Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > Quadro FX 5800 vs GTX295

Quadro FX 5800 vs GTX295

Forum Graphic & Displays : Graphics Cards - Quadro FX 5800 vs GTX295

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Very interesting as it seems the two are quite similar in power...ie: similar power consumtion, the gtx even has more cores however its very interesting how the gtx295 costs a whopping 500-600bucks while the quadro fx 5800 cost an unbelievable 3000 dollars....what is the benefit of the quadro...what makes it worth so f-ing much?

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Quadro and Geforce use different architecture.

Geforce is for gaming, Quadro is for video/graphics editing and designing.

Quadros suck at gaming, and Geforce suck at graphics editing.

------------------------------ i7 920, E5300
GTX260, HD4870, HD4830
Reply to BlueScreenDeath


They accelerate the CAD (computer-adied design) and DCC (dgitall contect creation). Well these cards are usually used in workstations.

allthough they share the same core with Geforce, Geforce cards are nowhere near in terms of cad performance.




When you play game, performance (FPS) is really important so system can shut down shading textures rendeting shading, after only approximating a final output just in order to keep the Framerates at playable level.

And Cad cards complete all rendering operations even if that causes timings and delays.

Reply to Christopher11

Yup. My laptop have a QUADRO card. and its crap for gaming !

------------------------------ __________________________Le Québécois_________________________
WCed Q9550 EO + P5Q @ 3.825ghz / HTPC - E5200 + P5Q @ 3.3ghz
BFG GTX285 OC2 + PC P&C 750w . / HIS HD4850 with Sharp 42" 1080p
Reply to boulard83
- 0 +

BlueScreenDeath is correct, they are different architechure people usually have these cards in high ecnd workstations that do CAD designing.

Reply to AKM880
- 0 +

+1 for BSOD...
You cannot and should not compare GTX 295 and Quadro...
They both are entirely for different market...

Reply to gkay09

blackhawk1928 wrote :

Very interesting as it seems the two are quite similar in power...ie: similar power consumtion, the gtx even has more cores however its very interesting how the gtx295 costs a whopping 500-600bucks while the quadro fx 5800 cost an unbelievable 3000 dollars....what is the benefit of the quadro...what makes it worth so f-ing much?




Yep, the same is only skin deep here. Under the hood they are highly optimized for entirely different types of software.
Although a higher end workstation card can run games perfectly fine (notice I said higher-end) why would a gamer pay upwards of 3-5g's just to play a game that a much less expensive gaming card can do. Low-end cheaper workstation cards do a pretty bad job running games.

On the other hand though, no gaming card, no matter what the price, can touch a quadro running the applications it was designed to run.

Reply to jitpublisher

the difference is to do with drivers, hence why some people buy 8800GT's and softmod them into FX 4600's.

also I think the 5800 is the workstation version of the GTX 285 not the 295.

Reply to Helloworld_98

thanks...i get the difference now cause I used to think that the gtx295 was the king of kings in quality and price but turns out I was wrong. LOL so i guess they have completely different purposes.

Reply to blackhawk1928

Here is an example: A Gamer or a 3-D Graphics Programmer (Game Programmer) working on games would use a GeForce GTX 295 to build and test a game in real-time play. A Mechanical Engineer or a 3-D Graphic artist (Game Artist) working on computer animation for a game would use Quadro FX 5800 to build large 3-D worlds, complex 3-D game model assets, animation, simulated physics, video editing. Rendering animation can go beyond what the card is capable even, so it's then sent to a render-farm to render the film and 3-D models are sent to the Game Programmer to be used as game assets. Basically, if you need to crunch numbers, use a Quadro. If you need to see results in real-time play, use a GeForce. More or less. It's not about the price when choosing between these two cards. The question is - which role do you play? Answer that question and select your card from there. These cards are Kings in fulfilling one of the roles you play in.


Message edited by Anonymous on 09-04-2009 at 11:00:25 PM
Reply to Anonymous
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > Quadro FX 5800 vs GTX295
Go to:

There are 678 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them