Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

How accurate is S.M.A.R.T. for hard drives?

Last response: in Storage
October 28, 2010 4:42:13 PM


Has anyone ever been saved from a HDD failure from a SMART warning?

More about : accurate hard drives

a c 415 G Storage
October 28, 2010 5:59:07 PM

Google's study on disk reliability indicates that there is a fairly strong correlation between some types of errors reported by SMART and increased likelihood of failure. The issue is that the likelihood of failure is still less than 50% - for example the average drive that reports a scan error is still 70% likely to keep working just fine for at least the next 8 months. So you're faced with the question of whether or not to replace a drive that ~probably~ won't fail.
a b G Storage
October 28, 2010 9:05:03 PM

Yes. I have been saved 2x with SMART warnings with some old Maxtor drives. Granted, I do have a very good back up system and these drives didn't have anything important, but nevertheless I was able to avoid down time by ordering some new HDDs before they completely failed.
a b G Storage
October 30, 2010 12:11:42 PM

Even keeping in mind what sminlal said, I, like Shado,w would not ignore a SMART warning.

Ignoring a SMART warning is worse than trusting your data to a backup system that you knew was 70% reliable.