Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > [Solved] Upgrade from 8800gt

Best answer from pepperman.

Word :    Username :           
 

I have a nvidia gefore 8800gt and i have no clue which card to get. I have been looking around and I cant really decide which card is better. Im looking for a card thats around 150-200 bucks and that can run smoothly. someone please help thank you :D

The 4870's are roughly equal to the GTX 260 216 sp's. http://www.tomshardware.com/charts [...] .html?prod[2480]=on&prod[2463]=on&prod[2464]=on

If you want a single card, you would get more for your money with a 4870, but if you want a multi-gpu, (you will need to upgrade your psu) you should go with the GTX 260 (make sure its a 216 shader model).

HD 4870- link posted above^

GTX 260 (216 shader)- $175
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127430

PSU- $110
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817139006
Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

try 9600gt, it's cheap at the moment.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by cheesesubs on 10-18-2009 at 06:55:43 AM
Reply to cheesesubs

Providing the rest of your system isn't ancient, $150-200 can buy you a 5770 or 4890 ATI side or a GTX 260 nVidia side. Any of those would be a huge upgrade from an 8800GT.

------------------------------ Coolermaster HAF 932 | Asus P6T Deluxe V2
i7 920 @ 3.4GHz | Thermalright Ultra-120
OCZ Platinum 6GB 1600 | EVGA GTX 275 FTW
X-Fi XtremeGamer | Corsair 850TX
Reply to kohd

I have a q6600 2.40 GHz CPU with a P5N-E SLI motherboard

Reply to polishtom

polishtom wrote :

I have a q6600 2.40 GHz CPU with a P5N-E SLI motherboard




oh i945 chipset.......it is highly chance your mobo only support pcie 1.0 ....so either any card at the moment able to work on your system....(4890/gtx260 require pcie 2.0 to function better performance, geforce 9 will still require pcie 1.1 or above)

other word...get a new rig......


Message edited by cheesesubs on 10-18-2009 at 07:12:29 AM
Reply to cheesesubs

All current PCI-E 1.1 to 2.0 are backwards compatible with PCI-E 1.0 so you can pick any of those cards. I think the best bang for your buck right now would be the HD 4870.

$145 XFX HD4870
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814150436

Reply to pepperman

Let's see.

These are the video cards that are generally considered to be faster than a 8800GT.

Radeon 4850
Radeon 4870
Radeon 4770
Radeon 4850x2
Radeon 4870x2
Radeon 5850
Radeon 5870
GeForce 9800GTX+
GeForce GTS 250
GeForce GTX260
GeForce GTX275
GeForce GTX280
GeForce GTX295

Reply to stridervm

^ Don't forget the 5770 and 5750

Reply to pepperman

Why don't you just read Tom's best graphics for the money...and look at the hierarchy chart to make sure an upgrade is worth it. 8800gt's still a pretty good card.

Look for the October article soon
http://www.tomshardware.com/review [...] ,2404.html

------------------------------ Q6600 at 3.2ghz,680i sli,
vista 32-bit,
4gb corsair 4-4-4-12 ddr2, 8800gt 512mb w/ zalman vf-900, zalman 9700, theramltake armor, 2-250gb raid 0,

Reply to Raydog

cheesesubs wrote :

try 9600gt, it's cheap at the moment.



Why would he downgrade? O_o

Reply to Bluescreendeath

Bluescreendeath wrote :

Why would he downgrade? O_o



Exactly. 9600gt's a downgrade. Look at hierarchy chart.

------------------------------ Q6600 at 3.2ghz,680i sli,
vista 32-bit,
4gb corsair 4-4-4-12 ddr2, 8800gt 512mb w/ zalman vf-900, zalman 9700, theramltake armor, 2-250gb raid 0,

Reply to Raydog

You can get 5770 for cheap.It performs tad slower than 4870 bu hope to do well after driver upgrade.

Otherwise 4890 is a good card for 200$ (nearly)

Reply to shubham1401

Because cheesesub has no idea what he's talking about. Nothing wrong with PCIe 1, nor is a 9600GT an upgrade from a 8800GT.

One thing to possibly keep in mind is you have a mobo that has more then one PCIe slot. This means you can use your 8800GT as a PhysX card if you want. While AMD provides a better cost/performance ratio, if you have vista you can't use one. Before you do this, make sure the games you play can take advantage of PhysX.

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

You can do sli for about $75 give or take and that q6600 won't fold like a lawn chair unlike my e6400. Some of the advice that I have seen in this thread is pathetic a 945 and a 9600gt what must he be smoking.

Reply to nforce4max

4745454b wrote :

Because cheesesub has no idea what he's talking about. Nothing wrong with PCIe 1, nor is a 9600GT an upgrade from a 8800GT.




9600gt isn't a downgrade of 8800gt. it is downgrade of 8800"GTS" which he doesn't have it..... it has better fabrication(65nm), and same buswidth(256bit) and better performance than 8800gt can offer. and most important is....less power hungry than 8800gt.

and the debate of pcie's backward competibility. i'm not saying pcie 1.0 can't support any newer graphic card. some chipset like g31 and nforce 610i can support pcie 1.0 to 2.0 but some cant. like older nforce 4 and i945. so simply it depands on the chipset. the problem is the "chipset". which he need to get a new system instead of just get a graphic card.

because i know what exactly i'm talking about.......

ps: i945 is the worst chipset in intel history and prescott + i945 is the worst combo ever....

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by cheesesubs on 10-19-2009 at 04:52:04 AM
Reply to cheesesubs

calling a troll on cheese, unless he's talking about only a 256 MB 8800 GT and not the 512.

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by Mierin on 10-19-2009 at 04:52:34 AM
Reply to Mierin

Mierin wrote :

calling a troll on cheese, unless he's talking about only a 256 MB 8800 GT and not the 512.



how'd you prove i am a troll? tell me.

Reply to cheesesubs

By my ignoring you from here on out. You have no clue what your talking about, the 9600GT is slower then the 8800GT. It might be on a newer process, but how many stream processors does it have? (hint: not as many/enough) Good day sir, I pray you stop misleading people.

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

4745454b wrote :

By my ignoring you from here on out. You have no clue what your talking about, the 9600GT is slower then the 8800GT. It might be on a newer process, but how many stream processors does it have? (hint: not as many/enough) Good day sir, I pray you stop misleading people.



well just look up wikipedia, i may be wrong with 8800gt&9600gt, i was mistaken with 9800 gt. anyway.

btw he's mobo still cant run either geforce 9 or above, even pcie 1.1 like geforce 8 were still risky on that chipset. unless he wants to run these card with tons of hardware issue(as it may be fatal.).

so the conclusion is---he needs to change his mobo if he wants to get a newer graphic card because these graphic card require at least g31/35 or above to function probably(p45 would be much better).

Reply to cheesesubs

cheesesubs wrote :

9600gt isn't a downgrade of 8800gt. it is downgrade of 8800"GTS" which he doesn't have it..... it has better fabrication(65nm), and same buswidth(256bit) and better performance than 8800gt can offer. and most important is....less power hungry than 8800gt.

and the debate of pcie's backward competibility. i'm not saying pcie 1.0 can't support any newer graphic card. some chipset like g31 and nforce 610i can support pcie 1.0 to 2.0 but some cant. like older nforce 4 and i945. so simply it depands on the chipset. the problem is the "chipset". which he need to get a new system instead of just get a graphic card.

because i know what exactly i'm talking about.......

ps: i945 is the worst chipset in intel history and prescott + i945 is the worst combo ever....



Just so you know, the P5N-E SLI (the board he has) is based on the Nvidia 650i chipset. It will run any current GPU without any problem at all, so long as the mobo isn't defective.

http://www.asus.com/Product.aspx?P [...] ifications

Reply to pepperman

pepperman wrote :

Just so you know, the P5N-E SLI (the board he has) is based on the Nvidia 650i chipset. It will run any current GPU without any problem at all, so long as the mobo isn't defective.

http://www.asus.com/Product.aspx?P [...] ifications




i guess i mixed up with "ASUS P5LD2". thank you for correcting me.

Reply to cheesesubs

pepperman wrote :

Just so you know, the P5N-E SLI (the board he has) is based on the Nvidia 650i chipset. It will run any current GPU without any problem at all, so long as the mobo isn't defective.

http://www.asus.com/Product.aspx?P [...] ifications


whoa ok so i dont have to get a new motherboard right and if i get the gtx 260 i wont have any problems cause i want to make sure

Reply to polishtom

^ Yup, you'll be fine. Make sure your psu is at least 500 W (preferably at least a total of 36 amps on the 12 V rail). Also make sure you have at least two 6 pin PCI-E connectors on your PSU and/or you buy one that comes with adaptors.

Reply to pepperman

Quote :

whoa ok so i dont have to get a new motherboard right and if i get the gtx 260 i wont have any problems cause i want to make sure



As I've been trying to say, you'll be fine. Don't listen to those who have no clue what they are talking about, PCIe 2 will work in PCIe 1, it will just have half the bandwidth available. This doesn't mean half the speed, it means it wont' be able to talk to the CPU as fast as the bus allows. Seeing as even the fastest cards have trouble filling PCIe 1, this isn't an issue. (similar to harddrives not being able to fill SATA 150MB speeds because they can only sustain 100MBps.)

As Pepperman said, make sure you have the connectors you'd need, and a PSU good enough to run whatever card. Other then that, you'll be fine.

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

ok i have a 600 watt psu that would be enough right? and if i were to get another gtx 260 how would i be able to connect since i have enough adapters to connect one gtx 260

Reply to polishtom

Not all 600W PSUs are the same. It might have enough, but possibly not if you don't have enough plugs. The only way to tell is to look at the PSU casing and see how much power it has on the 12V rail(s).

------------------------------ The voice of REASON
Do NOT feed the TROLLS!
Always a DEMON!
Reply to 4745454b

4745454b wrote :

Not all 600W PSUs are the same. It might have enough, but possibly not if you don't have enough plugs. The only way to tell is to look at the PSU casing and see how much power it has on the 12V rail(s).


how will i determine that? i see a +12V then under it 32A and under that 384 watts and under that combined with the +3.3V and the +5V its 580W

Reply to polishtom

You probably won't be able to SLI then, but it should be fine for a single card.

Reply to pepperman

thats whack was hoping to do SLI and if i were to do it i would have to buy a new PSU correct?

Reply to polishtom


I agree about th 9600gt, it is a downgrade essentially. I work on computers for a living on both PC's, as well as have my Apple cert. There is about a 15-20% performance difference in favor of the 8800gt vs the 9600gt if memory serves. Don't get me wrong, 9600gt is not horrible, I have one myself, but going from the 8800gt to the 9600gt is the equivalent of downgrading. If I remember right, the 8800gt has 112 stream processors vs the 64 of the 9600gt which makes up a lot of the difference.

 

For the PCI 1.0 vs 2.0, 2.0 might help, but I am not sure many cards actually can saturate the full bandwidth offered by 1.0-1.1. At least I believe that was the case a few months ago, but who knows with the new 5870 series. That being the case, my next upgrade for graphics will likely be a 5750 or 5770. However, the op may be able to find a cheap 4850 floating around somewhere, but at this point, I think I'd go ahead and jump to the DX 11 cards, but that is a personal preference.


Message edited by ohiou_grad_06 on 10-20-2009 at 04:01:52 AM
Reply to ohiou_grad_06

I completely agree with Ohiou, however about the 5750 and 5770 I'd suggest going with the 4870s or 4890s there much cheaper than the 260s at least the 4870s are. Newegg has the lowest 4870 at 124.98. The 4870s outpreform the 260s by far and match up with the 280s on some games. http://www.tomshardware.com/review [...] 64-10.html shows that. And the 4870 offers the DX 10.1 support which should be set for a while. D11 has few to no games currently but yeah. 4870 is the better buy. Rather than the 260 since its in like the same price range on Newegg.

Reply to aznshinobi

aznshinobi wrote :

I completely agree with Ohiou, however about the 5750 and 5770 I'd suggest going with the 4870s or 4890s there much cheaper than the 260s at least the 4870s are. Newegg has the lowest 4870 at 124.98. The 4870s outpreform the 260s by far and match up with the 280s on some games. http://www.tomshardware.com/review [...] 64-10.html shows that. And the 4870 offers the DX 10.1 support which should be set for a while. D11 has few to no games currently but yeah. 4870 is the better buy. Rather than the 260 since its in like the same price range on Newegg.


so the 4870 out preforms the gtx 260 superclocked or not? and can you give me a link please been lookin around for the 4870 but only found it at 150

Reply to polishtom
Best answer

The 4870's are roughly equal to the GTX 260 216 sp's. http://www.tomshardware.com/charts [...] .html?prod[2480]=on&prod[2463]=on&prod[2464]=on

If you want a single card, you would get more for your money with a 4870, but if you want a multi-gpu, (you will need to upgrade your psu) you should go with the GTX 260 (make sure its a 216 shader model).

HD 4870- link posted above^

GTX 260 (216 shader)- $175
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814127430

PSU- $110
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6817139006

Reply to pepperman

but why is the evga version of the 260 more then then the msi and the same with the 4870 why is the visiontek more then asus wheres the difference?

Reply to polishtom

polishtom wrote :

so the 4870 out preforms the gtx 260 superclocked or not? and can you give me a link please been lookin around for the 4870 but only found it at 150



If you want a 4870, you should go with the one I posted (at least if you're going off of newegg). Since the price difference is so small, you should stick with a 1GB version over the 512 MB version.

The 4870 I posted before was $145. Here's the link again.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814150436

Reply to pepperman

polishtom wrote :

but why is the evga version of the 260 more then then the msi and the same with the 4870 why is the visiontek more then asus wheres the difference?



The difference is the brand. Some brands carry a better warranty, like XFX, EVGA, and BFG whose cards carry a lifetime warrany. Others don't have such warranties. Personally, I prefer XFX and EVGA.

Reply to pepperman

Oh, the EVGA is more expensive, also, because of brands, since more people just prefer EVGA since its the standard Nvidia brand, I THINK! Since its like how Sapphire and EVGA are exclusive to its GPU

Reply to aznshinobi

pepperman wrote :

If you want a 4870, you should go with the one I posted (at least if you're going off of newegg). Since the price difference is so small, you should stick with a 1GB version over the 512 MB version.

The 4870 I posted before was $145. Here's the link again.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814150436


whats the difference between the memory of the gtx 260 which has 2106MHz and the 4870 has 900 MHz is it the speed?
and thanks for the link

Reply to polishtom

The 2106 MHz of the GTX 260 is GDDR3 with a 448 bit interface while the 3600 MHz (900 x 4) of the 4870 is GDDR5 with a 256 bit interface. The bandwidth is very similar, I could calculate it but I'm too lazy right now, but you really can't compare the two cards that way; they're built on different architectures, so you can only look at theoretical performance differences. You're better off looking at the charts (either the ones I posted, or you can go there yourself).

Reply to pepperman

118 GB/s for the GTX 260
115.2 GB/s for the 4870

As I said, they're very close to each other

Reply to pepperman

ok so if i were to go with gtx 260 SLI i will have better preformance then the 4870

Reply to polishtom

and that 4870 has a horrible cooler!

Reply to polishtom

With SLI, yes, but just as the single card config, a pair of 4870's will perform similarly. I agree, that is a terrible cooler; to be honest, I wasn't operating at full capacity when I linked that. Unfortunately, the next best one I would recommend (based on warranty) is the ASUS Dark Knight, which costs $160.

Since you seem to want to have a multi-gpu setup, it really boils down to your mobo. The only way you can do it (without upgrading your mobo) is SLI. If you have the money now and/or you want to add another gpu later, you should go with the GTX 260. If all you want is a single GPU setup, you could get either, depending on how much you want to pay.

Dark Knight
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6814121291

Reply to pepperman

Yea I think I am going to go with the gtx 260 buy one then wait a few and buy a new psu and another gtx 260. Dont really want to get a new motherboard just for the corssfire. Thanks for all the help pepperman really appreciate it and to the rest of you guys.

Reply to polishtom
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Graphic & Displays > Graphics Cards > [Solved] Upgrade from 8800gt
Go to:

There are 466 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
  • 01:00 -pcaddict- won the Freshman badge
  • 01:00 impreza won the Freshman badge
  • 01:00 raulkm won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 letus won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 pmiddy won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 MarcieMark won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 kaypeezee won the Uniformed badge
  • 04:06 xyz001 won the Sophmore badge
  • 01:00 scione won the Freshman badge
  • 01:32 aford10 won the Home Brew badge