once again check to see what processors are supported as 125W processors may damage your board.

Reply to loneninja

Ye I checked on the asus website and the board I'm looking at buying has 120W support and a BIOS update will add AM3 support.

Reply to Andy1633
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > CPUs > AM3 CPU in AM2+ Mobo = significant bottleneck or no?
Go to:

There are 1356 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them