Download the Tom's Hardware App from the App Store
The reference for current tech news
Yes No
Ads

Acrylic Cases and EMI

Forum CPU & Components : Power Supplies, Cases & Mods Acrylic Cases and EMI

Related Content
Can't find your answer?
Ask!
Word :    Username :           
 

Hello,

I just recently ordered an Acrylic case to put together a computer with some parts I had just laying around from my last build. However, I perused on the internet today and found out that these cases do no adequately shield EMI and can play havoc with other nearby electronics. How true is this and how can I mitigate the EMI? Will I just have to buy another case?

Reply to nx74205
Register or log in to remove.

What are you worried about? Are you EMI sensitive?

Reply to vvhocare5

well just dont put it right next to ur monitor if its one of the old crt types. it may cause interference like maybe if u stick a wifi router right next to it. but since many people put their comps on the floor next to them it doenst really matter. ps: :)

Reply to shovenose

No sweat, give and take - it not only sends out emi (radiated emissions) there is also susceptibility to EMI.

Most likely no problems. Remember the strength of the field varies inversely proportional to the Sqaure of distance.

Reply to RetiredChief

you can reduce EMI interference by enabling "Spread Spectrum" in the BIOS, usually there is an option for both the CPU and Mobo. Most motherboard BIOS have this option as stated by the FCC regulation.
This option allows the oscillator to spread EMI frequencies over a larger spectrum thus to reduce the spectral density of the electromagnetic interference (EMI) that these systems generate.


Message edited by arterius2 on 05-20-2010 at 05:54:12 AM
Reply to arterius2

shovenose wrote :

thats what spread sepctrum does? cool!


yes, it's pretty neat... if you work for the CIA or something. (These guys are pretty sensitive about their equipment)


Message edited by arterius2 on 05-20-2010 at 03:13:17 PM
Reply to arterius2

Thanks everyone for your responses...so basically i have nothing to worry about which is cool..

Reply to nx74205

RetiredChief wrote :

No sweat, give and take - it not only sends out emi (radiated emissions) there is also susceptibility to EMI.

Most likely no problems. Remember the strength of the field varies inversely proportional to the Sqaure of distance.



Do you know the exact equation.....just curious.I don't remember from my physics 2 class..

Reply to nx74205

Almost ALL commercial computer cases today actually have an invisible electrically-conductive coating sprayed on the inside. Although it is not as good as a solid metal case, it substantially reduces the penetration of electromagnetic noise signals through the case. This means BOTH noise going out from your mobo and components, and noise entering from outside. If you get a case of whatever material (acrylic or not) that does NOT have this feature, you are risking more problems from such noise.

"Spread Spectrum" on mobo's apparently refers to a way that the clock pulses (and some data) are formed and used. Clock pulses normally are nearly square waves, and this means they contain some significant high-frequency harmonics of the base clock rate. These can manifest themselves as noise sent out of your computer. Setting the Spread Spectrum option limits this effect by sort of "rounding off" the square corners of the signals. The result in some cases MAY be that the system does not work so well if you are trying to run near the edge of performance by overclocking, etc. For most systems run under stock conditions it ought not to create a problem. HOWEVER, this only deals with half the problem - the noise sent out of your machine. It does nothing to protect your mobo from outside noise sources.

Reply to Paperdoc

Paperdoc wrote :

Almost ALL commercial computer cases today actually have an invisible electrically-conductive coating sprayed on the inside. Although it is not as good as a solid metal case, it substantially reduces the penetration of electromagnetic noise signals through the case. This means BOTH noise going out from your mobo and components, and noise entering from outside. If you get a case of whatever material (acrylic or not) that does NOT have this feature, you are risking more problems from such noise.

"Spread Spectrum" on mobo's apparently refers to a way that the clock pulses (and some data) are formed and used. Clock pulses normally are nearly square waves, and this means they contain some significant high-frequency harmonics of the base clock rate. These can manifest themselves as noise sent out of your computer. Setting the Spread Spectrum option limits this effect by sort of "rounding off" the square corners of the signals. The result in some cases MAY be that the system does not work so well if you are trying to run near the edge of performance by overclocking, etc. For most systems run under stock conditions it ought not to create a problem. HOWEVER, this only deals with half the problem - the noise sent out of your machine. It does nothing to protect your mobo from outside noise sources.



um... actually no, spread spectrum looks something like this graphically:

Without Spread Spectrum
http://zone.ni.com/cms/images/devzone/tut/a/98656ce2570.gif

With Spread Spectrum
http://zone.ni.com/cms/images/devzone/tut/a/98656ce2571.gif

In short, Spread Spectrum spreads EMI across wider range of frequencies. your whole "rounding off corners of boxes" concept didnt really make much sense. and spread spectrum usually impede OC capabilities.


Message edited by arterius2 on 05-20-2010 at 09:17:03 PM
Reply to arterius2

reply to NX74205
Extract from
http://www.osha.gov/SLTC/radiofreq [...] netic.html
"The inverse-square law is defined as: "A statement that the strength of a field due to a point source or the irradiance from a point source decreases as the square of the distance from the source. Note: For sources of finite size this gives results that are accurate within one-half percent when distance is at least five times the maximum dimension of the source (or luminaire) as viewed by the observer."

There are some other considerations, ie the frequence as it relates to the wavelenght of the "E" field.

Reply to RetiredChief

Paperdoc wrote :

Almost ALL commercial computer cases today actually have an invisible electrically-conductive coating sprayed on the inside. Although it is not as good as a solid metal case, it substantially reduces the penetration of electromagnetic noise signals through the case. This means BOTH noise going out from your mobo and components, and noise entering from outside. If you get a case of whatever material (acrylic or not) that does NOT have this feature, you are risking more problems from such noise.

"Spread Spectrum" on mobo's apparently refers to a way that the clock pulses (and some data) are formed and used. Clock pulses normally are nearly square waves, and this means they contain some significant high-frequency harmonics of the base clock rate. These can manifest themselves as noise sent out of your computer. Setting the Spread Spectrum option limits this effect by sort of "rounding off" the square corners of the signals. The result in some cases MAY be that the system does not work so well if you are trying to run near the edge of performance by overclocking, etc. For most systems run under stock conditions it ought not to create a problem. HOWEVER, this only deals with half the problem - the noise sent out of your machine. It does nothing to protect your mobo from outside noise sources.



Thanks for the info...how can I find out if my case was sprayed with this coating?

Reply to nx74205

arterius2, you did not understand what I said. If you analyze a square wave using a Fourier transform, you find that it actually is composed of the sum of an infinite series of sine waves. The lowest-frequency component is the fundamental square wave frequency; added to it are progressively smaller proportions of the harmonics of that. In effect, broadcasting a square wave amounts to sending out many frequencies, not one. But if the square wave generated is altered so that its higher frequencies are reduced in amplitude (attenuated), that "noise" at higher frequencies is removed. The appearance of the "square" wave so formed is less square, especially at its sharp "corners" where the transition from one state to another occurs. That is why I used the phrase "rounding off". However, this has two impacts on the signal and on circuits that use it for a clock (timing) signal. One is that the transitions from on to off, or the other way, are no longer almost instantaneous - they now actually take enough time to affect the way a digital circuit changes state. Further, it also means that the square wave spends less time in a single stable state (on or off), so any work a circuit does that depends on how long the "on" state lasts may be affected. As we agree, that can impact operations of circuits that are being pushed to their performance limits, such as when one overclocks the computer.

Reply to Paperdoc

OP, you should contact the manufacturer of the case you want to use and ask them what they have done to reduce EMI interference reaching the computer mounted inside, and its impact on surrounding devices. There are FCC regulations for this, and they may be able to tell you that their case does or does not meet FCC regs for EMI interference. Truth is, you don't care exactly what they've done if the FCC requirements are being met.

 

Of course, you can just not worry about this question - your choice. You just need to understand the risks, maybe just small risks, of using a case without this feature.


Message edited by Paperdoc on 05-21-2010 at 04:09:28 PM
Reply to Paperdoc

Paperdoc wrote :

arterius2, you did not understand what I said. If you analyze a square wave using a Fourier transform, you find that it actually is composed of the sum of an infinite series of sine waves. The lowest-frequency component is the fundamental square wave frequency; added to it are progressively smaller proportions of the odd harmonics of that.


If it makes any difference. :)

Reply to jsc

jsc, thanks. I thought I recalled that it was only the odd harmonics, but was not sure if that was square wave or another waveform. Don't have my old reference books here to check.

Reply to Paperdoc

Yes "If we continue with this series, adding a sine wave at 5 times the frequency and 1/5th the amplitude, 7 times the frequency and 1/7th the amplitude and so on up to 31 times the frequency (and 1/31 the amplitude) you get a waveform that looks like Figure 9.4. "

Figure 9.4 = sq wave

Reply to RetiredChief
Register or log in to remove.
Tom's Hardware > Forum > CPU & Components > Power Supplies, Cases & Mods > Acrylic Cases and EMI
Go to:

There are 1780 identified and unidentified users. To see the list of identified users, Click here.

Please mind

You are about to answer a thread that has been inactive for more than 6 months.
If you still wish to proceed, please ensure that your posting is original and does not duplicate or overlap any prior responses to this thread.

Add a reply Cancel
  • Ask the community now
  • Publish
Ad
Ads
Latest best answer
Case with filters. Recommendations?
By al360ex, 3 hours ago:

Then I'd go with one of these cases. If you choose the HAF 932 Advanced Edition, you...

Best offers
They won a badge
Join us in greeting them
Top experts