Tom's Hardware > Forum > Motherboards & Memory > General Motherboard > Which Motherboard is better?

Which Motherboard is better?

Forum Motherboards & Memory : General Motherboard - Which Motherboard is better?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Hi, building a new pc and would like some feedback on which motherboard you think is better and why?


GIGABYTE GA-EX58-UD5 LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813128362



ASUS P6T Deluxe V2 LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6813131365



My new build specs are below.


Thanks in advance ;)



CPU: Intel Core i7 920 Processor LGA1366 2.66GHz 8MB Cache CPU
Motherboard: ???
RAM: Corsair Dominator TR3X6G1600C8D 6GB (3x 2GB) PC-12800 (1600MHz) DDR3 Triple Kit
HDD: Western Digital 300G SATA II VelociRaptor(WD3000HLFS)
Graphics Card: Zotac GTX295 1792MB DDR3 896bit GRID inc
DVDROM: LG DVD22X+- DUAL LAYER DVD Rewriter with Software(GH22NP20)
Floppy: Sony 1.44 Floppy Drive(Black) Sony1.44 Floppy
Case: Antec Nine Hundred Two Tower Gaming Case w Side Window black
PSU: Corsair HX-1000 1000W ATX Modular PSU,140m Fan,3-way SLI
UPS: Belkin 4-outlet Surge protector, lifetime$40K connected Equipment Warranty
OS: Windows 7 $???

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

I happen to prefer Gigabyte motherboards. OTOH, P6T's, in their various incarnations, seem to the "reference" board for the i7's.

Reply to jsc

I'd get a bigger surge protector! And with widely spaced plugs for DC cubes.

 

Need enough for:
System
Monitor
External Drive
Cable or DSL Modem
Speakers
Powered USB Extension Box
Unknown Future Toy

 

I also like Gigabyte boards!


Message edited by mongox on 09-23-2009 at 02:40:18 AM
Reply to mongox

I like Antec cases, but they do not come with a system speaker and I am pretty sure the motherboard doesn't either.

Reply to jsc

I don't see a connection for a floppy disk on the motherboard, so look into an external USB connection floppy if you want one. Neither of the last two motherboards that I bought had a floppy connection, so this seems to be the trend.

I'd also consider getting a 5870 video card instead of a GTX295. Anandtech had a good article on the 5870 http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.aspx?i=3643 as well as one from Toms http://www.tomshardware.com/review [...] ,2422.html The 5870 should be cheaper, faster, and provide a bit longer life before becoming obsolete.

As mongox suggested, look for a bigger/better UPS/surge protector. I made the mistake of buying a small one once and found it only supplied one minute of power, not enough to do a proper shutdown in case the power goes out. What you list will take care of a little hiccup in the power grid, but not enough for a real loss of power.

Reply to Sailer

The Gigabyte board does come with a floppy header and cable. The Asus has the connector/header but shows no cable.

The Gigabyte has 10 SATA connectors and two controllers with some with special features. Seems to come with bracket to make two of them easily eSATA. The Asus has 6, one external.

I wasn't reading carefully, if that Belkin is a UPS, then just plug a good surge protector to it. I haven't really kept up on UPS lately, so don't have any recommendations. I like the look of this surge p!
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] -_-Product

Reply to mongox

Nice list you have here. Gigabyte or ASUS both are Taiwanese brands, but I prefer ASUS over Gigabyte not only in motherboards but on other parts as well.
Just a question, do you guys still use floppy disks nowadays? an innocent question=)

Reply to justinheir

My main use of floppies is to check old ones and make sure I have everything on them on a hard drive. Anytime I find a floppy, I look at it and see about properly archiving it. Since I've been using 3.5" since they came out, I have quite a few! I usually crack them in half and trash em once I copy em, to make sure I don't keep them any longer! I keep a few original program disks and ones I had fixed up with nice labels for projects! LOL

I also use a floppy for memtest.

Reply to mongox

justinheir wrote :

Nice list you have here. Gigabyte or ASUS both are Taiwanese brands, but I prefer ASUS over Gigabyte not only in motherboards but on other parts as well.
Just a question, do you guys still use floppy disks nowadays? an innocent question=)



Yes and no. My oldest computer has a floppy disk and I use it sometimes for very small files. The three motherboards of my other computers don't support a floppy and I don't feel like getting a USB floppy. As a result I copy everything to rewritable CDs or DVDs. I think the floppy was good in its time, but that time has pretty much come and gone.

Reply to Sailer

@mongox

I get it. Do you work in the library? I bet labels really work well for you.

@ Sailer
I remember the last time I used a 3.5" floppy was around 10 yrs ago. I agree, it served it's time well.
BTW, nice sailboat, do you sail often?

Reply to justinheir

LOL, no library. Been a computer professional since '83. The un-labeled diskettes out-number the labeled ones at least 10 to 1 - I long ago gave up looking at those and just trashing em. The labels were generally ones I printed up for things like diagnostics and standard MS-DOS and Windows boot disks I created for customers. If I built ten computers for XYZ Oil Company, I might create disks for them with company logo on it, etc... Something like that with my company info and ph# was a good marketing tool and made em feel special. And as far as I'm concerned, someone that hands me a check for $15,000 or more - is special!


Message edited by mongox on 09-26-2009 at 09:44:01 PM
Reply to mongox

Hands down to you man! Yeah 15 grand would be extra special for me too. (LOL)

Reply to justinheir
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Motherboards & Memory > General Motherboard > Which Motherboard is better?
Go to:

There are 705 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them