I'm trying to decide which 3TB drive to buy. The WD is a bit more expensive, but has a 3 yr warranty compared to the Seagate 1 yr. I'm not worried about performance, and i'm not too worried bout power efficiency, however noise is a factor.
I get the feeling the WD is better, but I just wanted a trusted second opinion.
I would buy the Seagate myself, there is a difference in these 2 drives that may be worth mentioning to you.
Both are know to be very reliable products.
The Western digital Green series are power saving drives, they will spin down during periods of inactivity to save power, causing a bit of a lag at times when you go back to using them. Not a big deal, but it is what it is. It is a 5400rpm drive.
The Seagate drive is more of a performance series drive, so it is not quite as miserly to operate as the Western Digital. It is a 7200rpm drive, which makes it quite a bit faster and more responsive than the WD Green drive.
Don't know if any of that matters, but that is the major difference in these.
well, i've been running 4 1tb 5400rpm WD green drives in raid 5 config for storage for about 4 years now, still going stong and silent.
personally i've had much better luck with WD than seagate, others will say the opposite.
again, with 3yr warranty and 5400rpm, the WD wins on both noise and reliability fronts.