Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New System Build > First Time Prospective Core I7 Builder vs Dell XPS 9000 Core I7

First Time Prospective Core I7 Builder vs Dell XPS 9000 Core I7

Forum Homebuilt Systems : New System Build - First Time Prospective Core I7 Builder vs Dell XPS 9000 Core I7

Tom's Hardware: Over 1.4 million members in 6 different countries available to answer all your high-tech questions. Sign up now! Its free!
Word :    Username :           
 

Hello all:

Long time lurker whose never built a system. I personally will pay a bit of a premium for a better performing chip set (like Intel Core I7) that may last a number of years. After all, I've stretched the life of a Dell Optiplex G240 until it won't play any game made today.

I've spent the time to compare components and pricing of a DELL XPS 9000 Core I7 920 system against similar components sourced at NEWEGG and find there's only $100. or so difference in price. I suppose someone with argue at the lower NEWEGG cost, I'm still getting some enhanced components like a 700w certified power supply versus 475w in the Dell system.

But Dell bundles a WIN7 OS and warranty and support into that small difference. AND - the DELL machine comes BUILT out of a box.

I've done loads of repairs, hard drive swaps, fan replacements, cpu swaps, memory upgrades, etc. But I consider that to still be far different than building disparate manufacturer's parts into a working PC.

I'm struggling to find a significant benefit here. I'd appreciate more experience views here.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

APPROXIMATE PURCHASE DATE: as soon as I can figure this all out, preferably within a week or two.

BUDGET RANGE: under $2000, prefer to bring this down if possible without sacrificing too much.

SYSTEM USAGE FROM MOST TO LEAST IMPORTANT: Business use, Some gaming, INternet browsing, Web development with Dreamweaver and Photoshop.
Would like to be able for kids to do video and audio editing esp. for scholarship applications now requiring movies - Never had a home machine powerful enough.


PARTS NOT REQUIRED: monitor - or maybe a 2nd monitor if these cards support two displays - I don't know how to research that point.

PREFERRED WEBSITE(S) FOR PARTS: anywhere reputable.

PARTS PREFERENCES: None, just good compatibility desired

OVERCLOCKING: probably not; mild OC if anything

MONITOR RESOLUTION: Hmmmm... my PCs were never really powerful enuff to worry about this. I do have a 22" widescreen ACER LCD now but have run it at the limitations of the old video card.

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS:
* I value performance and reliability.
* This would be my first complete home build.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Studio XPS 9000: DELL
Case: XPS 9000
Power supply: 475W
Mobo: Intel Motherboard
Proc: Intel® Core™ i7-920 processor(8MB L3 Cache, 2.66GHz)
OS: Win 7 Home Premium, 64bit
1Yr Ltd Hardware Warranty, InHome Service after Remote Diagnosis
Memory: 6GB Tri-Channel DDR3 SDRAM at 1066MHz - 6 DIMMs
hard drive: 500GB 7200 RPM SATA Hard Drive
Optical Drive: 16x CD/DVD Burner & Roxio 10
Video Card: nVidia GeForce GTX 260 1792MB
Sound Card: Soundblaster® X-Fi™ Xtreme Audio
Speaker: Bose Companion 2 Series II Multimedia Speaker System
Keyboard: Dell USB Consumer Multimedia Keyboard
Mouse: Dell Studio Optical Mouse
Integrated 10/1000 Ethernet

DELL $1,528.00


NewEgg

Case: COOLER MASTER HAF 932 ATX Full Tower 139.99
Powersupply: OCZ ModXStream Pro OCZ700MXSP 700W SLI Certified $99.99 *
Mobo: ASUS P6T Deluxe V2 LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX $289.99
Proc: Intel® Core™ i7-920 processor(8MB L3 Cache, 2.66GHz) $288.99
OS: WIN7 Ultimate UVA Student discount $10
Memory: CORSAIR DOMINATOR 6GB DDR3 SDRAM 1600 Triple Channel $229.99
Hard drive: WD Caviar Black 1TB 7200 RPM 32MB Cache SATA $109.99
Optical Drive: LITE-ON Black 24X D SATA CD/DVD Burner $31.99
Video Card: EVGA 896-P3-1255-AR GeForce GTX 260 Core 216 896MB 448-bit $189.99
Sound Card: Integrated MB - Eight channels of HD sound -ADI AD2000B audio chipset $0
Speakers: Bose Companion 2 Series II Multimedia Speaker System $99
Keyboard: Microsoft Comfort Curve Keyboard 2000 $17.99
Mouse: Logitech LX3 Silver/Black 3 Buttons Tilt Wheel USB or PS/2 Wired Optical Mouse $21.99
Integrated 10/1000 Ethernet

NewEgg $1,529.90
$(55.00) Combo rebate on Proc/Case/MB
$(30.00) Mail-in rebate on Proc/Case/MB

$1,444.90 Total

Sponsored Links
Register or log in to remove.

Build your own is always better. That PSU on the Dell sucks, the ram is the slowest DDR3 Speed, that hard drive is probably a slow one, and overall Dell sucks. Their Ultra Sharp monitors are the only thing they got going for them. AlienWare is overrated. I would also not use anything OCZ, except for maybe their high end SSDs. OCZ sucks. That's just my opinion. Yes, I'm a Dell Hater.

Message quoted 2 times
Message edited by masterasia on 10-31-2009 at 04:22:01 AM
Reply to masterasia

masterasia wrote :

Build your own is always better. That PSU on the Dell sucks, the ram is the slowest DDR3 Speed, that hard drive is probably a slow one, and overall Dell sucks. Their Ultra Sharp monitors are the only thing they got going for them. AlienWare is overrated. I would also not use anything OCZ, except for maybe their high end SSDs. OCZ sucks. That's just my opinion. Yes, I'm a Dell Hater.



ocz has some descent ram. Check them out, unless your going to overclocking your ram, you dont need dominators. You can easily save $100 by going for some g-skill or ocz ram at the same timings and speed, then put the money towards a better graphics card like a 5850.

Reply to impaledmango

Yeah, you can definitely save a couple bucks on RAM by going with the OCZ Platinum tripple channel 1600 MHz DDR3 kit. That would be around $70 savings.

And it's a good kit. Low voltage, relatively tight timings (7-7-7-24). I think there are some out there by Mushkin with 7-6-7-18 timings, but those cost a bit more. And the platinums are decently overclockable as seen in any review of the kit.


A Samsung Spinpoint F3 1 TB would be a faster drive in that size range. It's also cheaper than the Western Digital ($80 versus $110). That saves you about $30

So that takes your total to about 1344.90.

As for the benefits of building yourself: It's a lot of fun, you become more comfortable with the hardware you're using, you get to make sure that all your components are fairly high quality.

You choose your upgrade path, your motherboard features, etc.

------------------------------ i7 920 @ 3.2 GHz w/Cooler Master V8,
OCZ Platinum DDR3 1600 MHz 8-8-8-24, Sapphire Radeon HD 4870X2,
Samsung Spinpoint F3 500 GB, Corsair HX1000 Watt PSU,
Intel DX58SO, Cooler Master Storm Sniper mid-tower, Windows 7 Professional 64 bit
Reply to mortonww

masterasia wrote :

Build your own is always better. That PSU on the Dell sucks, the ram is the slowest DDR3 Speed, that hard drive is probably a slow one, and overall Dell sucks. Their Ultra Sharp monitors are the only thing they got going for them. AlienWare is overrated. I would also not use anything OCZ, except for maybe their high end SSDs. OCZ sucks. That's just my opinion. Yes, I'm a Dell Hater.

 

Sounds like you're a OCZ hater too. Why does OCZ suck? Provide evidence.

 

To OP: Dell does suck, building your own computer is always better because it's cheaper. That intel board on the dell comp sucks against the other x58 mobos. Overall it just sucks, didn't bother listing all the crappy things dell has

Message quoted 1 times
Message edited by overshocks on 10-31-2009 at 06:15:57 AM
------------------------------ You can select me as Best Answer
e6400 oc'd 3.2ghz,CCF cooler
3870x2, p5k/epu
750watts psu, antec 900
Reply to overshocks

overshocks wrote :

Sounds like you're a OCZ hater too. Why does OCZ suck? Provide evidence.



I had 3 bad sets of ram in the past 3 months. RMA-ing takes forever. They don't have anything in stock at their warehouse. They have
to ship from Taiwan. I've also had a Fatal1ty PSU go out on me in less than a year. The Fatal1ty PSU was in a computer that
doesn't even play games. One of the sets of RAM came out of one of my system that barely gets used at all (no overclock either).
I've read mixed reviews about their SSDs so I'm afraid the try them out.

I guess in the past year, I've had a lot of bad experience with OCZ. One thing I did like about them was that they do follow through on their
rebates pretty fast. Faster than any other company that issues rebates.

Reply to masterasia

Here is a middle option from MWave.com
You can choose the parts you want and they will assemble and test them for $80.

Think about using:
ASUS P6T (not deluxe) or GIGABYTE GA-EX58-UD3R
Antec 300 or CM RC-590 case

Reply to WR2

Case: CM HAF 932 or ANTEC 1200
MoBo: An upgrade to the Asus Rampage II Extreme would get you the Supreme Xi-Fi daughter card similar to what the Dell provides.
Powersupply: Corsair TX / Antec TP Series if single GFX / Corsair HX / Antec SG or CP Series if dual cards
Memory: Mushkin 98692 have low CAS timings for same price
Hard drive: The WD Black is fast in the 2 TB Model, 1 TB is slower. Any 500 GB per platter latest gen drive.
Video Card: Underpowered for rest of system ... see below

The 260 remains one of the few viable choices "value wise" for nVidia....then again DX 11 is here w/ ATI and it ain't for nVidia so you may want to consider that DX11 may come to be a factor 2-3 years down the road and instead grab a DX11 card if you don't wanna upgrade within 2 years or so. Then again if you like PhysX effects (see the Batman w/ PhysX review over at firingsquad.com), nVidia remains the only game in town.

Your budget leaves room for a monitor upgrade ... as much as I hate to give money to dell, the 2408WFP (S-PVA panel $450) and U2410 (IPS panel $550) remain two of the few affordable non TN panels around.

Since you do photography, might want to consider spending $35 here:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6820176016


Message edited by JackNaylorPE on 11-01-2009 at 02:33:38 AM
------------------------------ If a man speaks in the forest and no woman hears him, is he still wrong ?
Reply to JackNaylorPE

There's a much larger difference than $100 in those two component lists.

The Newegg build has a better PSU, better memory, better harddrive, better motherboard, better optical drive, and I wouldn't be suprised if the case wasn't arguably better as well.

As far as "support" and "warranties" goes, I do hope you realize each of the individual components you buy come with a warranty (most of which are at or over a year -- full replacement, no questions asked, as well as online and/or phone support from each of the respective companies), and it's not like Dell has stellar over-the-phone customer service for any other problem you'd have.


Message edited by brockh on 10-31-2009 at 09:15:31 PM
Reply to brockh

What great feedback. I will attempt to summarize the sugegsted changes and post an updated config here. I, too, was thinking of the higher quality Divx 11 capable board with the savings and suggestions made above.
Thanks all.

Reply to varocketry

masterasia wrote :

I had 3 bad sets of ram in the past 3 months. RMA-ing takes forever. They don't have anything in stock at their warehouse. They have
to ship from Taiwan. I've also had a Fatal1ty PSU go out on me in less than a year. The Fatal1ty PSU was in a computer that
doesn't even play games. One of the sets of RAM came out of one of my system that barely gets used at all (no overclock either).
I've read mixed reviews about their SSDs so I'm afraid the try them out.

 

I guess in the past year, I've had a lot of bad experience with OCZ. One thing I did like about them was that they do follow through on their
rebates pretty fast. Faster than any other company that issues rebates.

 

That's too bad, I guess you were pretty unlucky. Well, that's just personal experiences and that you were the unlucky one out of the many. Some people could have experienced what you had experienced with other companies


Message edited by overshocks on 10-31-2009 at 11:41:11 PM
------------------------------ You can select me as Best Answer
e6400 oc'd 3.2ghz,CCF cooler
3870x2, p5k/epu
750watts psu, antec 900
Reply to overshocks

All:

Thanks for the prior feedback on a prospective build. I've received a number of comments that the X58 chipset MOBOs are not stable and to avoid the CoreI7 920 that I prefer. I'd appreciate comments from any of you.

And comments on the Radeon 5850 which is a strong perfomer and has Directx 11 support.

I'd appreciate one more round of comments especiaally if I've missed an important item for the build.

Processor: Intel Core i7-920 Bloomfield 2.66GHz LGA 1366 130W Quad-Core - $288.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16819115202
Motherboard: ASUS P6T Deluxe V2 LGA 1366 Intel X58 ATX Intel Motherboard - $414.98
http://www.newegg.com/Product/ComboDealDetails.aspx?ItemList=Combo.291021
RAM: CORSAIR XMS3 6GB (3 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) (6 gig RAM bundled)

Case: COOLER MASTER HAF 932 RC-932-KKN1-GP Black Steel ATX Full - $139.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811119160
Power Supply: CORSAIR CMPSU-850TX 850W ATX12V 2.2 / - $139.99
EPS12V 2.91 SLI Ready CrossFire Ready Active
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139009
CPU Cooler: COOLER MASTER Intel Core i7 V8 RR-UV8-XBU1-GP 120mm Rifle - $49.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16835103055
Harddrives: WD Caviar Black WD6401AALS 640GB 7200 SATA 3.0Gb/s (qty:2) - $149.98
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822136319
Video Card: DIAMOND 5850PE51G Radeon HD 5850 1GB 256-bit GDDR5 PCI - $309.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814103085
Keyboard - Microsoft Comfort Curve Keyboard 2000 - $17.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Prod [...] 6823109149
SOund Card: Internal to motherboard

Speakers: Logitech S-220 17 Watts 2.1 Multimedia Speaker - $23.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16836121014
CD/DVD Burner: PLEXTOR Black 24X DVD+R 2MB Cache SATA 24X DVD/CD Writer - $52.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16827249054

--------
$1588.88

Thanks very much for your thoughts and comments.
I'm ready to buy this from NEWEGG so my son and I can build over Thanksgiving.

Reply to varocketry

To all the people hating on Dell XPS 9000 - yes it does suck badly when comparing to custom built high-end desktops, but you must also understand that there is a huge population of users who are not geeky to the extreme, and simply use the computer just for the sake of using it, without worrying too much on performance and other aspects. As a computer user myself who happens to play games casually, I wouldn't even need half of the quality of some of these custom-made desktop specs. If you're not experienced in building your own desktop, I recommend you buy one from dell, preferably the 8000/90000 series. It is seriously in the rankings of middle/higher end desktops and I think people are setting the bars too high for the mainstream users. If you're worried about the PSU, you shouldn't be because it works very smoothly and it will easily be able to handle gtx 260. The 8000/9000 series will definitely last you for 2-4 years.

All I'm saying is, don't get too hyped about aiming for high-end desktops, because we will always eventually replace it with better models; just lay back on your chair and let the renowned retailers build it for you if you're not too experienced - you save alot buying rather than build too ;)

Reply to hkfosho

hkfosho wrote :

To all the people hating on Dell XPS 9000 - yes it does suck badly when comparing to custom built high-end desktops, but you must also understand that there is a huge population of users who are not geeky to the extreme, and simply use the computer just for the sake of using it, without worrying too much on performance and other aspects. As a computer user myself who happens to play games casually, I wouldn't even need half of the quality of some of these custom-made desktop specs. If you're not experienced in building your own desktop, I recommend you buy one from dell, preferably the 8000/90000 series. It is seriously in the rankings of middle/higher end desktops and I think people are setting the bars too high for the mainstream users. If you're worried about the PSU, you shouldn't be because it works very smoothly and it will easily be able to handle gtx 260. The 8000/9000 series will definitely last you for 2-4 years.

All I'm saying is, don't get too hyped about aiming for high-end desktops, because we will always eventually replace it with better models; just lay back on your chair and let the renowned retailers build it for you if you're not too experienced - you save alot buying rather than build too ;)



The point was never to "hate" on the components (well, maybe some of it), but they just cost too much. If you're open to building one you can spend the same amount of money and get a lot more which will last you longer, it's simple. If not, you have no other option but to buy a prebuilt one. There is no arguing between the value of building it yourself and buying one -- building it yourself will net a better computer. My first build took two or three hours. I'd say it was well worth it.

Reply to brockh

hkfosho wrote :

To all the people hating on Dell XPS 9000 - yes it does suck badly when comparing to custom built high-end desktops, but you must also understand that there is a huge population of users who are not geeky to the extreme, and simply use the computer just for the sake of using it, without worrying too much on performance and other aspects. As a computer user myself who happens to play games casually, I wouldn't even need half of the quality of some of these custom-made desktop specs. If you're not experienced in building your own desktop, I recommend you buy one from dell, preferably the 8000/90000 series. It is seriously in the rankings of middle/higher end desktops and I think people are setting the bars too high for the mainstream users. If you're worried about the PSU, you shouldn't be because it works very smoothly and it will easily be able to handle gtx 260. The 8000/9000 series will definitely last you for 2-4 years.

All I'm saying is, don't get too hyped about aiming for high-end desktops, because we will always eventually replace it with better models; just lay back on your chair and let the renowned retailers build it for you if you're not too experienced - you save alot buying rather than build too ;)



First off you have the wrong point of view. You do not have to build a highend PC, you can build a PC at any end of the spectrum of computers and inbetween. That Is the main point of building your own PC, you choose the parts and with any reasonable budget you can get the most out of your money. On the other hand all the PC from the retailers are pre-built, lack quality hardware, pushing of the limits of the parts just so it is stable enough to be sold (nothing more, hopefully nothing less), more expensive price, no real upgradability path, and limited customization.

Second, building a computer is EASY, I built my first gaming rig a little over a month ago and it was sooo much easier then I thought it would be. An hour putting it together, then 1.5 hours for cable management :/, and then like 30-45min to install OS and I was done, no complications at all. I even taught 2 other friends to build their own PCs. I even took it apart last week to install the cooler, tbh once you build a computer once, it feels natural and less stressful! Of course their's the stress if something goes wrong, but from what I've heard the RMA process is much better then indian customer service!

My opinion is, alienwares, dells and all those other expensive pre-built computers are for either A) console kids who are rich and just get their parents to buy them a PC B) People who like to treat themselves, or others for something C) People who are just rich enough to not give ashit they are getting Ripped off! Other then that I honestly see no legit reason to buy pre-built.
Third,

Reply to impaledmango
Tom's Hardware > Forum > Homebuilt Systems > New System Build > First Time Prospective Core I7 Builder vs Dell XPS 9000 Core I7
Go to:

There are 1095 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Sponsored links
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
  • 01:00 Ckaz won the Freshman badge
  • 01:00 james59 won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 snarl won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 patlabor44 won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 Kiren won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 WookinPaNub won the Uniformed badge
  • 01:00 kwadams won the Uniformed badge
  • 21:57 brockh won the Sophmore badge
  • 01:00 xpax won the Freshman badge
  • 01:00 Mizoguchi won the Freshman badge