Tom's Hardware > Forum > Motherboards & Memory > Gigabyte > [Solved] Should I Stick with GB?

[Solved] Should I Stick with GB?

Forum Motherboards & Memory : Gigabyte - [Solved] Should I Stick with GB?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!

Best answer from bilbat.

Word :    Username :           
 

Hey all,

I'm working on a bare bones build for a relative and came across an issue with the GB motherboard I ordered for it. The model is a G41M-ES2L (a smaller one to say the least) and it won't even kick on. I've checked and re-checked everything, switched PSU's, etc... to no avail. Needless to say, it's going back. I know you get what you pay for, but the reviews of GB all around the net seem pretty good. Is it maybe just a common issue with this particular board or rather, just a fluke?

If I stay with GB, does anyone have a suggestion for a MOBO that will do just fine with a Pentium dual core (E5200)? Again, this is pretty bare bones, so I don't need anything over the top.

Thanks for the advice in advance!

------------------------------ -Kevin
Desktop: Q9400(stock,lapped,SpinTechQ)/Intel DP43TF/VTEK 4850(512)/8GB DDR2 800Mhz/X-Fi Titanium Pro/Liteon BD-ROM/Velociraptor/Windows 7 Pro 64-bit
Laptop: Little Toshiba Satellite (M305)/T6400/4GB DDR2 800Mhz/Windows 7 RC 64-bit (for now
I would echo both these posts. I began building (not counting re-vamping KayPro Z-80 boards) in the late eighties, have never gotten a DOA MOBO; and, after fairly extensive research, decided GB was IMHO the best manufacturer to stick with...

That does not discount the possibility of getting a bad board; most QC these days, for these sorts of products, is statistical - i.e., they've decided to accept the possibility of some finite, very small number of defectives 'escaping', to minimize the expense of testing, and provide us with a cheaper (well - let's say 'less expensive' ;) ) product. Then, there is also, for all electronics, the problem of 'infant mortality' - if it stays working for two months, it'll likely keep working well into technological obsolescence; but, getting through that two months, in a build with, say, thirty components, can possibly be hell!

The only major flaw I found in the initial assay was (and this appears to be endemic to all MOBO manufacturers) spotty, sometimes plainly incoherent tech-support - and this problem is vastly reduced by the folks here, and at TweakTown: if you've got a problem, you usually can get it fixed/figured out one place or the other...
Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

I only use GB mobo's. Never had a bad one, ever. That is a highly rated model.

Either your doing something wrong or it could be DOA.

Reply to zipzoomflyhigh

Never had a new doa board in 17 years of building. I would remove the board battery to reset the bios. Try a bare post on a phonebook, even if you have to remove the power supply from the case to reach the board. Reinstall the memory; and try a different power supply if you have one. Lots of ps have had issues with newer boards lately; don't know why.

Reply to o1die
Best answer

I would echo both these posts. I began building (not counting re-vamping KayPro Z-80 boards) in the late eighties, have never gotten a DOA MOBO; and, after fairly extensive research, decided GB was IMHO the best manufacturer to stick with...

That does not discount the possibility of getting a bad board; most QC these days, for these sorts of products, is statistical - i.e., they've decided to accept the possibility of some finite, very small number of defectives 'escaping', to minimize the expense of testing, and provide us with a cheaper (well - let's say 'less expensive' ;) ) product. Then, there is also, for all electronics, the problem of 'infant mortality' - if it stays working for two months, it'll likely keep working well into technological obsolescence; but, getting through that two months, in a build with, say, thirty components, can possibly be hell!

The only major flaw I found in the initial assay was (and this appears to be endemic to all MOBO manufacturers) spotty, sometimes plainly incoherent tech-support - and this problem is vastly reduced by the folks here, and at TweakTown: if you've got a problem, you usually can get it fixed/figured out one place or the other...

Reply to bilbat

Well said by all. I've tried every little trick in the book: Switched PSU's, removed memory, the battery, and even took the board out of the case to try it on a non-metal surface. I agree, it is plain to see that quality control is a matter of statistical probability rather than actual hands on testing anymore. Never the less, I think I'll stick with GB on the re-order.

Appreciate the advice in the matter.

Reply to buwish

Do you have a case speaker attached? At this point, it is often the only information available about the underlying problem...

Reply to bilbat

I had this recently with a DQ6, its arrive DOA

Reply to bulldogbeau
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Motherboards & Memory > Gigabyte > [Solved] Should I Stick with GB?
Go to:

There are 1273 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them