Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question
Solved

Questions about TRIM/GC with SSD dual-booting XP and 7

Last response: in Storage
Share
February 23, 2011 6:02:45 AM

I am looking to build a new system. It's been several years. I want to dual boot XP and 7, since there are still a lot of old apps and games that I just haven't been able to get running properly on 7. But I also want to use an SSD. I know that in Win 7 an SSD is no problem since there is trim support. But I am concerned that using 7 and then rebooting into XP will cause issues since 7 will issue trim commands but XP wont, causing the SSD (possibly a C300) to use its built-in garbage collection function. I don't know much about trim and garbage collection, so I am concerned that a dual boot configuration like this could end up causing some long term degradation to the SSD.

I am also looking at an Intel SSD since they provide their toolbox app for XP. I could also just get an old fashioned HDD, but I use an SSD at work and it has spoiled me.

Best solution

a b G Storage
February 23, 2011 9:35:33 AM

You are correct in that TRIM won't work on XP. This means that any deleted data won't actually be cleared from the drive. Garbage collection will help to alleviate the problem if given time, but unfortunately the C300 is very poor at this and takes too long to show any notable improvement. It's best used with TRIM. If you can't use TRIM for whatever reason, you should look at a drive with the Sandforce controller or an Intel drive as they have more aggressive GC. The Sandforce (not sure about the Intel) is also more resilient in the first place, and performance doesn't degrade as quickly as with the C300 when TRIM isn't available.

There is nothing inherently wrong with GC kicking in. There are some situations where TRIM alone will not improve performance but GC can. It's just a slower process, and does marginally increase the total amount of writes to the drive as data is shifted around.
Share
a c 115 G Storage
February 23, 2011 2:28:18 PM

Here's something you might not have considered. Put Win 7 on the SSD. Then unplug it and install XP on a HD. USe the BIOS Boot Priority to control what OS boots.
m
0
l
March 2, 2011 5:35:24 AM

Best answer selected by retrogamer.
m
0
l
!