Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Motherboards & Memory > Memory > [Solved] 9GB in an i7-920 desktop messed up?

[Solved] 9GB in an i7-920 desktop messed up?

Forum Motherboards & Memory : Memory [Solved] 9GB in an i7-920 desktop messed up?

Best answer from 505090.

Word :    Username :           
 

HP ELITE E9180T desktop i7-920 Refurbished

http://cgi.ebay.com/HP-ELITE-E9180 [...] 5ad8824ed7

Given this *should be* a 1366-socket motherboard, it should be operating on triple channel for optimal performance, correct?

But it appears the 9GB of memory is configured as 4x 2GB plus 1x 1GB ?!??

How does this sit in the slots? I'm assuming a 3-set then 2 slots. So did HP mess up, thus explaining why there so many of these being refurbished?

If I take out the extra 2GB and 1GB stick, thus ending up with just an original 6GB (3x 2GB), would performance be back to "normal"?

Would I be able to just buy & add 6 more GB later on my own?

Thanks

Reply to zepprx
Register or log in to remove.
Best answer

it should but won't set up like that

it appears they are using 5 slots

yes 3*2gig sticks will put you back in tri-channel (use the same color slots) and would be my recommendation

yes you could add another 3*2gig sticks later, though you will have to match the ram (not a big deal just have to look before you buy). that said few people can utilize more than 6 gigs of ram

------------------------------ www.canyounamethesepeople.com
Reply to 505090

Can I assume that the existing RAM (especially the 3x 2GB I would keep) is all from the same batch and/or brand, though?

With refurbished computers, you never know if they just threw a bunch of spare sticks in there... Could this actually be running in single-channel mode, or is that far-fetched?

If I add another 6GB myself later, you said to "match" the RAM... do you mean to the existing RAM, on the BRAND (not just type)? How will I know what the existing brand is; is all RAM labeled?

THANKS!


Message edited by zepprx on 04-08-2010 at 10:20:38 PM
Reply to zepprx

i would assume so, but it is obviously not a guarantee

yes it is currently running in single channel mode

you need to match speed, type, cas, and voltage; as an added bonus sometimes you can match brand and model but it's not necessary

brand and model will be on the ram, the other specs can be found by running a free program cpuid

------------------------------ www.canyounamethesepeople.com
Reply to 505090

505090 wrote :



you need to match speed, type, cas, and voltage

brand and model will be on the ram, the other specs can be found by running a free program cpuid



speed, type, cas, and voltage are pretty standard and easy to match... Pretty much just DDR3 10600 (or whatever), correct?

The cpuid program... is that on the computer already (like a bios or "run" command), or something I need to buy/download from a web site?

Thanks

Reply to zepprx

You'll need to download that utility. http://www.cpuid.com

Speed and type are easy to match. CAS latency sometimes. Voltage is more difficult because sticks will sometimes vary from that manufacturer's specs. Matching "high performance" sticks seems to be harder, since some manufacturers seem to enjoy packaging the same value line product rated for a higher CAS/voltage.

Good luck!

Reply to Thadius856

ddr3 1600 would be the type and speed then comes the cas and voltage it's not hard newegg will narrow it down real quick with the power search option

cpuid is free just follow the link thaduis posted

------------------------------ www.canyounamethesepeople.com
Reply to 505090

Thanks everyone... very helpful. So I should remove at least some of the mis-configured 9GB of memory. Which would be better performing:

(a) Remove 3GB => then run the remaining 6GB in triple channel
or
(b) Remove 1GB => then run the remaining 8GB in dual channel (how much worse is this vs triple?)

Even in dual channel mode, would there still be advantages to buying an 1366 socket Mobo, versus an 1156 Mobo? Although the i7-920 and i7-860 CPUs seem to be similar in their specs.


Message edited by zepprx on 04-09-2010 at 07:38:53 AM
Reply to zepprx

I actually have that exact system, and found your post trying to find info on the best way to optimize that oddball RAM configuration. You should be aware, though, that the e9180t and e9150t systems have been plagued with problems, which seem to be linked to a bad mobo. Problems as in >4000 posts on the HP board, multiple class action lawsuits, etc. I actually wound up replacing the mobo, case, and PSU at my own expense just to get it to work for me. The problem has supposedly been corrected with the version 1.40e REV E01 board, so you'll want to confirm that it has the "good" board before pulling the trigger.

Apologies for the sidebar comments. I don't mean to derail the post - I actually have the same question as the OP - would it be best to pull 3GB and run 6GB in triple channel, or pull 1GB and run 8GB in dual?

I should also add that with the 4x2, 1x1 configuration, CPU-z says it's actually running in triple channel mode. What gives? http://i343.photobucket.com/albums/o472/EricMDyer/CPUID.jpg


Message edited by EMDyer on 04-09-2010 at 09:13:26 PM
Reply to EMDyer

Thanks for the heads up. Did you buy it new or refurbished?

This ebay seller doesn't have a phone #. They emailed me an answer on the memory (said it WAS all identical) but ignored my question about what the motherboard brand/model was.

I thought "refurbished" meant taking care of problems so that the PC tests okay. Is there a forum thread of what "refurbished" really means? Or I can start one.

Thanks

Reply to zepprx

Thinking it probably depends on when they refurbished it - the motherboard issue has gone on for a long time, and I'm sure they were sending them back out before the final board. It's been a real PITA, so if you can't confirm it, I'd probably look elsewhere!

Still trying to understand why that memory config is showing as triple for me in CPU-Z?

Reply to EMDyer

i would run 3 * 2gig sitcks in triple channel

not sure why cpuid would show that as tripple channel but I assure you it isn't with 5 sticks , is it possable you are running 3 * 3gig sticks

------------------------------ www.canyounamethesepeople.com
Reply to 505090

It's definitely 5 DIMMS on an EVGA X58 SLI, 4x2GB, 1x1GB. Thought maybe the bios did something weird to run a sort of quasi triple channel mode. Probably just something quirky with cpuid.

Reply to EMDyer

some kind of qerk then its not possible to run tri channel with five sticks, kinda self explanatory you need sets of three to run tri channel

------------------------------ www.canyounamethesepeople.com
Reply to 505090

Thanks everyone for the info.

After seeing the issues with the Elite 9820T pegatron mobo, I'm not convinced it would be corrected even on the refurbs, as I would suspect HP simply adjusted the Bios, rather than replaced the mobo. Heck, they didn't even adjust the wrongly configured RAM!

The M9600T is a later version, also Elite. There seems to be lots of complaints about it also, but I wonder if the problem got fixed?

http://h30434.www3.hp.com/t5/forum [...] e?q=m9600T


Message edited by zepprx on 04-11-2010 at 08:44:31 AM
Reply to zepprx

Don't some mobos support some sort of tri-channel "flex mode," running some DIMMS in tri channel, others in dual?

Reply to EMDyer

EMDyer wrote :

Don't some mobos support some sort of tri-channel "flex mode," running some DIMMS in tri channel, others in dual?



no that would require a 5 channel mem controller

older motherboards had the memory controller built into the north bridge, i7 actually has the mem controller on the cpu which is one of the largest reason's the i7 performs so well

------------------------------ www.canyounamethesepeople.com
Reply to 505090
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Motherboards & Memory > Memory > [Solved] 9GB in an i7-920 desktop messed up?
Go to:

There are 1857 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
Difference between 2133 (O.C.) and 2133 for DDR3 RAM.
By stickg1, 10 hours ago:

Nice CPU, you can use 2133 RAM, you will have to manually set it to that speed in the...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them