Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Nvidia > Video Editing: GeForce or Quadro?

Video Editing: GeForce or Quadro?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Nvidia - Video Editing: GeForce or Quadro?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

I'm in the process of building a new computer for purely video editing, as my old one can't keep up with the 1080p .mts files.

Old computer has 8600 GTS and a dual-core processor.
Laptop has GeForce GT 120M 1GB with a Dual-core 8600.

They both can't run the videos well. I'm definately upgrading to an i7 processor, to be decided later.

I've checked around online and can't find much, so I'm wondering if a GeForce 295 GTX would be best, or a Quadro equivalent?


Also, since I'm on the topic, would running two 295's in SLi be better than one? For video editing only.

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

You won't need a 295 for video editing.

What software are you using? Most applications are more geared toward CPU power over GPU power. You need to check if your editing application supports GPGPU. You will need an okay GPU to playback HD video, but nothing close to a 295.

You're probably better off upgrading your CPU to a quad-core than replacing your GPU.

Reply to frozenlead
- 0 +

well, in the case of video editing, Quadro is better, it will help take load off the CPU and put it on the GPU through CUDA compatible apps, like adobe premier, and it even helps in photoshop cs3 and i suppose cs4, over all, the quadro will give u better rendering times, it will be faster, but when it comes to playback, the gtx 295 would be better, but u dont need a gtx 295 in sli unless ur gamming, if u still wan tto use ur rig to game and edit, then go for the gtx 295, but if u want it for only video editing, then go for the quadro, that or if u wanted to go with ATI u coudl get the FirePro, its like the ATI version of a quadro, though i take it the quadro might be a bit better, it will cost more

Reply to win7man

Sorry, I had a giant post typed up before that got deleted and thought I wrote the software again.

I'm using Pinnacle 12.

I will not be using it for gaming, and I do want an Nvidia card.

It's not a choice between upgrading CPU or GPU. I'm building an entirely new system, so this is more which GPU I need to go along with it.

Reply to Sturmdolch
- 0 +

well, if thats the case, well, im not sure if Pinnacle supports CUDA rendering, and so if thats the case, then u don't need a quadro, and u sure don't need a gtx 295, i would say that a 9800 gt would work out just fine because it would be the CPU rendering it, so u would want as good as a CPU as u can get, were if u intend on doing cuda were a program runs on the GPU slightly, then u would want a better GPU, and that's were Quadro is good, but only for rendering videos faster realy, cuz a 295 is also good with CUDA, just not as good, but if u intend on goign for programs in the future that suport the quadro, then get it, if not save the money and get a decent GPU, but u don't need a real high end out, the 9800 GT would be just fine. that and lots of ram, fast ram, DDR3, cuz ram is a good thing for video editing, though if its using the quadro for the rendering, u might not need as much ram, but can't say for sure

Reply to win7man

Thank you! I'll take this advice and think it over.

Reply to Sturmdolch
- 0 +

Pinnacle does support gpu acceleration. Either a quadro or fire card would be the best choice.

As already stated the 295 and sli are not viable choices for your use. Unless you wanna drop 1600 on a pair of quadro's

------------------------------ E8400 : GA-EP35-DS3L : mushkin 4GB DDR2 800 : HD 2600PRO : 450W ATX12V : Windows 7
Reply to 505090

I would go for a quadro rather then a geforce for what you need although there a pros and cons to both :) thats just my opinion.

Reply to blackhawk1928
- 0 +

ok, so seeing how Pinnacle apparently supports GPU acceleration, then i would say go ahead for the quadro, though u may need to enable something somewere in Pinnacle

Reply to win7man
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Nvidia > Video Editing: GeForce or Quadro?
Go to:

There are 1074 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them