So the voltage was set to auto, and I couldn't tell what it was setting it to, so I just manually set it to 1.5V. I was able to get past the user creation step and get into Windows, but while I was trying to download my videocard drivers, Windows was saying something like, the system has had an error and needs to shut down.
So then I tried to set my timing again, and this time I was able to get it to come up after I set the timing. What's weird is, when I hit f5 in the BIOS, it still says my timing is 9-9-9-24 even though I have it set as 8-8-8-24.
I ran memtest again and it passed without any errors! Wonderful!
So I figure I'd start from fresh and reinstall windows with these new settings. While it was trying to extract the files it gave me this BSOD and stopped: