GA-X58A-UD3R - AHCI \ I DE Benefit ?

[4l3x]

Hello to everyone

i got 2 situation that regarding my Q?s :

in a system with windows 7 64bit - what is the benefit of AHCI over IDE ?

and in case i want to make a multiboot W7 64bit & XP SP3 - is it possible to use AHCI and the boot louder will load the OS's correctly ?

in general what is the benefit of AHCI over IDE ?

Thanks in advanced

 

[bilbat]

For my money, the biggest advantage of AHCI over IDE is the availability of hot-plug for eSATA ports; i.e., you can plug in a drive, and have it 'discovered' by the OD immediately, without having to do a reboot to have it recognized - and, be aware, AHCI drives appear in the 'Safely Remove' list - you must do this before disconnecting, as it flushes the disk buffer from memory to the drive - if you fail to do this, you run the risk of corruption. If you are using an SSD, it also (at least, in the Intel ICH implementation) 'passes-through' seven's TRIM commands to optimize the drive.

As far as actual performance gains (it also enables drives' NCQ - native comand queueing - see the Sorting Out SATA topic in the 'sticky' - I haven't been able to see a significant difference. Here are some thorough AHCI performance figures...

The win boot loader thing is just a mess. It should work, it can work - but, unfortunately, it often doesn't - or takes four tries to get it right! ...And Xp is pretty much the major 'violator' - it has a bad habit of corrupting the boot loader files of later installations (Vista or Seven)! I always recommend using BootIt™ Next Generation - it's fast, easy to configure, flawless, and has great support - oh - and it's cheap! It has excellent disk partitioning tools built in, MBR diagnostics and editing - I run nine OS's off three RAID pair:

and never a 'bobble'!

 

[4l3x]

bilbat - i wanna to say thank u so much for ur support - i did axeact what u offer here and its all running smoth - both xp sp3 and win 7 ul 64bit on all ports (intel - gigabyte - marvel - all set to AHCI - from wiki+dev333 idea : http://www.tomshardware.co.uk/forum/274987-12-solved-running-x58a-ud3r-ahci-mode-winxp-bsod
and the star of the day BOOTIT amazing tools there easy to use and with the vids on http://www.terabyteunlimited.com/howto/index.htm it never was so easy !!!

Thank u Mr.Bilbat & Mr.Dev333 for spinning ur heads faster then sound =)

 

[bilbat]

Always

!

I absolutely love BootIt - just the other day a buddy called up who was trying to fix up an older machine, and the installer was only seeing a quarter of the drive. Went over with a BootIt CD; it told me his MBR was corrupted; in all of a minute and a half, I had installed, fixed the MBR, uninstalled - and he was ready to go - and fairly awed