Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > [Solved] 2 4870's 1gb or 3 4850's or 3 gts 250's?

[Solved] 2 4870's 1gb or 3 4850's or 3 gts 250's?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Graphics Cards - [Solved] 2 4870's 1gb or 3 4850's or 3 gts 250's?

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!

Related content

See all topics related to "4870 4850"

Ask the community Add a reply

Best answer from FallenSniper.

Bottom Search this thread

i got 300 bucks to burn on graphics so i was wondering what was the best i could get? oh and my current build is phenom II 940 @ 3.6ghz 4gb of ram @ 1066 and a DFI LP DK 790FXB-M2RSH AM2+/AM2 so any suggestions? plus i dont care where i but it from i'm open to pretty much anything but i would prefer newegg.

Message quoted 1 times

Add a reply

I would recommend this one if you really want to spend all $300.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] -_-Product

I don't really like the idea of buying two cards at the same time for SLI/Crossfire. If you spend some money now to get a very good single card, then you can spend even less later to get another one for SLI/Crossfire. Here's how I think about it:

Buy a single card that puts you in the top 10% as opposed to buying two cards that put you in the top 5%. When your cards get older, buy another of your original card to keep you in the top 10%, as opposed to those two cards you could've bought together before that are now down to the top 20%. Sure you could upgrade those but now your paying even more again.

Either way you should wait for the 5 series to lower some prices and then make your decision.

Here is my ranking of them. I'd say the GTS250 and 4850s in triples will give you slightly more performance, but it's more of a hassle, has worse scaling, and requires a bigger power supply.

So overall, I'd say they are about equal.

1x 9800GTX/GTX+/GTX250 or 4850 = 1
2x 9800GTX/GTX+/GTX250 SLi or 4850 Xfire = 1.8
3x 9800GTX/GTX+/GTX250 Tri-SLi or 4850 Tri-Xfire = 2.4

1x 4870 1GB Xfire or GTX260 216 = 1.3
2x 4870 1GB Xfire or GTX260 216 SLi = 2.34

If you already have a GTS250/4850, get tri-fire. If you're starting from scratch, get 2x 4870s or 2x GTX260s.

Message edited by Bluescreendeath on 09-14-2009 at 12:23:37 AM

Reply to Bluescreendeath

Best answer

Reply to FallenSniper

sweet thanks because im the type of person that likes to maximize their budget and i got a pretty beefy power supply (corsair 850 watts) two 4870's 1gb would be 280 and 3 4850 512 would be 255-300. but i would prefer an intense array of graphics but thats just me.

Reply to tacoslave

hmm the 285 not as powerful as the 2 4870's yet more expensive but you do have a point about the 5 series and i still got a trusty 3870 to hold me off till then so i guess ill wait and get a monstrous 5870.

Reply to tacoslave

Quote :

hmm the 285 not as powerful as the 2 4870's yet more expensive

My point was that a single 285 is not as powerful but 2 285s is more powerful.

Reply to FallenSniper

If you could wait and see what ati next gen of cards offer. The 5850 is rumored to be as strong as a gtx285 with a 299$ price tag.

Reply to invisik

There is no point in even considering having more than one Nvidia card on that CROSSFIRE board.

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1]

http://img29.imageshack.us/img29/5041/vr2009champ.jpg

Reply to mousemonkey

I expected you to say there's no point in having more than one 285! Buying a card right before the 5 series would be just plain silly... And also something I would do

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by FallenSniper on 09-14-2009 at 03:45:13 AM

Reply to FallenSniper

FallenSniper wrote :

I expected you today there's no point in having more than one 285! Buying a card right before the 5 series would be just plain silly... And also something I would do

Put down the credit card and step away from the keyboard. :lol:

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1]

Reply to mousemonkey

too late

Reply to FallenSniper

Oh no, what have you gone and bought this time? not another 3xxx Ati card surely?

Message quoted 1 times

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1]

Reply to mousemonkey

So yes, that is a Crossfire only board so not point in even talking about SLI.

Also just wait for the 5 series. If you are planning on spending enough money to get tir-fire you can get a 5870 which beats a 4870x2.

Message quoted 1 times

Reply to darkvine

tacoslave wrote :

And your monitor is what res?

------------------------------ Badges? We don' need no stinkin' badges...!
Reply to croc

darkvine wrote :

Last time I checked there weren't any benchmarks out for the ATI 5XXX series.

Message quoted 1 times

Reply to g3force

mousemonkey wrote :

Oh no, what have you gone and bought this time? not another 3xxx Ati card surely?

Oh of course not... I have a Core 2 Extreme now though... lol -_-;

Reply to FallenSniper

Well that's not so bad, I hope it wasn't at an 'extreme' price though.

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1]

Reply to mousemonkey

Indeed it's not so bad. And at least it's not a downgrade like last time. QX6700 for $150.

Reply to FallenSniper

g3force wrote :

Last time I checked there weren't any benchmarks out for the ATI 5XXX series.

There is one from ATi themselves that shows it getting higher frames in Crysis with 4xAA then a 4780x2. How real is that since it is from ATI? Who knows but if it is at all possible why not wait off when you are clearing willing to drop some cash on a CF/SLI set up.

Message quoted 1 times

Reply to darkvine

darkvine wrote :

Ati are really going to say that their new card is slower than anything in their last series, what manufacture would ever say that?

------------------------------ [:mousemonkey:1]

Reply to mousemonkey

That is why I said "how real is it". While I am sure it isn't going to be quiet that could if it is even close to being that powerful it is worth the wait a few weeks.

Why blow 300+ on a tir-fire set up when a single card might do the job in less then a month, plus DX11, plus latest card.

I am fairly sure a tir-fire would beat it even if it is as fast as ATI claims but with all of this other perks there is no reason to blow that much money on something at the moment until you see some numbers on the 5000 series.

Reply to darkvine

Theres no debate, it would be unwise to buy anything other than a 5000 series card. I'm sure that 2 5870s, or even 5850s would destroy and tri-fire system that you could put together currently.

Message edited by bige420 on 09-14-2009 at 07:19:03 AM

Reply to bige420

Wish. Saying it would be unwise to buy anything other than a 5 series is wrong... What if you want a midrange card?

Reply to FallenSniper

well what i meant to say was this 5 series = win and as for me buying anything from nvidia = no. i guess i should wait besides i might end up buying a 5870 then upgrading later.

Message quoted 1 times

Reply to tacoslave

tacoslave wrote :

well what i meant to say was this 5 series = win and as for me buying anything from nvidia = no. i guess i should wait besides i might end up buying a 5870 then upgrading later.

OK, you ducked my first question, so I'll ask again: What resolution is your monitor? Now I'll add a second question: What PSU do you have? And now for a third question: How many LED's, and other assorted winky-blinky 'accessories' are in your case?

------------------------------ Badges? We don' need no stinkin' badges...!
Reply to croc

I'm talking about if you have the money available then you should go 5000 series. If you dont have the money to spend then by all means go 4000 series or whichever, but this guy seems like he has the cash to spend. Im not 12 years old btw....

Reply to bige420

Ask the community Add a reply

Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > [Solved] 2 4870's 1gb or 3 4850's or 3 gts 250's?

Go to:

Help |
Forum rules

There are 1249 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Related content

See all topics related to "4870 4850"

Page generated in 0.375 seconds

Focus On

[Solved] 2 4870's 1gb or 3 4850's or 3 gts 250's?

Forum Graphic & Displays : Graphics Cards - [Solved] 2 4870's 1gb or 3 4850's or 3 gts 250's?