Yes! Here we are, the inevitable repeat of the ATI 5850 vs nVidia GTX 470 post.
I upgraded my monitor (2048 x 1152 res) this past Christmas and have been thinking of a GPU upgrade (from an 8800GT) for a bit. I've been on the fence (and I'm still willing to sit here for a little) waiting for Fermi to see how the GPU field plays out. And unlike some, I think the GTX 470 came out strong. A little hot and the drivers premature, but eventually I think driver updates may let the 470 pull ahead of/match the more mature 5870. Hopeful thinking, but I think possible.
I'm currently running an Intel E8200 OC'd to 3.6 with 4 GB of RAM. The mobo has an Intel P35 northbridge, giving me a PCI-e 1.1 16x slot(like a PCI-e 2.0 x8 slot), so I wouldn't expect a major bandwidth/bottleneck problem with either card.
My main concern will be running Star Craft 2 maxed out, if you have a beta key chime in with performance. I have no brand loyalty (Matrox, 3DFX, ATI, nVidia, I've used them all) and I'm just interested in the best GPU for the $$$. I also want this upgrade to last me 2 ~ 3 years before I do a complete re-build.
I'm currently leaning towards a GTX 470 since it has a little more power, but I'm not shy of doing a little OC'ing and letting the 5850 run on some of the non-reference cards with better cooling. Price between the 2 is a moot point, I'm just curious about the performance people have gotten out of either card.
What do you guys recommend?
I upgraded my monitor (2048 x 1152 res) this past Christmas and have been thinking of a GPU upgrade (from an 8800GT) for a bit. I've been on the fence (and I'm still willing to sit here for a little) waiting for Fermi to see how the GPU field plays out. And unlike some, I think the GTX 470 came out strong. A little hot and the drivers premature, but eventually I think driver updates may let the 470 pull ahead of/match the more mature 5870. Hopeful thinking, but I think possible.
I'm currently running an Intel E8200 OC'd to 3.6 with 4 GB of RAM. The mobo has an Intel P35 northbridge, giving me a PCI-e 1.1 16x slot(like a PCI-e 2.0 x8 slot), so I wouldn't expect a major bandwidth/bottleneck problem with either card.
My main concern will be running Star Craft 2 maxed out, if you have a beta key chime in with performance. I have no brand loyalty (Matrox, 3DFX, ATI, nVidia, I've used them all) and I'm just interested in the best GPU for the $$$. I also want this upgrade to last me 2 ~ 3 years before I do a complete re-build.
I'm currently leaning towards a GTX 470 since it has a little more power, but I'm not shy of doing a little OC'ing and letting the 5850 run on some of the non-reference cards with better cooling. Price between the 2 is a moot point, I'm just curious about the performance people have gotten out of either card.
What do you guys recommend?