I just had a look at the manual for the Sabertooth Z77, and I was slightly wrong anyway. It's different than the BIOS on my Asus Z68 board.
The Turbo Ratio needs to be set to "Manual" (which I think you've done). Then set "1 Core Ratio Limit" to "Manual" and then 39. After that, set the others to Manual, as well, then set them like I said above.
So, "1 Core Ratio Limit" set to "Manual" and 39, "2 Core Ratio Limit" set to "Manual" and 39 or 38, "3 Core Ratio Limit" set to "Manual" and 37 and finally "4 Core Ratio Limit" set to "Manual" and 36.
And according to the manual, "Synchronizing Control" needs to be Enabled.