You can justify both those decisions with those reasons, although I would still chose the Mugen or S1283V over the Zalman, they will perform better in terms of temperatures. If quietness is important to you though then the Zalman should do well.
------------------------------Asus P6T & i7 920 @ 3.6ghz
GTX 260 Core 216
6gb 1443MHZ 7-7-7-18 1T OCZ Platinum
CM RC-690, CM V8 HSF
Reply to xthekidx
I was originally looking at the 4850 x2, but countless reviews comparing the fans to a swarm of west nile killer bees mercilessly hunting you down dissuaded me.
I'll look into the cooler. Another question I have pertains to the case. I guess his desk is relatively small, which is why we targeted mid-tower. Is the 902 the one to look at, or do the Tempest and CM-690 hold sway over it?
------------------------------Wizard to group: "Look, I've got access to chloroform, any one of these might have been true."
Reply to techwizard08
Is this going on top of his desk? If so, then i would go for a mini tower instead of a full or mid tower, and probably use the DFI LP JR or Asus Rampage II Gene for MB. The CM 690 is big.
Message edited by xthekidx on 06-29-2009 at 10:27:03 PM
------------------------------Asus P6T & i7 920 @ 3.6ghz
GTX 260 Core 216
6gb 1443MHZ 7-7-7-18 1T OCZ Platinum
CM RC-690, CM V8 HSF
Reply to xthekidx