Both are $149..... One is HD and one is not. The HD has a wider screen. Are the HD monitors good? Would I even notice a difference between the two?
The best advice I can give you is to go to a store and look at the difference yourself. Seriously. Everyone else can give you their opinions but until you see it for yourself, you'll never know for sure.
I just went to a store a few days ago and I plan to buy a 23" 1920X1080 monitor, I felt the icons on the 21.5" 1920X1080 were a little too small. I also preferred the wideness over the 22" 1680X1050.
If its watching hi-def movies then the 1920 x 1080 [ 1080p ] panel makes sense .
If you are gaming then that might not be the case . There are a lot of extra pixels on that panel 1920 x1080 =2 073 600 vs 1680 x 1050=1 765 000
Thats nearly 18% more pixels so your frame rates in games will probably drop by a similar amount . Can your gfx card cope? or are you ok with turning gfx quality down?
Message edited by Outlander_04 on 06-10-2009 at 08:04:15 AM