Sign in with
Sign up | Sign in
Your question

Why doesnt Microsoft put its OS's on a chip?

Last response: in Components
November 4, 2009 4:42:42 PM

Why doesnt Microsoft put its OS's on a chip?
I mean it would be really hard to pirate a physical chip and on a chip the OS could be faster that a HDD because it would have the whole chip to its self and it would be integrated better with the hardware (or at lest the motherboard)

Best solution

November 4, 2009 5:03:24 PM

There are a few issues with this:

1. Which slot on the motherboard would it go into?

2. It would cost them a lot more to produce.

3. If the chip is only as fast as say a standard hard drive then it would not be suitable for those that need faster (who currently use RAID).

4. Would possible need to produce a different version for laptops as they don't generally have the same slots available.

5. Would have to be a writable chip (i.e. flash) so it can be patched and configured to ones needs. This however would make it easier to duplicate (pirate) the chips.

6. The chips would have to come with a warranty, and I and others wouldn't accept a warranty that expires before the next version is release, at least.

7. It wouldn't really integrate itself better with the hardware, and you'd probably just be more limited in your choice of motherboard.

8. The page file would probably not go on the chip, for performance and cost reasons, so you'd still need a HHD even if you have no other programs to install.

9. If the registry is on the chip then, since that has to be writable, what do you do if it gets corrupt or a virus.

It might be viable to put parts of it on a chip, or even having it so the license key is embedded onto some sort of chip but at this moment in time I don't think that idea would really work, but who know what the future will bring.
November 4, 2009 5:08:18 PM

makes sense thanks for the info
November 4, 2009 8:51:10 PM

Though in the old days many home computers had the "OS" stored on ROM, so by doing so for a pc would be feasable.

However.... how much space would you limit the OS to ? and presumably any upgrade would still require you to buy some form or removable media. No to mention the headaches of flashing the ROM.

Not sure how MS would do updates either.