HTPC AMD-build... which mobo Asus vs. Gigabyte?

I am building a mid-range HTPC mATX with Athlon X4 and am still confused as to the best mobo betwee Asus and Gigabyte?!

Which of these two you recommend?

Gigabyte 880:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128445

Asus 880:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131654

They are very very similar, but it comes down to pretty much brand... I've had both in the past with no issues, but at least from marketing perspective, it looks like Gigabyte is building better boards now, with 2oz Copper, better Japanese capacitors, etc... while at the same time Asus *might* have a better BIOS?!

Any help is appreciated!!!

Cheers!

PS. There's also this MSI board (890)... better video, but older audio chip! Not sure about the MSI brand though.

MSI 890:
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813130269
4 answers Last reply
More about htpc build mobo asus gigabyte
  1. MSI is a highly respected brand all-around this world, with some great products.

    Although both of these motherboards utilize the same chipset, I would personally opt for the Asus board because I've never had any issues with them and they're very reliable whereas the first and only Gigabyte motherboard I've ever had died after but 3 months!

    However I would take that MSI-890 board over the other 2.
  2. I'm much more of an MSI guy. Their boards are built like tanks, and everything I've owned of theirs has been absolutely rock solid. I'd set the list as follows:

    1 and 2. Asus and MSI
    3. Gigabyte
    4. BioStar
    5 and 6. ASRock and Foxconn
    7. Jetway. I'd avoid them at all costs.

    I know people will disagree with that, but that's just based on my personal experiences and reviews. Those are only motherboards, though... ;)
  3. Hey alex, I see you're still struggling with your motherboard decision.

    Asus, Gigabyte, and MSI are pretty much on everybody's top 3 list here. The order of that top 3 list will vary from one person to another though because you'll always find someone who had a bad experience at one time with one of them and they'll rate it lower because of it. Really, you can't go wrong with any of them.

    At this point you've narrowed down the choice to 3 very nice motherboards. I think the MSI has the edge with the better video on the 890GX, though it does cost $30 more because of it. Don't worry about the audio on the MSI. It still has a nice audio chip and if you are going to be sending your audio digitally over HDMI or S/PDIF to a receiver then it doesn't matter anyway.

    Toyota, Honda, or Nissan? They're all pretty good.
    Asus, Gigabyte, or MSI? They're all pretty good.

    At this point just pick the one that "looks pretty" since they'll all do exactly what you want them to do :lol:

    Maybe check out their respective websites and see which one you like the layout better... who has the easiest to find downloads, etc.
  4. rwpritchett said:
    Hey alex, I see you're still struggling with your motherboard decision.

    Asus, Gigabyte, and MSI are pretty much on everybody's top 3 list here. The order of that top 3 list will vary from one person to another though because you'll always find someone who had a bad experience at one time with one of them and they'll rate it lower because of it. Really, you can't go wrong with any of them.

    At this point you've narrowed down the choice to 3 very nice motherboards. I think the MSI has the edge with the better video on the 890GX, though it does cost $30 more because of it. Don't worry about the audio on the MSI. It still has a nice audio chip and if you are going to be sending your audio digitally over HDMI or S/PDIF to a receiver then it doesn't matter anyway.

    Toyota, Honda, or Nissan? They're all pretty good.
    Asus, Gigabyte, or MSI? They're all pretty good.

    At this point just pick the one that "looks pretty" since they'll all do exactly what you want them to do :lol:

    Maybe check out their respective websites and see which one you like the layout better... who has the easiest to find downloads, etc.


    Yup, am still stuck! :)

    Any BIOS difference between the three? I might go with MSI then, cause it's got better video and if I don't do too much gaming (still debating PC vs. PS3/Xbox), might just be fine.
Ask a new question

Read More

Motherboards Asus Gigabyte Product