Solved

1tb hd recommendation

Hello all,

I'm looking for a new 2 1tb hd for complete my raid5 setup, I have 2 samsung HD103SJ (originals) currently.
as the samsung hd devision was sold to seagate and the new HD103SJ are a rebranded ST1000DM005 it is hard to find original HD103SJs and when I do, they are quite expensive.

I'd like a recommendation to a hd model which is good and won't be a bottleneck to my current existing hds.

Thanks for your help.
11 answers Last reply Best Answer
More about recommendation
  1. I prefer identical drives if possible, Amazon seems to have them for $102 plus shipping: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002MQC0P8 (or http://www.amazon.co.uk/Samsung-HD103SJ-internal-SATAII-7200RPM/dp/B002MQC0P8 in the UK)
  2. Are you sure the ST1000DM005 is not just a Seagate name for the Samsung drive, it does not exist in Seagate's lineup. http://www.seagate.com/search/?keyword=ST1000dm005
    I belief we are still talking about the Samsung drive here rebranded over to Seagate.
  3. RealBeast said:
    I prefer identical drives if possible, Amazon seems to have them for $102 plus shipping: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002MQC0P8 (or http://www.amazon.co.uk/Samsung-HD103SJ-internal-SATAII-7200RPM/dp/B002MQC0P8 in the UK)

    as I'm not living in the us, ordering the drives from amazon/newegg/ebay is irrelevant as if one of them is dead, I have no address almost to get a replacement, also the postage fee in such case will make it not worth it.

    rolli59 said:
    Are you sure the ST1000DM005 is not just a Seagate name for the Samsung drive, it does not exist in Seagate's lineup. http://www.seagate.com/search/?keyword=ST1000dm005
    I belief we are still talking about the Samsung drive here rebranded over to Seagate.

    I don't know, the ST1000DM005 in my country is significantly less expensive.
  4. ok,
    so I'm down to 3 drives:

    1. the original samsung spinpoint f3 which costs 154$ and has 1 year warranty.
    2. the rebranded ST1000DM005 spinpoint f3 by seagate (I know it is a rebranded as the original has two plates of 0.5 gb and the rebranded one of 1 tb) which costs 120$ and has 1 year warranty.
    3. a Hitachi DeskStar 7K1000.D which costs between 127$ to 141$ with 3 years warranty.

    any recommendations?

    Thanks.
  5. I'd go with the rebranded ST1000DM005, as out of hundreds of bare drives (excluding laptop drives) in my personal experience I have not had one fail in the one to three year range. They either fail very soon -- I expect many due to shipping trauma -- or later than 3 years.
  6. RealBeast said:
    I'd go with the rebranded ST1000DM005, as out of hundreds of bare drives (excluding laptop drives) in my personal experience I have not had one fail in the one to three year range. They either fail very soon -- I expect many due to shipping trauma -- or later than 3 years.

    are you sure you aren't mistaken with the 003? the 005 is a brand new line of drives following the samsung hd devision acquisition by seagate.
  7. Best answer
    And produced at the Old Samsung product facilities. Next iteration will only be Seagate since no desktop drives anymore on Samsung's website nor the Seagate site http://samsunghdd.seagate.com/
  8. rolli59 said:
    And produced at the Old Samsung product facilities. Next iteration will only be Seagate since no desktop drives anymore on Samsung's website nor the Seagate site http://samsunghdd.seagate.com/

    I see, so your recommendation is to get the ST1000DM005, right?
  9. daggs said:
    I see, so your recommendation is to get the ST1000DM005, right?

    Yes.
  10. ok, thanks.
  11. Best answer selected by Daggs.
Ask a new question

Read More

Hard Drives HD Samsung Storage