Which 4870? RMA'd my old Club3D

[Moebius078]

Hi guys,


I RMA'd my Club 3D 4870 OC because of excessive flickering due to unneeded refreshing of the screen. Since the shop (komplett) no longer has that particular version in stock, they offered me two alternatives:

- Gainward GS
http://www.komplett.be/k/ki.aspx?sku=386137
- MSI
http://www.komplett.be/k/ki.aspx?sku=376087

Which one would you suggest? Should I push a little, so they upgrade it to a 4890? Any reasonable arguments i could use?

tnx,
Moebius

 

[montyuk]

could always try for this one - http://www.komplett.be/k/ki.aspx?sku=442787

 

[Moebius078]

Tnx, is it because it has a better cooler? I've read that the gainward cooler is also pretty effective and quiet.